us very probably consciously that the valid contracts are insufficient and must another , more efficient structure for the union be developed in the future , i .e . a more strongly constitutionally minted structure with a clear demarcation between the powers of the member states and the authority of the union is . it concerns first messages of the uneasiness in view of the economic and social difficulties , with which we are confronted despite a continuous growth as result of efforts for many years on the part of all of our fellow citizens . current situation , which must for many independent transport enterprises , for which agriculture is intolerable , in any case is particularly improved . the communication over the procedures is actually good , but it must be carried for the fact concern that the system not when political impact weapon can be used . also they have now the rights clearly in the view , which must keep them . i agree with its warning of one for some appearing enticing return to the methods of government co-operation . many of us aim at a federation of national states . this implies also that everyone finds its correct place . the correspondents emphasized and also the level of the discussion the necessity to go still further . i can naturally only agree them . the latters i would like to say that one studies the forces involved before a speech , with them to make themselves familiar and her weigh must , because a political speech must be always realistic and always consider the force situation and the objectives of us all . i would like that we set in this intensified co-operation , in order to supply some examples of the new efficiency of europe . the tuning takes place today at 12 .30 o'clock . request for modification 12 must reject the commission . i will be correct for the acceptance of the regulation draft . thus in the reports of the european audit office constantly such to low data one refers to , which occur again and again from greece to portugal . we were not correct therefore for this report . according to the proponents are not only more cheaply and world-wide applicable such penalty , but also in as much more pollution free as their fuel consumption per passenger is smaller . the report calls besides for the definition of bench mark with view of the spreading of the best practices in the european union . an obligatory and all-comprehensive charter also in-complainable rights could lead to a later time to difficulties . i thank both for its great employment . we do not believe however that it can be locked after less than three months in nice . however already for this reason we cannot be correct to take up the charter with the summit to nice to the contract . the csu europagruppe welcomes that with the available conclusion draft of the fundamental right charter those are summarized the citizens in relation to the organs and mechanisms of the european union of being entitled fundamental rights and made visible . it is an image of the liberal of europe understood in emergence . because i would have wished the fact that on this charter still one continues to work as suggested this numerous nichtregierungsorganisationen from different countries of the union . (a5-0248/2000) of mr . queiró to hungary [ kom (1999) 505 - c5-0028/2000 - 1997/2175 (cos) ] ; therefore i would like to also suggest to you that we submit no more general report , but only reports on the situation in the countries as parliament in the next year , in order to make clear that we provide for a differentiated continuation of the negotiations . it continues to seem to me that the french presidency on the basis of the work of the preceding presidencies and the commission will be able - at least i hope this - , to give on the european advice of nice a quite exact overview of the entry process . as i already said and to repeat here would like , the french presidency will not evade of the arising difficulties , what does not mean naturally that we have the time and the possibility of discussing fully each of these difficulties . this question is naturally perfectly understandable , but must be answered to it appropriate and precise . it represents a large perspective , which we must concern with grossherzigkeit and distance vision . not each result of the diplomatic conference became fair the enormous adjustment pressure of the extension . the second large change , which we experience and to europe stop ourselves must , is the rapid acceleration of the economic development to the global market and to the global competition . fourth: from it it results as the further principle that the states , which began later have a fair chance to unlock to those which began in former times . where large and long-term investments are necessary , in order to reach european union standards , should be considered that also the current members took long transition periods in these cases in requirement . to border safety device and crime prevention likewise our standards and the advantages of european co-operation apply . we regard nevertheless the present commercial exchange between the european union and central and eastern european countries . fortunately the mr . kommissar communicated finally , the fears , of which one spoke , to the citizens is unfounded for the first time now . but one is clear - and i welcome it that mr . verheugen underlined that again: a transition period for the adherence to democratic rules cannot give it . in addition we need the assistance of the commission , because it is missing to us with all determination sometimes at the appropriate ammunition . that is necessary , so that we can place ourselves as european union of goals of bringing the internal reforms to the conclusion . but there are important aspects and questions , in which we are other opinion . this harms the european union , its future independence regarding north america as well as a common european defense and security politics , because it saves also dangers for the relationship to russia and other countries . we wish ourselves however results , and we want that what must be done in preparation on the extension is shifted not on another diplomatic conference . i will seize myself briefly , as i did this already a while ago , when i did not use three minutes of my speaking time with my first speech contribution . this is very important , and is very pleased over the fact i that the commission works on an information campaign , which is to be accomplished after the words by commissioner hay gene both comprehensively and decentralized . but - and this is my last word , because i would like that this is completely clear: i am not a pessimist in this question , i set on time , i want a clear statement in favor of the extension - , in order to be reliable , must one remain serious , do not have one be understood , must one the agreement of the peoples , which peoples of the candidate countries like also our peoples , to win being able . i do not see a necessity momentary to talk in connection with the extension about the financial forecast . of none i can say it to you today ! for the same reason by the way they expressed also the desire to step the european union . we will give the word now to the individual correspondents . me the responsible task was transferred to submit the report over the request estlands for entry to the european union . as conservative one i deal very economically with the funds of the taxpayers . i believe , only then you would have a notion of it , which humans in lettland carried out in the last years . that is not sufficient , which must entire strategy more strongly to the citizens and citizens is aligned . litauen has a considerable potential for a long-term economic growth . in the broadest sense it concerns the co-operation of the european union with the russian federation . a further neuralgic point is the support of the public in and outside of the european union . as consequence of an intelligent tax policy the foreign direct investments amounted in the last year to more than 5 .45 billion euro . we should not interfere , already not at all we germans ! the slowakische democracy develops stably , and within this range we had here already experienced different one . in my speech contribution i will point out and will systematize the six aspects of the development of the situation in hungary , which are under the point of view of the entry to the union of importance . therefore i am glad that this topic was taken up to the general report of the mr . abgeordneten brok over the extension . that applies probably to no more range than to the range of the nuclear power , where the danger exists that the lobby of the nuclear power opponents usurps the legitimate doubts regarding nuclear security and environmental protection for their own purposes . i would like to recommend the endorsement of the education of a high-ranking group to my colleagues . the report , which was accepted likewise unanimously in the committee , comes to the conclusion the fact that the part of the national territory , which is subordinate to the legal authorities , which fulfills political criteria of copenhagen . the key role comes to our high representative for the gasp , javier solana , about which the own role of the commission remains naturally unaffected . hauptproblem of malta consists however still of the fact that the entry process is judged by government and opposition differently and the european union value on the fact puts that this entry process runs continuously . even between the usa and mexico the levels lie together more closely . therefore we exert ourselves in the range of the domestic market for a considered , flexible and the challenge appropriate strategy . i may say in the place in addition , that i have respect for the citizens and citizen in central and eastern european countries , which had the courage before ten years to go on the road and this process in course to have also brought . the information society is important for the old as for the new industry . we may also not by the percentages of into domestic legislation converted community law to be dazzled be able . the 10 new eastern european countries do not have to exhibit such an rich hereditary uncle . that applies equally to - beneath human dignity - the transport of living animals to the slaughterhouses . now we work on a regulation , which is to plan for all important legal instrument an estimation of the health consequences . in my statement it must be dealt also with the european union and made clear that the european funds for the regional development may be granted not further on the basis of a purely buchhalterischen distribution under the regions and areas . elmar brok introduced its speech with the reference to it rightfully that we all the beneficiaries of the extension will be , in the special also we on this side of the present external border . inland waterway craft traffic will be important for environmental reasons , because we must get bulk goods away from the road , and if we cannot transport them on the rail , then we must use water ways . also egoism and not least populismus played a role , and that falling euro course did not surely also affect the result positively . our message to the entry candidates reads: do not let by the extent of the available reports and documents irritate itself . unfortunately at present too many parties have their ideological feathers/springs stripped with the consequence that they embody too few ideals and are too materialistic . if it should be necessary to suspend the free right to acquisition of properties and homes of one's own then we should do this . it is existent so far , however possibly becomes by bureaucratic intransparenz and the obvious , but public resistance of some governments does not endanger . where are the millions of jobs , which the maastrichter should bring to contract by the way? while we are still about to seize the contracts again demand some the next reform already . almost all international investigations point in connection with the extension on macro-economic profits . nevertheless the principal purpose of the slovenian policy - the earliest possible entry to the european union - is questioned apart from some insignificant minorities by no political grouping . if the extension of the union is rapidly carried out , that would take place to a considerable degree decentralized , how it formulated the parliamentary group of the eldr in its statement for extension . it became clear that the strictly arranged institute regime typical for the country has long-term consequences for the health of the waisenkinder . i ask for support of the appropriate requests . and even we , the european politicians , have too little view of the negotiation process . cyprus will function as it were as bridge to the countries of this region . i wish also further much success in this important area to the negotiators . a second kind of communication is naturally also important between our countries and the extension countries , in order to mediate , for which it goes with the european union . we cannot carry it for us out to lose still more from the momentum from the beginning of the 90's . mr . praesident , first i would like to congratulate as correspondents of the parliamentary group of the social-democratic party of europe for the report over romania of the berichterstatterin to its excellent product . for the institutions , for the member states , for us everything goes showing it therefore , us this challenge , in addition , the fears of our own public grown , and again the strength for finding the ambition and the vision strength of the founder fathers of europe . i have unfortunately the impression that this extension process is not advanced despite many beautiful words and despite industrious opening and closing of numerous chapters by the advice with the necessary political reproduction . many countries of the union had to fight and know at a certain time of its development with similar problems bulgaria advise , in order to help overcome the present problems . the democracy is not only a question of the majorities , but above all also a question of the appropriate joint decision of minorities . the applicant countries must be treated and their entry may only on their development be dependent . at the same time we should recognize , also as much employment countries as litauen try to make up for lost soil . to that extent it is appropriate in our interest to expand our on the right of and liberty system until romania and this is reliably in a critical debate with our public an argument . regarding a thing there however large agreement prevails , and that is the extension . my parliamentary group supports therefore the stipulation of a time limit of the transition periods within the environmental range on maximally five years . mr . praesident , we must absolutely bring a positive movement into the extension . of course is to be discussed still the order of the entry of the candidate countries , among other things because still the progress must be judged with the internal reforms . it makes me happy that the report so positively precipitates and that slovenia itself - and i could examine that several times as directors/conductors of the delegation , and the mr . kommissar was several times also thereby - really substantial exerted to fulfill the criteria . i consider the suggestion discussion worthy . these forms of the force and the woman trade are to be condemned already now with all means both in the european union and in the entry countries and fought . finally i would like to follow on this occasion the considerations and the concern of many colleagues , who consider it necessary to finally once in detail examine the question of the borders of europe and thus the range of its extension as well as the appropriateness of the development of a relevant report of the european parliament . - minutes of the preceding meeting were distributed . - thanks . in this house rightfully it is pointed out again and again that in europe of the citizens the citizen rights must be embodied in the right of the union . i place now the request for adjournment of the committee for right and domestic market to the tuning . we know that it acts very rarely with the unwanted material , which here it concerns around acutely toxic materials , but rather around , long-lived and accumulatable materials working on a long-term basis such as dioxin , aflatoxin and heavy metals such as cadmium , lead and mercury . we cannot make the suender today for no more . if one permits this blending , there must be at least one registration at the boards of control , and it must become public that there is this blending , because this problem must also in the public admits to be and be discussed . one must be put out clearly: the dioxin crisis was the result of criminal actions against existing regulations . mr . praesident ! thank you at the colleagues and colleagues , who spoke before me . this was a compelling necessity . the limit value for fish flour differs for example from the limit value , which is suggested for animal products not made of sea animals . it is to time that we this misleading design of the subsidiaritaetsprinzips , with which patronizing our nations is continued to develop by brussels daily an end to set . i am just like the berichterstatterin of the view that the suggested measures are justified and the specified substances must be controlled , even if these are taken not toxic for itself in the combination with other substances however increased values to exhibit . unfortunately much was lost at delivered knowledge , at healthy understanding of farmer into the industriellen agriculture , where the animals were reduced to production units and commodities . the very much detailed and complicated hygiene requirements , which were distributed on numerous guidelines , are united , harmonized and simplified by the new regulations . the number of those , which inquire the contents materials completely exactly , is loud means searches relatively small . secondly: a change results very probably however for the farmers , who are the producers of the feed basic products . they will have to destroy in the future substantially more portions of output products . the remuneration is necessary , although it is undisputed that the farmers also carry a large responsibility for the well-being being issued of the animals . in request for modification 18 is expressly demanded to take up water to the definition of feeds . on the basis of these scientific risk evaluations the commission will recommend suitable measures to the member states for the definition of limit values for these materials in feeds . after the examination of the requests for modification , which were submitted in this meeting , i welcome the support of the parliament for the suggestion . altogether the commission can approve of 15 of the 27 requests for modification . i assume that will have this time no success . the commission assured that it will work on it , and it also announced that it not until will be finished the day after tomorrow . the farmers must know completely simply times more exactly , at least on request also in percentage figures , which is to be contained everything and to which extent in these mixing feeds . in the end i would like to quite cordially thank and hope the correspondent , mr . graefe to baringdorf , and also mrs . roth roth-behrendt for its reports that the advice in this question takes a constructional attitude and we arrive so together at a transparent system of the feed declaration . all this we have to owe clearly to the bse tragedy , which developed to a genuine novel with several chapters . pollutants , which affect the health of humans and animal , are not acceptable . we begin however with that positives . the available suggestion is the beginning of a set of initiatives , which are based upon the white paper for food security . thank you , mr . kommissar . (the parliament accepts the resolution . ) report (a5-0248/2000) of mr . queiró in the name of the committee for foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defense policy over the request of hungary for entry to the european one union and the conditions of the negotiations (kom (1999) 505 - c5-0028/2000 - 1997/2175 (cos)) report (a5-0247/2000) of mrs . nicholson of winterbourne in the name of the committee for foreign affairs , human rights , common security and defense policy over the request of romania for entry to the european one union and the conditions of the negotiations (kom (1999) 510 - c5-0033/2000 - 1997/2171 (cos)) the third and perhaps most difficult condition is that the advice agrees on new institutional agreements , which guarantee the efficient , effective and democratic functioning of the community after the extension . for large europe rather such institutions must be planned , which promote the development of the east , but area for sovereignty and differences at the same time to leave . this outstanding principle should apply by the way also within the european union . finally i would like to stress that the extension process must take place gradually and in conformity with the adjustment progress of the applicant countries . in the current context and in view of the voices , which are to be heard recently and which are the extension of the european union in question to place , it importantly that this parliament sets a clear political signal for this extension . the european union serves the unification of the peoples since its establishment . the criteria of the advice of copenhagen from 1993 to the democratization or to the competitive ability strengthen under the cover of the "joint possession conditions" the rule of a ungezuegelten and destructive capitalism . under these circumstances an escape could lead forward with the extension process to an increase of the populist and faschistoiden excrescences , which are to be determined at some places . we have straight on the agenda of this meeting a report over the equal chances for women and men , which again illustrates , as badly it is with acquis communautaire in practice straight in this area . who wanted the poland of the kopernikus and johannes johannes-paul ii . the entrance to the european house to refuse , that the volksdemokratien set 1956 off in budapest maltreated hungary or the symbol-pregnant capital prague , in that once the head of state by a fenstersturz and the people of january palach , which sacrificed itself for the liberty , by force held down . larger europe with more tasks and obligations needs new and more extensive financial means . on this occasion entbiete i the older citizens and the pensioners in estland mean greeting and hope that one might have carried providing have made for them possible an existence in the european union . even if lettland makes further progress and the european union adapted their institutional structures and politiken , in order to be able to master the extension , i do not see a reason , why lettland should not be taken up to the union . even if litauen makes further progress and the european union adapted their institutional structures and politiken , in order to be able to master the extension , i do not see a reason , why litauen should not be taken up to the union . also in the umweltsektor progress is to be determined with the creation of the "national fund for environmental protection" and the application of the causer pays principle . if the union poland opens the door to our common house , it leaves a justice , which became to withhold from this country all too for a long time opposite this newcomer justice walten - . i look forward to the imminent entry of the czech republic to the european union . . (en) i welcome the report of mr . queiró over the request of hungary for entry to the european union and can the largest part of its conclusions support . i hope that bulgaria of the union in too will not join furthermore future . report poos (a5-0249/2000) it concerns a balanced and fair statement , which the advice should take seriously to the knowledge . in this connection i hope that the negotiations under the patronage of the united nations lead to success , so that the greek and the turkish group of peoples on cyprus can profit together from the advantages of the entry in the context of a reunited republic . i welcome the report of mr . poos over the request of the republic of cyprus for entry to the european union . but we consumers find us at the outermost end of the food chain and are thus the last storage tank for changed and falsified food . we exert ourselves in particular for the fact that food security on european level and in concrete form is ensured by the stable and/or by the field up to the table . evenly because we are for the development of really fraternal and equal co-operation relations between all countries of this earth , we do not have the intention of supporting with our vote a farce . the advice informed the parliament before the tuning in the committee , however so at short notice that thereby completely consciously further discussions with me or the parliament were prevented . in my report i not only a stronger agency and inclusion of the nro , a more comprehensive accountability demanded the collecting main of an annual report and a discussion in relation to the parliament , over it in the parliament as well as greatest possible transparency , but also expressed me to recognize repeated discrimination and to keep the memory alive to the past , in order to be able to use it with the fight of prejudices . at the same time entitled interests of the employees must be considered . the management and industry are earliest as chief executives with the regulation of discrimination questions on the job able to compile practicable solutions . jenny is koordinatorin of the group of access charters and from me to the public hearings over article 13 was invited . practically because guidelines and schemes offer incentives to the fact that the member states proceed with the fight against discriminations from the same basis , and they make it for the commission possible to notice their role as hueterin of the contracts in addition , in the social discussion to precede . although the available legal basis releases means for new preparing actions , their financing could lead within this category to a central reduction for other politiken . before us a suggestion for a necessary , but insufficient framework guideline lies . we will have opportunity to perfect their mechanisms after a certain application time . i hope , the commission before the background of this new guideline carefully with the question of discrimination due to the sex will be concerned . i congratulate to the commission and mean colleagues , who compiled these reports . i welcome the recommendation in the report man giving to world-descriptive organizations the possibility of placing if necessary as vocational requirement against the personnel conditions which refer to this consideration . the fact that the institutions make use so fast by the new powers granted by the contract of amsterdam , proves that the european union in the area of the equal chances still plays a role of the pioneer , and but , mrs . kommissarin , i would like to thank the european commission completely expressly . the operational readiness level of discriminations of most different kind in our societies confirms the importance of the available scheme , which concerns the report of mr . cashman . mr . praesident , in the name i would like to express our confusion to the delegate of the bonino list over the way of the treatment of the topic discrimination , racingism and stranger hostileness by this union and the member states . can the mrs . kommissarin explain , why the commission ignores this aspect? second is independent for me the problem that ngo are also so important , her , here to be requested , itself of their size to endeavor their kind and her actions around execution . all this positively evaluated the parliamentary group of the liberals and a democratic party of europe , however in particular the activity of the european parliament , which also and above all put special reproduction on the prevention of discrimination as well as on the proven procedures . this is a challenge for us all , because we judge all humans by the first impression . mr . praesident , if we fight discriminations and issue regulations against it , then we confess their existence and even the fact that numerous of their manifestations are "legal" meanwhile , since they belong to the everyday life picture . first the unctad , the world trade and conference of development of the united nations , 1963 in geneva the principle of the positive measures , set up thus to discrimination . the information and the sensitization actually attain a fundamental meaning within this range , by it must appropriate preliminary work be carried out , so that a new mentality , a new thinking and behaviors to remember , so that the prejudices still spread in the population can be eliminated for all mark and real equal rights are guaranteed to all citizens and citizens . therefore it concerns now to advance with the two legislations initiatives standing to the discussion also , by being improved in some aspects and the means planned for the financing of the program are supplemented , where the political value of this fight against discriminations comes to the expression . in particular the agreement over the principle of appropriate adjustments , with which sweden and ireland played a role of the pioneer , will now guarantee that the employers in europe adapt their jobs , special equipments to purchase and their operational sequences in such a way change that handicapped coworkers receive a genuine chance . the article 13 forms the starting point for a new objective of the european union: the fight of the discrimination or the unequal treatment of the citizens for reasons , which are specified in this article . secondly i would like to point out that the commission with this first package unfortunately made an error which can be taken seriously , by arranging the reasons for discriminations in an order of rank . mr . praesident , a discrimination for religious reasons is to be tolerated just as few as every other form of discrimination . as convinced trailers of the laizismus i cannot follow therefore this thought . the noble thought to award to each citizen the greatest possible liberty if it is compatible equally with the liberty of the others , meets still today obstacles , partly actual , partly legal kind . one of these guidelines was already discharged in very short time , and i am very optimistic that the other one is approved of in november still during the french council presidency . some do not stand in conformity with other legislation , for example the request for modification over the procedures in the committees . to reject i must the request for modification 38 and the suggested cancellation of the list from article 5 , in which permissible cases are specified due to the age unequal treatments . they took up the important question of the performance of the contract . in this scheme for the first time common projects are planned . it lies on hand that the code of practice will be the more effective , the more countries world-wide follows . in article 7 of the kodex the member states commit themselves to prevent that weapons are passed on to unsuitable final users . mr . praesident , i admits that i back-long myself for the times , in which from the european parliament , in addition , from the different peace movements and trade unions demands after considerations and measures for the continuous lowering of weapon production was raised and one the question placed himself , how arms production could be changed over on civilian production . in view of the situation , in which the world and our continent are today , after the end of the cold war and the collapse of the equilibrium of the fright maintained by the massenvernichtungswaffen , a such behavior would be irresponsible . these weapons became as it were the symbol for the anarchy at numerous places in the world . the gasp covers measures to the crisis fight outside of the borders of the union , but nothing that can be called common defense policy . these aim at it off , the export of weapons at governments , that hurt the human rights , as well as into crisis areas or in regions , in which an arms race takes place , to prevent . the commission participated actively in close co-operation with the member states in the development of the common measure of the european union for hand-held weapons and light weapons . after the agenda the discussion follows over the report of the commission over the european research area . further elements are the introduction of promotion forms conceived for longer periods , which are settled between the project promotion and the institutional financing half-way ; the use of instruments planned in the contract "with variable geometry" , above all the participation of the union in national programs , as it plans article 169 of the contract . we want to promote this hierarchisierenden character , and this depends on the promotion form . they say , you would think of a complete shake up of the master program . my judgement need we today something , which lends a structure to the european research area , thus something , which goes beyond the master program , with which the national programs are only supplemented . we need a structuring element , therefore we must introduce methods . which concerns the considerations with the stoa paper , then we must do my judgement together somewhat , since the parliament , which are concerned common research centre and the future research institutes in the individual member states . obviously the commission with giant steps walks on the implementation of the european research area too . it will give a whole chapter over science , society and citizen . it gave contacts to the authorities of greece , ireland and portugal to submit in order to request the governments of these countries , the commission their projects in the context of the coherence fund as fast as possible . perhaps is the absence of a service , which it straight mentioned and which there was in the last commission , to which exclusively the coherence fund it dedicated itself to it debt that you no more concrete data are present . my second question reads as follows: beside the coherence fund there are the joint promotion concepts , the structure funds , the regional programs etc . . to you were definite projects submitted and already approved by which countries which programs of which countries to have you? 1989 submitted the commission a new suggestion , which should offer more flexibility . i white the expressions of mr . bolkestein to estimate and me is well-known that one of the principles in the contracts reads that foreign enterprises may not pay any longer than domestic , but should the general rules for fair competition in europe to application find also here . in cases of disproportionately high taxation we should realise the effect , which the competition right in this situation can have , also if generally apply ourselves that these affairs are subject to the competence of the member states . if you want to save fuel , then by deliveries on that and not by other taxation forms . i would like to answer mr . purvis that the problem of the natural , regional disadvantages is probably thing of the governments of the individual nations , live nevertheless a part of their constituency in those remote regions and in peripheral areas . mr . praesident ! thanks , mrs . kommissarin , for your information . in the past spring and summer the european commission accomplished a general revision of its activities and its personnel status . there are such tasks . they in increasing measure by tourists and businessmen are used , who remarkably often come from europe . the commission is the view that all enterprises will be able , to prepare in time for the final conversion for the euro to which also the adjustment of its computer systems and the software belongs . the theoretical political discussion does not stand longer on the agenda , we can the dangers of a referendum generally discuss , but perhaps to another opportunity . this applies also to moose . recently to the french authorities a letter of reminder was sent . to the entry candidates i can communicate to you that to this problem meetings with them were closed to have taken place and provisional conventions . while the commission cases arrived to the spring sowing seeds of different conventional planting places imported by objections of at the knowledge , under it cotton which exhibited traces of genetically changed seeds . after i short circuit myself however with its agency , i am able to communicate to you the fact that fundamental safety requirements regarding computer equipment for the private and/or official use in a guideline for electrical products low tension guideline so as well as in the guideline over radio communication systems and telecommunications final mechanisms is fixed mentioned to which . would it follow my opinion that one falsely differentiates here between security on the job and security with respect to the classroom and/or the security of a child , who sits at home at the computer? perhaps it vibrates the hand of president chatami . aung san suu kyi lives today in fact under house arrest . therefore i am very zoegerlich to include the trade more strongly with and/or to call further measures in regarding trade or investments . nr inquires . 15 of (h-0769/00): they referred for example to election campaign meetings , which had visited them . the inquiries nr . 16 to 44 is answered in writing . we plead for a consolidated european report , which should be examined and published by this parliament . instead of on it , how we can compete with the countries in the world producing other weapons , we should concentrate rather on the conversion on civilian production . the five constant members of the security council , whose task actually consists of it , over our security to awake , should give to these suggestions attention and as fast as possible an agreement negotiate , those 21 . is worthy of century . the today's debate marks an important step during the reform process , which was introduced by the commission under mr . prodi approximately one year ago . the thought forces itself upon me that the commission in running did not create it around the production of a suggestion within the time framework determined in the reform white paper to weigh all individual points exactly . therefore actively i on that both the finance director and the internal invoice controller should provide detailed annual reports on their activity . in the report van hulten is intensified the separation endorsed by the commission rightfully still and an useful beginning for the exchange of best practices between the organs ordered . that is not to repeat itself here hopefully ! if we meet definitions for the large institutions , then independence on the whole line , demanded by the committee of the ways , must apply . we experienced in the past very frequently , how to long decision-making processes led with the applicants to disappointment and to a confidence loss into the european institutions . i would like to say to the mrs . kommissarin that this report is only one intermediate step . that means it that he represents the first step with the building of a bridge between the at present valid control system and that , which we want to reach after the reform . that is the suggestion , which is present . then only if they are able , sampling , the selection , which is frequently controlled , is also gone back . beyond simple explanations we all are conscious to us of its that that is certainly no easy venture . i mean naturally also that we neither when politicians nor as technicians at all able are , to concern the problem alone . fortunately however the completely outweighing majority of children and young people grows up in an environment , which does not exhibit of these problem characteristics . i agree the commission president unreservedly that such a catalog , which has similarity with a condition must be prepared . it is for me naturally that the subsidiaritaetsprinzip must be strengthened and that the european union has to keep itself away from many politics ranges , their setting of tasks is not transnational . information from all world and all fields of knowledge is supplied within shortest time to the house , and communicating around the earth is approximately for it everyday life . they were arrested fast and explained opposite the policemen: " , in the series one is amusing is not so fast seized . the legislator - and thus i would like to close - cannot regulate everything , sometimes but it must remind of the rights and obligations of everyone . in addition i understand the remarks for education to regard for the training of the ability of understanding about pictures as well as for the sensitization of the recent generations , the media critically and itself not something , sometime , of regarding somehow . nothing on their still in the development opinions present more harmful to affect , as if a report leads like these to no progress and/or to no larger mobility or does not create it at least to eliminate the obstacles of which the training mobility today is concerned . in the individual countries different problems are to be solved: go for example around different regulations in the ranges social security , scholarships , residence and tax law or around the absence of a common acknowledgment of conclusions and practical course stays . it becomes time that europe of the perfect conversion of programs dedicates like sokrates and "youth for europe" again attention . the experiences with the mobility of studying and instructors show that the real lack lie here not primarily in the training system , but at the social , tax and immigration authorities . as an example for this the sokrates program was specified . there must be a clear monitoring , clear control , although in a random sampling way , and above all an advisory board , a web page must be furnished , where the pupils and student can attach their complaints . we demand therefore the inclusion of the person's group of the researchers into the area of application of the recommendations . but this is more simply said than done . the discussion is closed . we estimate your beginning , which orients itself at the model of president jacques chirac or of minister of foreign affairs joschka fischer . the union must speak in the foreign policy with a voice and develop common an safety ability and defense . which we need , a decision forum is for the accomplishment of the problems , which are for both sides of central importance , as for instance the migration movements , the misalignment of factors of production or the power supply . in the resolution request to the reports of the commission , on which you will co-ordinate afterwards , this topic is treated very in detail . the indicators compiled by it will make an evaluation possible of the obtained progress . apart from the conference of ministers and the colloquium over the equalization in the occupation still two important should be mentioned particularly the equalization dedicated , however in the range of the advice "occupation and social" falling texts . second concerns the principle of the non-discrimination , under it the prohibition of discrimination due to the sex . to the reports i would like to still mark - the advice president also addressed it - that the important cultural differences naturally belong to the large problems within the european union . also the reports , which we treat here , reflect . we must check that the guideline actually finds entrance into the legislation for equalization . i believe that this is for the first time in finland used procedures for very many ranges practicable and one may expect of this as part of the equal rights strategy of the commission still much . in the name of the equal chances the french women acquired the right to night work owing to the european union . as a french citizen such a view of the world is in particular strange to me . despite these remarks we will be correct for the available report , because we are natural for the equal chances , but equal chances mean above all that everyone is respected . who takes the freedom of choice to mothers to educate their own children without payment keeps over short or long the calculation in the form of juvenile delinquency and vandalismus presents . i remind in this connection of our report over splitting of the pension rights with divorce that the achievements for the survivors and the retirement age are finally included into the guideline of 1979 . the polish women were very grateful that we made clear that the representative , who was there did not show evenly the attitude of the polish women . a stronger inclusion of women on all government levels and in all areas of life is a substantial condition for the recess of the democracy as well as for the reaching and retaining of peace . finally i would like to say still something to the situation of the women in the countries , which prepare for their entry to the european union . the advice , and not least the men in it , have therefore in this area an enormous task to lead europe in the fight against the woman commercial mafia . no conscious politician can displace this slave trade , to shoulder-twitch turn into or leave unconsidered . we can infer from the reports and speech contributions , which we analyze today , what many from us was already clear , i .e . that this problem of the equal chances of structural kind is and global strategies are needed for its solution , because we women are neither a category still another a homogeneous social group and just as little are we a collective . actually i took with certain regret to the knowledge that maria de belém rose irish republican army does not dress this post any longer . two of your speakers addressed new social rights , new tax rights . thirdly they are the basis for a strategy on the level of the european union - even with the fundamental right charter it was from great importance that an overview of the present situation was to us at the disposal - , in addition , on national level , since the member states can specify national goals now on the basis a comparative evaluation . the common discussion is closed . these requests for modification must be understood in the new context of the inter+institutional agreement , and therefore the parliament can refrain to insist on these requests for modification over the komitologie since they became insignificant by the new inter+institutional framework in certain way . i believe nevertheless personally further that the text accepted at that time by the parliament considered substantially better to the new realities of the domestic market and the liberalisation of the markets , since the elements of control and clearing-up , which were contained in the not accepted changes , offered a larger warranty for the fact that the regulations would be used kept and during their conversion the same procedures . if we want the fact that the third countries accept the obligations , does the european community have to be mindful as first to provide for the adherence to their own regulations because if a country has the possibility of bringing products over smuggling ways on the market of the community why is to then make itself it the trouble to negotiate with us any permission? in the same way the request for modification of the parliament becomes concerning the paperless registration , which by the advice one took over , which customs authorities of the member states make possible to equip itself with the most modern automated administrative instruments . but it is too late now , because you let the members for it just co-ordinate on it and to have expressed itself . tunings (continuation) report (a5-0198/2000) of mrs . dybkjær in the name of the committee for the rights of the woman and equal chances over the annual reports of the commission "equal chances for women and men in the european one union - 1997 , 1998 , 1999" (kom (1998) 302 - c5 ­ 0106/1999) (kom (1999) 106 - c5-0289/2000) (kom (2000) 123 - c5 0290/2000 -1999/2109 (cos)) . (fr) i do not deliver today the first time a statement to the mobility of studying and instructors . all the greater importance is attached to the available report , as it is submitted to the forthcoming extension to an instant , i .e . , crucial for the european union . discrimination can be fought not by the creation of additional administration offices , but only and alone in the heads of humans . - (fr) i was not correct for the report man , because with all actually necessary props after equal treatment in occupation and occupation it does not need to be so far gone therefore yet in the overeagerness that the protection of the liberties and the attention of the right state come thereby completely into oblivion . as convinced representatives of the laizismus , the separation from church and state , could i mean agreement in addition not to give . . (en) the snp welcomes this guideline and its goal of setting for discrimination on the job an end . if the guideline should be acceptable and feasible , it may not be overloaded with literature and wishful thinking , which do not have to look for legislations in a text anything . the eplp has strong reservations however to the following ranges: also questions like the conversion altogether , the training for certain age groups of employees , which and the interpretation of this guideline should be left kind of a conciliation system on the part of the kmu to our opinion after the member states . rightfully mr . implements van hulten in the interview that we can begin only then with a positive agenda , if we such problems such as fraud and verschwendung , in addition , lack at efficiency and effectiveness in the adoption of resolutions to have mastered . the reasons for my agreement to this report are mainly connected with the question of closer relations of the european union with nato and the rapid implementation of a common defense policy . in the report also the european export of arms is discussed as solution for future regional conflicts in the border areas of europe . however i cannot accept that this with the demand after a common defense policy and a european safety and defense policy are connected within nato . . (el) the children are the first victims of force in the television . i welcome that the results of this study are present now . on community level one will beyond that use an expert committee with the order to prepare a memorandum which contains general principles for the protection of persons under age in the medium range . report dybkjær (a5-0198/2000) . (el) interestingly enough for the first time the necessity was recognized here to evaluate the effectiveness of the political initiatives resulting from the annual reports of the commission . peru mr . praesident ! peru through-lives at present instants of the uncertainty , and we all preserve the hope that the present situation is solved by a process , in which all civil and political rights are guaranteed , which and consolidation of the democracy and the peace in peru serves the stabilization , a country , which had to deplore 25 ,000 dead ones in the last fifteen years . the word , which here it concerns , is called "democracy" . mr . praesident , ladies and gentlemen ! the conditions , on which in may in peru elections ran off this yearly , were unacceptable . b5-0793/2000 of the delegates ainardi and others in the name of the parliamentary group of the konfoederalen parliamentary group united european linking/the nordi greens left ones for the situation of the women in afghanistan . therefore i welcome it also that the resolution contains and to it draws the attention of some clear points over the situation of the women , how important assistance is , in order to prevent the further total discrimination of women by the taliban guidance . the european union has here an important task . an acknowledgment , of none of the member states , may not give it so for a long time , how the policy of the violations of human rights and above all the systematic discrimination of the women is continued . this and the fact that the money from the drug cultivation is used for the purchase by weapons , we must lead ourselves in the european institutions before eyes . however it the neighboring countries with the improvement of their possibilities for the drug fight to support decided . i consider the time suitably to remind of the fact that the european union must prepare a understanding policy opposite latin america , which could possibly prevent that these countries in regular intervals crisis situations through-live , as they arose occasionally . ladies and gentlemen ! the release of the spanish jesuitenpaters alejandro matos castro welcomes the commission like the house in the last week . b5-0782/2000 of the delegate haarder in the name of the parliamentary group of the liberals and a democratic party of europe to macedonia: law over universities and universities ; therefore we all are very glad that now finally perhaps this problem of the higher education goes against a really good solution . according to my opinion that is above all a good example for all neighboring countries that over the education hate cannot only be sown , as it so often happens today , but that also as cradle for a peaceful , multi-ethnical society can serve education . i would have also wished myself , we would have found a solution , which all parties in the parliament could have agreed . perhaps i may point out here at the opportunity that the commission in co-operation with the high commissioner , mr . made van the stoel , already good experiences . with the today's discussion we do not only want to state our condolence . primarily we discuss , what happened , why it happened , how we for the future remedy to create to be able and how from now to the commission and the european parliament to the fact to contribute to be able that such an incident does not occur again . anyhow we explained ourselves in agreement with this common resolution request and to endorse it in the available form as urgency , and for the reasons already stated we are against the requests for modification , which were likewise submitted in the urgency procedure . to the request for modification over the conditions of work: this question is already the subject of a guideline , and the request for modification is not anyway as meaningfully as the text . that is acceptable for the northern and western islands of scotland simply not , also not for the possible passage over the north sea to the european mainland , which is not furnished hopefully in too furthermore future . i welcome it that the greek government cancelled this release in the meantime . therefore the commission has itself following the fall of the express samina turned to the greek government immediately with the request to get clearing-up over the application of the valid community law . i would like to raise the question and ask you to clarify this in the presidency whether after the abolishment of the on fridays from certain side already the abolishment of thursday began . i would like to communicate to you further that on the part of the european union the mechanisms are set in course , so that we , as soon as the will of the serbian people respects , can seize i .e . , as soon as is formed a government supported by the voters kostunicas , the following measures: first of all , an immediate abolition of the sanctions and secondly an economic aid package for the support of the serbian people in the reconstruction of its economics . in these hours in the roads of belgrade it will perhaps decide whether the democratic change occurs now and whether it can occur forceless . we condemn all actions , which are to be rated as provocation , in particular , which concerns the holy places in jerusalem . we must the people - how mr . solana said - with this conference in zagreb completely symbolically hands the hand . it is most shocking that the israeli police and the army of fragment projectiles used , which burst with the penetration into the body into dozens of parts projectiles , which are forbidden internationally , even with fights between soldiers , and are used now against civilians . i believe , europe can and must much in this direction do , and it must act thereby clearly and decided . consequently it must be done everything , in order to contain the smoldering fire as fast as possible . provocations , like the action of ariel sharon , must be omitted . that is also today again the case , and therefore the european union becomes , as already in all the last years , in the near east no role of mediator to transfer to be able , which leaves it thereby to the usa alone . we will hehren the serbian population not our and moral objectives will sacrifice , because it would mean that that perhaps thousands of humans in serbia and yugoslavia could die therefore . finally i would like to suggest , as fast as possible to make and as soon as a new yugoslav government is formed to travel with a delegation of the parliament there in order together with this new yugoslav government of plans for the structure of new serbia . mrs . praesidentin , ladies and gentlemen ! it is clearly that we possibly experience a historical day in this parliament today , perhaps the end one of the last supporting columns of a totalitarian dictatorship in europe . mr . praesident ! there is a problem , in the german dossier for the urgencies - i do not know whether in the other language versions also occurs - only the requests for modification are only contained of the gue parliamentary group , but none of the resolution requests and already not at all the common text . mr . praesident , i wanted only for the colleagues on the pile attentively to make , which shows , which documents we this week co-ordinating to have used . if the parliament could submit changes for the resolution of the advice , it became also safe of unemployment and to remind , which ordered slimness cure for the country from that result , but in this connection there are social problems of croatia for such requests for modification no legal basis . this is the opportunity to demand the same goals regarding the activity of the eib . mr . praesident ! yesterday evening we spoke ourselves here about serbia and the revolutionary changes carrying out there . therefore i would like seriously at the colleagues and colleagues , above all in addition , to the advice , appeal , to remain as close in the coming months with the negotiations over the household for the next year and for the years after as possible at the suggestion of the commission which estimated the entire costs in croatia , in addition , in other parts of the balkans in my view , still best . in the year 1990 there democratic elections were held , which were after international judgement fair and free . therefore to this financial assistance , to this warranty , but at the same time an energetic request of the commission , this deeply european and now really democratically and right-nationally governed country substantial to support and it into the number of the entry candidates to lead , because i believed , croatia our full support earned . just as the correspondent ask i me however whether the money for it is really made available , above all , because it looks like the fact that soon also large money stream must flow to serbia and the household of the union is not increased . also the delegations of the croatian and our parliament requested the advice to expand the mandate of the eib . i hope that contacts are attached as soon as possible and just like croatia also the serbian people , who earns our largest respect support are granted . (the parliament approves minutes . in this sense we request therefore the women in the european parliament to take part in this delegation: on tuesday and on wednesday we a call to start , we signatures collect and the messages for the participation in the delegation against to take , just with the request to strike between the mrs . bruecken of the peace at a place , where instead force prevails . altogether both basques and spaniards new wrong was added ; spaniards and basques have enough from the present conflict . it will remember mrs . praesidentin , sie that i drew the attention of james mawdsley , which was illegally held by the birmesischen authorities to the last conference to the emergency of the british advocate of the democracy . mrs . praesidentin , with me really concerns it the agenda . this technically seeming report , which does not seem to lead to large political changes , is to be used in reality expressed importantly , because it introduces the possibility over detours , the genetic engineering in the cultivation of wine and therefore genetically changed products in the cultivation of wine to receive . if we do not co-ordinate on the report , it will come to delays . the conseil d ' budget has - as you said - this appointment rejected and this refusal was communicated us in being entitled form . today repeats itself however such a case , which concerns a colleague , who belongs the evp , not however to my political camp in italy . therefore we set as engaged for the introduction of a social scoreboards , as it also for the domestic market happened ourselves , with clear measures , with dates , with time limits . hopefully , mrs . minister , lets herself be inspired the advice of expectations of the parliament , and hopefully you will succeed to fix on the summit in nice ambitious goals in a european sociopolitical agenda on which we can work then in the next years together . following the informal conference of the advice "occupation and social affairs" on 8 july in paris the presidency had requested all participants concerned - natural the european parliament , the economic and social committee , the committee of the regions , the management and industry , nro as well as the working groups and committees of the advice - to convey to it their suggestions . the debate over the confrontation of the quantitative and qualitative aspects is unsuitable , and in lisbon clearly a double objective was defined: more jobs and high-qualified jobs . this mobility must be promoted and at the same time the protection of the vocational career ensured . we must try to specify and also designate still in the system consisting the gaps and , in each case to set on the agenda . the open coordination method is our judgement the correct way to the safety device social europe . the conversion to lisbon publicised social goals requires joint efforts , a plan of action for the job creation within the service range and particularly within the range of the information society . the commission can naturally make an important contribution , but the social problems are regionally embodied and must be treated with much fine feeling for concrete conditions . the social dimension served the economic policy as reconciliation for the most consequence-fraught effects . it would have been better to leave the original suggestion of the commission in such a way as it was . congratulations mr . kommissar . it is an ambitious agenda , and i can remember still well , how laboriously we came in front in the last legislative period in the social protection . my judgement would be also very good it to support the women to bring their family and working life with one another in agreement . sometimes i have the impression that with the term modernization is meant frequently scooping out the social protection . which now are the most important contentwise characteristics? still it is difficult to specify european goals which are equally valid for all member states , because the reality proves as quite different . 49 requests for modification were submitted by the committee for the rights of the woman and equal chances . in a request for modification is suggested accomplishing annually here in the parliament a discussion to the topic as well as the commission . a further point is the intensified support of the community during estimate of the need of additional initiatives , inclusively , if necessary , the conversion of legislation and equalization and the fight against discrimination . in the past good ideas and plans for the equalization of the sexes , their conversion did not lack at all frequently only unfortunately failed . it does not concern that the voice of the women is seized by a handful of demand professionals , who hold themselves with public funds alive . it concerns the equalization from women and men in the civilian range , whom it makes for the women possible to come into the full benefit of the human rights and basic liberties . i expect myself that finally also the male participants set and traditional sex roles here and stereotyped ones fight . we must thank her meanwhile that them pursued our discussion , because their presence during the entire debate was not intended actually . competitive policy we are guilty to our enterprises the most favorable conditions , so that they can plan their production and not least its future . the consumers must have entrance to a large selection of high-quality products to attractive prices , and that is in the long run the reason for the fact that as much because of the domestic market and thus at the free competition is to us , because our citizens profit from it . that is the aid decision or nichtbeihilfenentscheidung in the range of the hard coal . point 16 in the report of mrs . riis riis-jørgensen demands a increased right security with the application of control of unions as well as a more efficient and more rapid temporal treatment in the case of calling the courts . in all these cases it concerns public enterprises , which owe their financial power not to a perfect management , but earlier or present monopolistic positions . we need an intensified inclusion of the citizen into the information about the competitive policy , so that it recognizes the advantages . they are extremely important for the economy and occupation in the regions , and i hope that this aspect is made in the future clear , so that these national aids for the regional development and the regional economy , for example the transportation aids , to be further-paid to be able . this report contains three correct messages . i thank mr . evans just as cordially for its excellent report concerning concerning the joint regulations over subventions at the iron and steel industry as well as the respected report of the commission over subventions in the european union . i would like to say the delegate mrs . palacio and mr . karas as well as the other ep members , who spoke about these questions , that its doubts in the regulation are considered to a large extent . otherwise we would show ourselves in our effort around the promotion of the competition and the consumer interests a disservice . the discussion is closed . with this financing system article 119 eec contract is converted , which applies for the common currency not joining member states during the third phase of the economic and monetary union only to those . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , my very much admired ladies and gentlemen ! i thank you for the fact that we can discuss today nevertheless still the suggestion for a guideline of the advice on the change of the guideline 68/193/eec traffic with vegetative propertyproperty property of vines , and i hope tomorrow also for a positive tuning . some of them on 5 july in the call of beaune their uneasiness in connection with the introduction of gvo in their trade expressed . the regulations contained in it favour besides the emergence of versatile vegetative propertyproperty property , since they offer best health warranties , which for the effective promotion of the restructuring of the viticulture in the community , which is urgently necessary key element of the new gmo wine . it must be said loud and clearly that it was necessary in no way to plug the articles of this guideline with references to the guideline 90/220 in change fully it is , one wanted the gene manipulation of common grape vines with all power to advance . 35 to nr . 40 to accept can transfer , which aim at , the safety and management requirements in accordance with the guideline 90/220 more consistently . to the fact i would like to mark that the plenum had not been requested to take as such position . mrs . praesidentin , i refers to point 14 of our minutes to the request for abolition of the parliamentary immunity of our colleague pacheco pereira . with the qualified majority i would like to deal somewhat more in greater detail . during the voice weighting likewise the two well-known options are still on the table: the simple voice weighting , for which a breath-thin majority appears , and/or which double majority , however on the basis of different formulas like double simple or again-weighted majority or however a kind "demographic net" . besides the european advice decided without prejudice to a need evaluation and a coordination of the economical and financial assistance for the federal republic of yugoslavia , which will together transfer the european commission and the world bank , to grant the federal republic of yugoslavia a first humanitarian emergency aid at a value of 200 million euro . if i am to say spontaneously and completely openly my opinion to you , then i would say: as sensitively these questions - which composition of the commission and the voting procedure - also to be likes , the success or failure of nice will not be based on it . positive it also was that the state and head of the government gave their agreement to the charter of the fundamental rights , but i must also remind of it , mr . ratspraesident , why was this agreement possible? we may not strangle the spirit of nice by annoyance , and therefore it is in the remaining 50 days of first-rate importance to lift the negotiations on the political level . in this sense i would like to contact also my colleagues and colleagues of the european people's party - and i ask mr . poettering that he listens to me - , because for which we occur in this parliament , we must represent that also outside . after everything that we know about the results of the state and heads of the government in biarritz regarding the most complicated questions of the contract reform , the charter will be probably the largest trophaee in nice . the advice would really correspond to expectations of the european citizens , if it a comprehensive consultation of the peoples , which national parliaments accomplished , in order to come to a charter , which actually corresponds to the needs . therefore all are requested to return to the origins of our union to apply the courage which mr . giscard d ' estaing and mr . schmidt had , when they decided 1976 and 1979 on the choice of the european parliament in general and direct elections to decide and us for the fact that we 2009 finally a president of the european union , i .e . the commission presidents , to have . in this connection i would like to answer in particular to it , what mr . poettering said to the discrepancies between large and small countries . i would like to deal completely briefly still with the questions of the foreign trade policy , because this is an extremely serious topic . this is in any case something valuable , which was emphasized by all members of the european advice . a second very positive aspect is the acceptance of the charter in its whole . refrained from the fact it seems to me that in this fundamental question for the future of the european union and for their decision procedure in biarritz pluses could be registered . i hope to advance it to us will succeed to still convince in this point and intersperse us in nice . in addition i would like to state two concrete examples: the right to work became the right to work , and a set of in the changed social charter of the council of europe contained rights to the charter were not transferred . as follows from the discussions , which were led in completely europe , under it also biarritz , the larger member states want the smaller partly to a reform of the european union urge , which corresponds to the direction taken by the larger member states and its desires . the dissatisfied ones on both sides are the proof for the negotiators that they move on an appropriate compromise . the guidance of europe formulated no clear visions . a commission , that is structured according to criteria of the agency of the individual member states , witnesses from little farsightedness . in such a centralistic union the small countries less influence than the small federal states in the two-chamber system of the usa would have . after the summit of sharm el sheikh , where all involved ones were endeavored around a solution nevertheless , in order to order to the force stop and to set the dialogue between barak and arafat again in course , we recognized , how difficult that is , although it had briefly the appearance , as if can the force be defeated . bad informants caused obviously mr . barón crespo to express things over italy and my party which do not correspond to the truth . a progress is important in the european energy taxation , which was blocked so far by the unanimity principle . we should not let it come to it that at the small states the fear develops , one could toward you acct advice solutions go . according to my opinion the convention carried distinguished work out , and i am also proud on the fact that i was allowed to belong to this committee . with the second hypothesis the question arises , in which time intervals the principle of the rotation completely equal regarding large and small countries is to be used . the expansion of the tuning with qualified majority as well as the joint decision on important subjects , which maintenance of article 250 in its current form , which place and the role of the commission in intensified co-operation not only with the first column - these are some elements , on the basis those we to immediately judge can whether in the long run a success or a failure is present . as well as mr . praesident , i would like first jacques , jacques delors , altiero spinelli and remote and herman thanks all of vaclav havel up to carlo ciampi , of joschka fischer up to jacques chirac , of michel barnier up to pierre moscovici , of chris cuffs up to costa simitis , without forgetting florence and the multiplicity of the present european delegates , who exerted themselves again since 1999 for the large movement for a european condition . we should criticize commercial europe not too much - this says to you a socialist - , because it created more wealth for all . we should at least on this goal agree , and we this there do , should we also say , how it can be attained . i stated with satisfaction that the suggestions presented recently on the diplomatic conference agree actually complete or partial with the views stated by me . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , my mr . berichterstatter , much admired ladies and mr . abgeordnete ! they had wished that this morning a discussion takes place over the questions , due to those your high house it for necessary judged , in the april of this yearly the delivered statement to the diplomatic conference to supplement . therefore it seems to be difficult me despite the attention of the existing constitutional framework - as i would like to say openly - to plan more than the delivery of a statement of the parliament during the introduction of such a co-operation . how it admits to you is this presupposes that we make certain political decisions , which are from far larger consequence than the three requirements specified a while ago of me . also i underlined that the method used for the charter is one possibility which can be considered . i very probably understood however that apart from the linguistic aspect behind your question a further request hides itself . also for this reason i would like to thank you for the form and contents of your initiative . the introduction of intensified co-operation should not lead to the creation of new organs additionally to the existing institutions of the union . it is at the time to revise the contracts . the european advice with its refusal hurts this fundamental agreement of europe to take up the charter of the european fundamental rights to the contracts to make it obligatory and the citizens , who are hurt in their rights to open the entrance to the european court of justice . differently , i do not think , europe of the citizens and citizens to have will be . number 8: the condition is to regulate - i quote - "questions the laissées ouvertes" . which is to have changed in it since that time , still none could explain to me . to second it concerns a insufficient setting of tasks , which leaves questions aside , which are for the future of the union and the interests of the citizens of special importance . mr . minister , according to the excessive quantity was issued himself the russian orthodox church on eve of the bolschewisti revolution - an event , which should have so fatal consequences for the whole world - in lengthy discussions over the organization of the robes at the chamfering time . therefore intensified co-operation must offer all the warranties , which the correspondent called: it must for all openly stand , that spirit of the contracts respect and may not the joint possession conditions not contrary-run . to one point i would like to however still refer: it does not seem to me correctly to set up the demand - to go or into this direction - , to accomplish in all member states a mandatory referendum in order to decide evenly the suggested changes . we have a really detailed debate led across the two topics , which are differently constituted , however in one point to meet . we are ready , whereupon in addition-work that there is a tuning during the conference in november in addition and the acceptance takes place thus still during the french council presidency . (the parliament accepts the resolution . ) what means "the introduction of the possibility of a part-time work for elderly people" different one than a threat in many countries already much to high pensionable age? as well known pensioners eat just as gladly jam as the children . i asked the pensioners , who sent me over the italian pensioner party into the european parliament , whether they would drink gladly genetically changed wine . besides standard standard propertystandard property is to be marketed to be able in exceptional cases , if the need cannot be covered by other categories . i ask you thus , mr . praesident: do different labor costs represent thus not also a restriction of the free competition in the european union? therefore could be tuned only against the fact what i also did . despite the increasing liberalisation in the european union subventions still come a constructional role with the achievement of social and economical progress . for environmental protection , the safety device of the public services and the warranty of same incomes for the inhabitants of structure-weak regions these assistance can be indispensable . we make attentive to the danger that the european union will take the less extensive aids under the pretext after strengthening its control of the important subventions also in the visor , to want to provide for competition between the small and middle enterprises . single diagramme vi - economics and social committee if one looks at oneself the schedules of due dates of the execution of the household for the columns 2 , 3 , 4 and 7 , one states that only on the average 8 % of all obligations are covered by payments . before three years we have to get chance capital begun with our occupation initiative , by helping small and middle enterprises . the parliament wants to do that in two different way . only then the european institutions also their order become fair . i may do me here expressly with the vice-president , who colleague gerhard schmid , responsible for household questions , for which thank you constructional co-operation . we want the fact that this committee receives its ability to work , but we cannot permit that to few on the demands of the european parliament as part of the budgetary authority is heard there . that is , the year 2001 offers the last complete yearly household , and forms also the background for the evaluation of the commission suggestion and the suggestion , which we submit to the parliament . in addition we want an examination of the administrative costs . since 1985 - mind you , since 85 - tries the budget committee of the parliament to reach that in the procedures of the european parliament the financial effects of the resolutions accepted by the plenum are considered . i close , mr . praesident , by thanking the other institutions for the care , they let which angedeihen the common explanation on their linear path . they have to decide today on a household , which was amended in first reading by the advice . which concerns the structural measures , then the intended central beginning remained actually alike in the comparison to the household 2000 . the attitude of the advice in relation to a revision of the financial forecast is purely material . if one regards these three different numbers , then one that still considerable differences are there , sees also purely quantitatively , naturally also contentwise . here i must point out that there was a new resolution with the advice with the komitologieverfahren after a long debate in the last year over it , and i had little hope that one can again open this debate . in the financial plan of berlin for the time to 2006 8 .1 billion euro were intended for the me since program . therefore i would like to request advice and budget committee here in the parliament to think with its considerations with regard to foreign policy also with regard to foreign policy and not only budgetary . second concerns the assistance for victims of violations of human rights , which need a treatment in special mechanisms . if a compromise settlement should result here in the still lining up time , which supports the important work of the emac committee , we can still regulate , otherwise we keep the position open of our committee . we need only the television to switch on and to us the problems in the near east regard , in order each day on the new of it to be reminded . therefore i hope that we come tomorrow in the tuning nevertheless still to the necessary majority for the observation post into dublin ! mr . praesident ! permit me in the name of the committee for agriculture and rural development some remarks , first for the development of the rural area . we asked for the permission of indikativer means at a value of two million euro for an information campaign to the gfp . the commission must negotiate with weighty arguments , in order to achieve a reasonable agreement with morocco , and task of the advice and the governments concerned is it to lend to this negotiation political impulses . if we regard the budget 2001 today , then the pictures of the serbian population before our eyes stand . altogether we wish ourselves that these requests for modification are accepted . an important possibility , which stands for the citizen openly , in order to provide hearing , consists of turning to the citizen-assigned or addressing petitionen to the parliament . first to the parliament household . for the large surprise of many delegates from my delegation we adopted at the beginning of of septembers unanimously a core strategy . the 400 requests for modification , which had been submitted of some my colleagues , came therefore for many of us in the budget committee quite surprisingly . it is difficult to constitute , how with new permanent posts the administrative problem can be solved , as long as both in the commission and in the advice antiquated and complicated methods are used for the administration of the many programs . this parliament showed in the past years always again that it makes expressed thriftiness the basis of its work . it cannot be the fact that one speaks about the years very loosely about obligations and assures it again and again , but then , if it goes to paying , says , goes to us now too far , there must we a piece now back-cut ! if we set only few millions here on the lines - many more cannot be it - , then we delay the bacon side , and if humans actually need her , we pull them away again . the household 2001 stood like already the household of the last yearly before nearly not solvable conflicts , on the one hand for the pressure of the consolidation and austerity policy , as it was decided in the context of the inter+institutional agreement , in order to place the financing of the extension surely , on the other hand the acute financing need of the stability pact for the balkans . demands for better performance contain also more personnel . the acceptance of this request for modification in its original version could have been the starting point for a change of the situation , but it was by the majority rejected by the budget committee . unfortunately there are of it still numerous examples: of the preferential treatment of combinations with foederalistischer objective or of numerous nro with most doubtful function and opinions over the financing of european parties up to the sums wasted for the program prince , with which the european citizens are to be convinced by the advantages of the euro , while this suffers a confidence loss , which the europeans from our danish friends to the responsible persons of the european central bank divide to a large extent . finally colleague heaton harris with its requests for modification referred rightfully on the unilateral nature of numerous european programs , in which the citizens with propaganda story are traktiert over the european integration , mind you to costs of the citizens themselves . additionally our management systems must be modernized . we must precede also with good example . a good example of the latter is the me since program for the catchment area of the mediterranean , a geographical area of highest strategic importance . if some about necessary shortening or seeking out means in column 4 speak , in order to be able to finance certain priorities , then you forget not that the parliament set priorities . we expressed this in the tuning in the committee clearly . this number requires thus a clarifying . thank you , mr . wynn . it means only the presence of real elements of the flexibility , in order to in front-walk on a certain politics policy further , while this some cannot wish or . and which to the countries of the union applies , applies also to the applicant countries . according to my opinion austria does not have a reason to deplore itself over the result completely in the opposite . the recommendations of the regional organizations and the experiences of the neighboring countries could surely make a useful contribution . in the year 1984 32 % of the soil possessed 0 .2 % the property owner in colombia . it is not task of the advice to commentate this or that aspect of this extremely delicate and painful question . but one cannot in this way begin also a debate over questions , which - as said - are extremely complicated . nr inquires . 10 of (h-0722/00): i will guard to give a final answer to this difficult question . we have only the feeling , and your answer seems to confirm this in certain way that the council presidency lets it be missing with the treatment of this question to something at consequence . therefore arising from this tax will be naturally not alike zero . i forgive them also , but we must adhere to the agenda . the reason for it , why it was so quiet on the right side here , lies thus in the fact that we clarified these questions already once , and our judgement do not have we the same things several times here to discuss and our valuable time waste . the moreover than temporary solution up to the acceptance of this text for preventing of transferable spongiformen enzephalopathien in june 2000 a decision was issued for the segregation of risk material in connection with these diseases , in order to prevent each further propagation of the epidemic disease and to ensure for the consumers the highest possible health protection level . i have no other data than those , which i just stated to you . we pursue the work of the commission and the advice on the package erika i and are well informed about it . but which concerns this meeresstrasse , which admits in both countries and also in the whole european union is as an extremely difficult meeresstrasse , those from large ships drives through we , in order to save only few hours , how the danger exists that old rust punts run somewhere on reason and cause a disaster , would have i and would have before everything the inhabitants of korsika and of sardinien gladly known , whether it is possible and whether you intend , the passage by the road of bonifacio for these large ships to forbid these container ships simply and simply? therefore we should actually support the suggestions of the commission for a revision of the personnel policy . in the household for serbia and for the kosovo new funds are needed . to the conclusion i would like hope to the expression to bring that one knows still 50 million euro branches in the household , in order to finance the peace agreement israel plo . therefore we will suggest new measures , which not so much on the search for further the to european in parliament financing funds - from which we already know that they are not to be found under the present conditions - , but on the definition of new inter+institutional obligations aim , by which the quality of the expenditures is to be improved and achieved that not one euro is wasted . remember that in the european policy as within every other range the moderate options do not form no more if necessary the majority . it serves rather the collusion the clearing-up , and the attitude regarding the measure-referred budgeting , shown today , disappoints me much . beyond that the allocation leads on actions to it that one understands the budget as political instrument , with which the distribution of the expenditures clear political priorities reflects . we should look for a solution , which has several years existence on this occasion , so that we do not have to again lead this discussion across the raising of funds to the reconstruction the balkans next and year after the next . who is interested in the development of a lasting agrarian sector , it will know that the main raid of the recent reforms agreed upon in berlin consists of carrying out a continuous transition of support of prices for products to the direct income aid to farmers . a budget is nevertheless always more than a sober zahlenreihe . in addition it is also immoral , the expenditures for the agricultural policy , for the program meda to shorten for expenditure-bordered the socially in order to guarantee means for the financing of the obligations of the european union in the kosovo and in yugoslavia . completely simply: in serbia humans may freeze in this winter neither nor hungern . on the other hand would like i mean doubts to announce that the different youth parliaments were taken up to the sokrates program . to the address of the advice must naturally also clearly be said , the advice carries also its responsibility for the unsatisfactory completion of some external programs . we need now a stable solution for these aids and in still higher measure for now necessary planning for the entire western balkans . i believe , most would be ready to accept such a sum under the condition that the money is used correctly . i divide the doubts and opinions of the berichterstatterin mrs . ruehle , who called her this afternoon in connection with the chapters research and social measures . two weeks ago ago the parliamentary meeting in equal numbers of the akp states took place . at the same time , that want we , in the fund for research and information budgetary appropriation are to be used in order to research after production alternatives for the present tobacco producers . i would like to note seriously the fact that the european union , which concerns northern ireland , which most direct and most positive influence had , which one can imagine . in accordance with this model the adherence to of the regulations and procedures becomes secured by an independent authority and in last instance by the courts . thus we will be able for the first time to lock a procedure of the joint decision in first reading , and this to an extremely complex and with many technical difficulties afflicted text for a range , which is particularly sensitive regarding the protection of the privatsphaere . it is to be evaluated as very positive that their tasks were not united . is z . b . admits that in the schengener system over 10 million data records over nearly 1 .5 million citizen are stored that with euro pole , whose powers are constantly extended , which gather information from the individual police authorities of the 15 member states central only under control of an authority , which has neither over the powers nor the means , in order to fulfill really still another another task . this ahead-skillfully , i uses the presence of the commissioner , in order to point out that one should carry my judgement not only for the protection of the citizen in view of the new technologies providing , but also for the use of these technologies in the sense of the better capability of the union citizens to switch themselves on and communicate interactively with the european institutions . in the requests for modification the text of the advice is transferred 1 , 2 , 4 to 10 , 12 to 40 , 42 to 54 , 57 , 58 and 60 to 64 in the points , in which the commission can agree . it understands itself automatically that its statements will be very helpful to the legislations suggestions on the protection of personal data , if they make an important contribution to to legislations the debate between the institutions . thus the contract recognizes on that the regions in extreme peripheral location exhibit a difficult economic and social situation , which is made more difficult by special disadvantages , which impair the development of these regions by their constant condition and by their cooperating strongly . in this way the strategy will contribute over a high occupation level to the promotion of the economic and social progress . therefore i speak mrs . sudre mean congratulations out . we expect the normative development of the suggestions of the commission with large interest , so that the characteristics can find consideration in accordance with article 299 paragraph 2 of the contract of amsterdam soon . for many europeans some regions are in extreme peripheral location only a routistic goal on the map . our unemployment ratios belong to the highest union . i am pleased over the fact that the committee accepted the requests for modification with large majority , submitted by me . i hold it for particularly important that the regions in extreme peripheral location are integrated in european-wide traffic , energy and telecommunications nets . the unanimous approval of the report by the members of the committee for regional policy , submitted by our colleague margie sudre , is a proof of the loyalty of the european parliament to one of its most important obligations . we cannot discuss here the whole conditions and believe that it with reaching this contently placing to seize idyllischen situation - if we it times in such a way to call want - will be no longer necessary , for the treatment of these three zones and in particular the regions in extreme peripheral location , which we today speaks further measures . this article does not put us into the position to do everything but makes possible it us to strengthen and - that consider i necessary - extend our working and improve . during the preparation of the necessary suggestions the commission co-operates naturally with the member states and the regions concerned . the difficulties of these regions point - how we know - a durable character up , and therefore i believe that they are durably on the support by the regional policy and on special measures dependent depending upon their actual development level . in the course of the yearly 2001 such a meeting could be accomplished again , if we continued to come with the conversion in march of the submitted program a piece . it was decided by the presidency that this affair is final , and i accept this without reservations . my judgement should the parliament to the at present valid rules adhere best , because there is frequent - as another colleague already said - not the devices , which did not function , but individual delegates forgot to co-ordinate . and if one could later correct a tuning , then we would never come to end . i am actual , which i eat . last end , mr . kommissar , is necessary it , apart from the authority , that the responsible services of the commission in co-operation and in coordination with the member states establish a system of homogeneous and effective controls in the entire food chain and that the network of food laboratories in the european union developed and in co-ordination with the commission becomes active . since it may not come in the scientific research to overlaps , must be co-operated with national research institutes and the european union research centers . today we discuss a white paper , whereby we leave ourselves lain close be should to specify some important principles . these procedures were in the meantime improved and changed , in addition to have we in the united kingdom an agency for putting central standards furnished . finally i would like to point out that we also support some the new requests for modification , like the requests for modification 11 to 13 and 7 to 9 . to the request for modification 14 we demand a tuning without party discipline . before this background i would like to say the following: first of all , which knows food security is guaranteed only if one accomplishes strict official controls , and these controls are only in each case as effectively as the weakest member in their chain . we discuss here a topic , at which proves completely clearly , how superficial and contentsless our debate is over the political agreement of europe . we entrust thus the european authority for food security alone with the scientific examination in co-operation with our national authorities . that is important . most food-conditioned diseases , by which europe is affected today , arose first on the american continent . however the conditions for calling the authority must be determined in such a way that efficient and rapid acting is ensured . we should refer also to it , as some my previous speakers in particular also mr . whitehead and mrs . gebhardt it did it that the white paper is very much more than possibly a new set of rules of the union . mr . praesident ! i feel today joy and gratitude , both in relation to the commission , that introduced the work for a better food security , and opposite mr . bowis and the entire committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics . as particularly important i judge request for modification 17 , in which a co-operation of the consumer associations is demanded . a further criterion is the complex examination of the legislation over labeling of food both for the large and for the retail trade , by which the consumer regarding the traceability of the products and their added finally correctly informed and which are made possible for determination of any responsibilities with risks and crises . new legislation is not my judgement the correct reaction , if existing regulations are not kept . with the tuning in the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics we succeeded in re-establishing a certain balance by we the range of application extended by the nourishing problems and took up some important notes to the role of small and middle enterprises for the receipt of the different nourishing habits . mr . praesident , i would like to follow the other colleagues and congratulate the correspondent , mr . bowis , to its very constructional and logical approach this problem . mr . praesident ! the fact that the white paper does not possess validity in law for food security , impairs the double meaning , which comes to it without doubt , by not means . the correspondent as well as very many members of our committee , under it also i , put the reproduction on the food authority , which actually is to some extent unfortunate . with independence and integrity is served the authority the position of the european consumers best . in run this process i frequently thought that we had a lucky hand with the selection of the correspondent . mr . praesident , also i would like to express mr . kollegen bowis my congratulations for its praise-worth attempt to let all opinions flow into his report and would like him above all also for the fact to thank that he accepted the reference to the more general term of the nutrition . finally the policy may not extract itself from its responsibility . the most important task is however that itself this committee the respect of other scientific committees , which acquires confidence of the public and the readiness of the governments in the member states to accept the decisions made by it . thus i see a food authority for the future . we have the world health organization in geneva . i do not conceal also that i expressed myself with the publication of the white paper against the authority . it applies to ensure therefore that the european union has the highest food safety standards , but must in the context of this beginning encountering unanimous agreement also the economic consequences for the producers be analyzed . the field of the authority covers then: independent scientific research and consultation , independent controls and inspections as well as an early warning system , but surely also coordination for the re-establishment of the confidence . on this occasion i would like the speakers , who demanded a careful solution regarding the promotion of local specialities and traditional products of food , insure that this topic in the hygiene regulations is considered . it will facilitate it for the commission to submit a balanced suggestion in which the position of the parliament and those of the many participants within the range of food security are considered as far as possible . our parliament does not concern itself for the first time with the topic anti-person mines , but this problem gave rather beside others in political regard the excursion for the signing of the convention of ottawa . i affirm my refusal of the requests for modification 10 and 19 , because of the coherency of the budget , and request for the request for modification 29 a separate tuning over the individual parts , in order the formulation of the entire text , which suffers my judgement at certain misinterpretations improve . and here the first question arises: the countries , which did not sign , must be requested by the european union , above all the commission , for the signing of the convention of ottawa . mr . praesident , admired colleagues and colleagues ! we know all , which consequences have the anti-person mines , although there are often large military reasons in individual cases . the parliament for the first time brought this topic 1996 on the agenda , when it demanded a horizontal household line and a normal legal basis , in order to create a uniform platform for the broad pallet of our actions in this important range . i cannot verhehlen however that the persuasive power of the european union is limited opposite other countries by the fact something that in some member states still problems exist regarding the signing and ratification of the convention . the effectiveness of mine clearing actions is largest , if these are individually to the special conditions of the respective situation cut . the parliament knows that there are of it already too many . how you also know , we want to move us away with our suggestions on the reform of the external assistance of the complex examination from single projects and with the discussion with the member states instead on general strategies and programs to concentrate . numerous nro was created , which concerns itself with this problem . nevertheless must we four years after first conference united nations to problem land mines in geneva and over year after the entry into force convention of ottawa to determine that many countries and thousands of humans , predominantly in the poorest regions of the world , still in frightening extent of the danger , which of anti-person land mines and projectiles and ammunition , which did not explode , are suspended . the commission must improve the quality of their programs and accelerate their execution . if you examine these requests for modification again completely exactly , then you will however state my judgement that some the requests clearing-up campaigns , transparency , entrance of the nro to the made available means , specified by you , and things to concern , which function quite properly at present , whose efficiency can be however still improved . mrs . bonino and mr . patten are also right with her opinion that parliament and advice should keep out from the administration . i listened to mr . patten in this point very exactly , since he is obvious the opinion , we should interfere still less . mr . praesident , our parliamentary group engages himself already for many years for the entire spectrum of the demands and actions necessary within this range - from the production stop over the destruction of the mine existence , the attitude of the marketing , the evacuation of the mines up to the rehabilitation of the mine victims and for the sensitization of the public . afterwards it is the task of the states to support this process on international level . the mines represent naturally a large obstacle for the reconstruction in these countries as well as for the return of the refugees . with the present speed the evacuation we became - as was said before here - far more than 100 years to need , in order to clean the earth from the anti-person mines to . when i see third range concrete measures , which one suggests , to examine and reconstruct should . each child , whom we protect elsewhere in bosnia , africa and mine death or terrible injuries , is worth the effort of us to all . it must be exercised indeed pressure on the countries , which did not sign yet , as for instance finland , or which did not ratify yet , as for instance greece . very honoured colleagues and colleague , regard them once finland ! and finally we that in the context of the future tasks of the common european armed forces specialists , hope above all humans are trained locally , to who somewhat because of the fact is that the mines disappear . and they underline just as few that on the list of the countries most strongly concerned above all developing countries stand . the demands of the parliament could contradict hardly more clearly the goals of lisbon . the berichterstatterin , mrs . van lancker , wants that the parliament decides changes of the suggestion of the commission , as well as particularly by adding different ranges , in those laws is attached by the definition of certain rights on european level . so the luxembourg process , which applies to the employment policy , is on which social protection and the social ausgrenzung is expanded . the great powers germany , france , great britain and in certain measure also italy are itself all over the fact united that they want to subject the small east or southeuropean countries , which would like to join the european union to their rule . we hold it however for legal reasons for missed , on them already now in kind . to take 6 euv purchase , because she could be decided in the convention - in accordance with its structure - not formally and therefore no legal existence has . the admission of new texts into the contracts could lead to legal uncertainties . in all other respects the correspondent makes himself i .e . the language pipe of the new theory of the double legitimacy in such a way specified of the european union , modern in brussels , the citizen represented by the european parliament and the states represented by the advice . the swedish and danish social democrats were correct today against the report of olive duhamel over the konstitutionalisierung of the contracts . in addition the european union must develop toward a condition , which includes the charter of the fundamental rights . a condition would be meaningful only if it would form the democratic framework for a genuine european federation , a kind united states europe . he said , he had arrived in agreement with a majority of the political class at the realization that we would like to rather know our relations with the other countries by an international contract regulated . . (en) i welcome the report of mr . duhamel as interesting and constructional contribution for the concept of the konstitutionalisierung of the contracts . we are the view that a reorganisation and a simplification of the contracts would facilitate it for the citizen to recognize the competence of the european union - and their borders - as well as the procedures for the perception of this responsibility clearly . up to the contract of amsterdam in the year 1997 europe was an intergovernmental supersyndicate . the edd parliamentary group is correct against the report co-operation intensified by gil robles gil delgado over . it reveals the view of an all too monolithic union , in which within a "uniform institutional framework" take place each form of co-operation and is to the goal of a superstate to be aligned . therefore a general slowing down must be prevented , as by the development of intensified co-operation a more rapid procedure is made possible for certain member states . the structures of the domestic market very successfully function since beginning of the 90's . - (nl) co-operation on european level can be useful for the solution of transnational problems . these regions could serve as outstanding research station for lasting development possibilities . the technokraten and the european judges wanted to abolish for example the special tax "octroi de more mer" , which supplies our citizens in the overseas sections with resources and protects above all our craftsmen . france however possesses sections in the indian ocean and in the karibik . their independence is an essential condition for their reliability . our tuning contributed thus to clarifying the role and the composition of the planned european authority , but it specified also our requirements to its financing and its independence . secondly the european agency must be perfectly independent . one must the kind of the agricultural and agro agroindustriellen practices , the problem of the food goods imported goods , the composition of the components of the animal feeds , the maximum limits for dioxin and for pestizidrueckstaende , which consider additives for food and other one and which food security priority grant . we were correct for the request for modification 15 , because the defense of the cultural heritage of europe is to us in the range of the food production locally much because of the heart . in practically no expenditure category a clearance remains to us . there we would like to set now also 50 % into the household line and 50 % into the reserve . the question is , as this can be agreed with one another . report (a5-0300/2000) by mrs . haug in the name of the budget committee for the draft of the total budget plan of the european union for the financial year 2001 - single diagramme iii , commission (c5-0300/2000 - 1999/2190 (bud)) mrs . praesidentin ! my name appears under several requests for modification to this report . (the parliament accepts the resolution request . ) the true surprise of this budget lies in the external politics policies , where egoism and knauserei prevail . also by a use of the flexibility instrument means can be set free . . (el) i have haug against the report and for the suggestion of my parliamentary group to reject the total budget 2001 been correct . we think thereby in particular of the new pilot project , within whose framework information measures are financed for the fight of the paedophilie . not least this fact shows the small commitment for the european union project , even under the politically active citizen . in this way is given 20 to 30 % of the markets again to the private competition . since this is not secured with available report , i was correct against the report . if one regards inakzeptabel the low national thresholds , which dezimieren the aids , in connection with the suggested shortening of the cancelling quantities on 5 % with zitrusfruechten , on 8 ,5 % with apples and pears as well as on 10 % with the remaining fruit and vegetable places , then it becomes clear that enormous quantities of verarbeitungserzeugnissen cannot be set off from fruit and vegetable any longer , which the prices press altogether the fruit and vegetable on the fields and in the processing plants will force rot to let and thus the farmers to roden their planting . i was correct for this report , because he corresponds to expectations of the portuguese organizations of the fruit and vegetable sector , which demanded a drastic change of the gmo for fruit and vegetable , since they the opinion are that this harms the national interests deeply . report johan van hecke (a5-0296/2000) the root of the evil lies in the fact that everything , even the quality of the environment and the climate , which capitalistic exploitation of productive resources and the superprofits is sacrificed . starting point in kyoto was that the rich countries keep their air pure , whereby they have the possibility however to limited extent later of booking the emission reductions reached with their assistance in other countries on its own result list . - (fr) the fight against the greenhouse effect is a large challenge for the industrialized countries and an obligation in particular opposite the peoples of the third world , which the consequences of the climatic heating up already pay with its life . the art of the life consists of dealing with these risks and uncertainties appropriately . also the efforts to investigate the assumed endokrin effective substances more accurately are to be continued ­ possibly with the help of a right framework ­ and strengthened . and the domestic market completed with the introduction of the euro brings the kmu to the consumers not sufficient profit . the banks are up to now by the member states obligated to announce transnational payments over 12 ,500 euro to balance of payments-doistic purposes of their central bank . of course the same strict editions apply regarding security and money laundering to it . we know even cases , in which remittance fees increased with the borderspreading exchange after the introduction of the euro , and not only around a small amount . the european central bank could help , with the penetration of a uniform european data format in the exchange and with the support the penetration of a uniform european bank code number within the international iban system . the fact that the consumers accept the euro is of crucial importance . mrs . praesidentin , the report of mrs . peijs over the mass exchange in the domestic market takes up the old demand of the european parliament concerning the high costs of the borderspreading exchange in the union again . the report peijs determines this in consideration consideration of d of the draft resolution , where it means that the high fees for international credit transfers shake "the confidence of the consumers in the euro" . here there give to thus do still much , but the means and possibilities of the politicians , which , which we can do , are in this area smaller than our scope of action in the question of the exchange on the domestic market . the euromarket is felt also in the future as binnenraum , and the citizen does not understand that in this area , in that rate of exchange risks become increasingly natural to be omitted and the electronic currencies with internet banking , a transfer from munich to salzburg is substantially more expensive than a transfer from munich to kiel . on the implementation of this goal we as well as you still many years will have to work . on this occasion we will speak also about a shorter duration of the completion of transnational transfers , on which in the report by mrs . peijs one penetrates . the discussion is closed . the correct policy consists probably of giving a pragmatic and kmu close concept the priority which makes the small business the principal item of the equipment , and not a suggestion , which would only serve under the pretext to want to avoid the watering can principle to produce for it , correct statistics which uses concretely to nothing would be . but concretely i have three notes to this program . it is reminded of the fact that the first joint scheme in this area was accepted 1983 , i .e . before 17 years . i was also always for the fact that this should take place on the basis of an efficient and pragmatic policy . i would call it genuine vorposten of the economy and the innovation , which are located in foremost front and in these ranges existing risks are directly suspended which . finally we must carry also , as well as the subsequent work for the results of the colloquium "science and government" , which took place past week in brussels under the patronage of the institute for technological future research in sevilla to this colloquium calculation , because there are numerous points of contact there to our current topic . the berichterstatterin lists several emphasis , in order to improve the basic conditions for enterprises in europe . that is excellent for europe , because technically correctly , competently and fast can be helped . mr . praesident , also i would like to follow the thank words for the outstanding work of the colleague montfort . is important to weigh well to avoid a situation in the people at expense other one constantly fail . that is unfair , why i support this report ! this is also the guidance principle of the charter for small businesses . the program will be so put on that this information about the nets is made available . the principal purpose of this plan the containment of the zuwanderung is obvious in the countries of the european union as well as the back assumption of all in europe illegaly living persons into its homeland . in particular i refer to it that measures for the improvement of internal security , for the intensification of the dialogue between the europeans and the local bodies in albania as well as - so far it the commission and the advice concerns , in co-operation with the albanian , which is necessary italian and the greek authorities purposeful actions . unsatisfactory social , economical and political conditions in combination with missing and/or unsatisfactory right security and organized criminality lead to substantial moving movements . mr . praesident , in contrast to the colleague luggage am i the view , the more groups with albania are concerned , the better been it . naturally we can not immediately find a solution for the entire problem , but medium-term we must create a world with appropriate justice , with security and future possibilities . beyond that a gap between the backers - us , which european union , and the united states - exists , who financial means makes available , projects write out and such on the one hand and the local population on the other hand . we use thus the bilateral agreements , which legally and clearly the activities , which duration of stopover , which place of residence , which remuneration , which work time , which conditions of work and the social security-legal conditions fix , so that the immigrants become a strength , which gets a managing going of our countries and instead of nationalistic efforts of the war cold in the spirit to the schueren friendship and co-operation of the peoples promotes . humans are sent back , who integrated themselves partially well . it may not be located however in the center how the stream of refugees and migranten are to be dammed , but like the situation in the region to be in such a way improved can that humans remain at home . mr . praesident , also i believes that , like colleague dimitrakopoulos noticed very applicable , the central question regarding the economical , social and the internal security of problems concerned of albania still therein exists , the country in the reconstruction of the constitutional state to support during the guarantee of security for the citizens and during the re-establishment of the reputation of the institutions and local administrations . i am like the colleague liese of the opinion that we need a load division with the asylum and refugee politics . the plan of action for albania and the adjacent regions was discharged in the june of this yearly . it concerns thereby thus the sixth plan of action . sometimes there frustration stops itself to work in addition , strangeness in relation to the european right , and we would like us , in addition , the other institutions for community to call not to shrink from here the muehsal of the detailed work precisely and to make available but also the necessary time and the necessary coworkers . we want to send a signal with this report to the citizens that we take the complaints over the quality lacking of the law-making and the complaints over over regionalization and centralism seriously . of course the topic is actually important extraordinarily , although the small number of the participants in now the discussion waiting in this hall for it actually speaks against it at first sight . beyond that the report raises inevitably the question of the subsidiaritaet , which are somewhat disputed in this plenum this evening . it would be to be arranged also that she makes a stocktaking of the legislation in the light of this principle , in order this more simply , more transparently , more efficient and more purposeful and painted by interest redundant legislation , how under number 6 of this report becomes lively . after very detailed examination of the report i arrived to the conclusion that it is also no political principle: it is more theological . that means thus the fact that acknowledgment subsidiaritaetsprinzips to in smallest municipalities , which regional administrative bodies , which inserted organizations , which social layers , which families and the citizens as only , which may really exercise the sovereignty over the legislation and the administrative activity , be guaranteed must . let me therefore a summary give . i give the word to the mr . kommissar . does it concern here an area , which we should adjust in detail , which is guaranteed everywhere converted , or should we consider , whether a freiwillige agreement can do , presupposed her is interspersed and controlled , an alternative are? - i was correct for the report , although i am not come through with some amendments , because he concerns himself also with the too high change and transfer costs in the euro-area . if in fifteen months then in eleven member states also still the same coins and notes are brought in traffic , the procurement of this uniform currency will increase in price outside of the own wohnsitzlandes . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , loves colleagues and colleagues ! i must express first my regret over the fact that the committee member , mr . fischler not here , responsible for the fishery , can be today . it must be an agreement , which lends impulses to fishery co-operation and the moroccan fishery sector , which in addition , the fishing interests of the european fleets considers fully . therefore we have united on the structure of a responsible partnership , whereby morocco will state its point of view in the context of a meeting , those , like you to have marked , on 30 october , thus on monday , in brussels take place ourselves . few weeks ago i was in algeciras at the spanish south coast . that lies not far from morocco . in the course of the time it showed up that she is not only difficult , but even as impossible to turn out could . by the fishery agreements the union can fishery activities accomplish and with the third countries of fishery rights adapt . in a swedish fishery technical periodical was to be read , how one of these ships brought its catch in el aaiún ashore , which as moroccan port was described . all this is questioned . our fishery agreements go and not only around with morocco around all , because also the agreement with mauritania and soon with guinea will also come on the test stand . 11 months it used in order to arrive at the turning point , to the consultation on 30 .10 . , reached now , and to that extent we appreciate also the last measures of commissioner fischler the results of its journey from 26 september to morocco and on high level , even with the king , led discussions . but i would like to convey gladly some completely short messages to the commission , that will with dignity represent busquin today by commissioner . my question to the commission reads: if no agreement with morocco is reached or if the present agreement is locked on the conditions signaled by the commission , an agreement for the stimulation of moroccan production , intends to seize the commission then structural measures for the reconciliation of the arrears , which will develop in the regions concerned? as we had foreseen it , the negotiations with the moroccan authorities became extremely difficult . if the unwanted result of the failure of the negotiations should occur , the union has finally the political and moral obligation to support fischer and schiffseigner with sufficient aids which secure their living costs for them . the over-capacities of the fish industry of the european union must be diminished . therefore we need as rapidly as possible close economic and political relations with morocco with simultaneous penetration of our european fishing interests . therefore the commission works on the basis of a new partnership useful for both sides , those on the one hand the comprehensive promotion of the fishery sector in morocco , the fleet , the aquaculture , which covers commercial processing and the research as well as on the other hand the grant of catch possibilities to european fischer . the right language teacher "this is not only in the german language a clear difference . in july 1999 the commission brought this violation of contract procedure before the court of justice . if it does not come thus to the harmonization of the systems desired by us , it may lie therefore , as the things today which do not lead attention of the subsidiaritaetsprinzips to the fact that what a demand is most likely after a privilege , when discrimination is dismissed . admitted , the previous commission under mr . santer was not perhaps the best , therefore it went also . to state members committee for right and domestic market from entire union and from all parties have itself here met , in order to occur that it no sense has to speak about rights and for right charters , if one does not seize in material arising cases , in which the human rights are refused , effective measures , so that they are recognized and interspersed , and therein lies in this case the problem . that is in modern europe actually does not add . naturally the education range still falls under the subsidiaritaet , but in the context of the contracts the liberality of the employees and the discrimination prohibition are own to us all , although we - and i particularly , because i come from a very federal state - to the subsidiaritaetsprinzip as order principle of co-operation in the european union profess themselves and us for the fact use that as rapidly as possible the allocations of authority between the levels in europe are arranged according to the subsidiaritaetsprinzip . in this connection cannot be no more by discrimination the speech . mr . praesident , you could be operated from an excellent connoisseur of the surgical technical terms in italian , french and german or from a surgeon? (the meeting is closed at 10 .56 o'clock . ) we express them our deeply felt sympathy . the word has mr . ceyhun ; he speaks as a correspondent and also in the name of the social-democratic parliamentary group . regarding the explanations of the advice and the commission to the third asia european meeting the advice communicates us that it does not wish to deliver to time an explanation . therefore it is a question , which lies after the contracts and after the euratom contract in the competence of the commission ; it concerns many citizens or can many citizens to concern , and not excluding spaniards , since in this zone and in their catchment area , for which there is not even a state of emergency plan , live hundredthousands european citizens from the 15 states of the union , apart from the many , which come from outside , because it here nevertheless concerns the costa del sol . mrs . praesidentin , it is sad , but very informative to hear of the spanish minister of the interior , mr . mayor oreja , that discussions with the baskischen nationalists were senseless , even if a future armistice thereby it jumped out . may i inquire whether for this week an explanation of the commission is planned for the decision of the british government to introduce a discriminating tax for not-british transportation of goods by road entrepreneurs? since the liberals in such a way specified parties , also , bend the european ever more to it , and authoritarianly gesinnten forces to groups , that is with strange-hostilely , racistic not only a serious danger for italy , but it points also on a problem , which concerns europe completely . the report contains however also critical remarks to the french suggestion . these demands are topic of the requests for modification nr . 2 and 4 of the report karamanou . the initiative of the french presidency , over which we advise today , has to improve the two aforementioned general legal aid conventions in criminal actions , in particular within the range of the fight of the money laundering , to the goal . i can to it say only if the idea of the fight of the money laundering is damaged , then am this the debt of the advice and not the parliament . to the results of their work we can only congratulate to them . the way there leads naturally , like mr . marinho says - and i am whole its opinion - , about the pooling . all speakers agreed up to now in the fact that this is a very valuable initiative , and we follow it . euro pole must be able to operate over borders away . of it it gives still too much in our modern europe , and before i approve a rushed into acknowledgment , i would like to see first the mutual acknowledgment of fair standards carried out . i understand that it is very difficult , because we must proceed with the structure from a splintering of the instruments . in addition , that is a necessity to consider in order to strengthen the economic situation european union , and it is also a desire of the citizens , to who we have , because the citizens of the european union are a right to security . we must lead an unyielding fight against the money laundering in the european union and be us across the fact in the clear one that it requires an effective police and justitiellen co-operation between the member states - as effective as possible - particularly after the establishment of the domestic market and after the liberalisation of the markets for capital and financial services . entitled with an activity as financial advisers nothing to the acceptance , which lawyer as such would not exercise its occupation . nevertheless are i me natural consciously that the question raised by several delegates is very delicate on the conditions , on which the privacy of the legal occupations can justify the refusal of justitiellen co-operation within the range of the fight of the money laundering . that applies in particular to heavy , heaviest and transnational crimes . altogether the task is so large and so important that it cannot be mastered by the advice alone . from it the necessity results to strengthen the rights of the citizens by creating an expedient right instrument and recognizing the competence of the court of justice , in particular regarding questions of the interpretation as well as decisions . even if i occur for more co-operation and coordination , consider i nevertheless the project to make from it a right framework wrong , why we will be correct against it . also a second point is from interest . therefore the comprehensive participation is so pleasing in this house . since several delegates addressed very delicate questions , i would like to use this opportunity , in order you in all openness - how this mr . coelho did straight - , to say that we see the first initiative in this initiative above all , in which political will of the advice to the expression it comes to catch up that in the comparison to police co-operation existing arrears in the range of justitiellen co-operation . therefore it is for me also important instrument , in order to guarantee judicial control of euro pole . the program fair for the research within the ranges fishery , agriculture and agro industry was part of the iv . research master program , which ran from 1994 to 1998 . in view of the meaning of the research program for the agriculture and fishery it is unfortunate that some problems were determined , which concern the organization of the program . the report of the audit office over the program fair , to which the report langenhagen refers , was only published in the march of this yearly , while the sector letters were conveyed for the first time for audit in december 1998 and in february 1999 of the commission . in the name of the committee for fishery i would like to refer to some few points . they have thank-worth-prove referred to the atmosphere , in which the report developed ; it was located in the indication of the dialogue with the audit office and the agencies of the commission ; and they made clear , how important to you this is . that shows that the commission was not dormant and that it takes your remarks seriously . i come now to the question of mrs . morgan , who addressed a drawing in of paid amounts . thank you , mr . kommissar . the presentation is to take place during the december conference . it means , even if it some state and head of the government do not want to admit , after my deep conviction also the opening from this parliament of so often and so persistent demanded condition process . i am extraordinarily pleased that i have today the opportunity to debate with you in detail this trefflichen draft of the fundamental right charter of the european union before you adopt the locking statement of your house to this text . i meinerseits do not doubt that the opportunity will be offered in addition . there were however also some critical expressions to contents of the charter . this is an important point of view , which i welcome . it was for us as parliament a large success - and the parliamentary groups stood together here , which is a positive result - that we interspersed it that the european parliament with 16 delegates was represented in this fundamental right convention . the available charter is , as i find , a large throw and can , how it called a large european newspaper on 26 september 2000 , the visiting card for europe become . therefore it considers my parliamentary group absolutely fundamental to take up to the article 6 paragraph 2 of the contract a reference to the charter . so many have to establish indeed believed that europe thereby would have finally the possibility of overcoming its existence as bare foreign trade zone and the withdrawn path of the liberalism in order the bases of europe of the citizens . the civil company is decided to mobilize themselves and to raise to the european summit in december in nice their voice and demand a charter , which offers real warranties for the citizens of europe . for this it requires beside the signatures of also effective political obligations , the day for day by all member states and all political forces to be carried out must . let us cry therefore or do in such a way , as if we are pleased , let us this large event celebrate , which is nontheless insignificant . the convention carried excellent work out . both the personality rights , the citizen rights and the social rights . the right to a good administration , which was mentioned also by mrs . malmstroem , places represents one of the most important progress . i am not safe , how much clearance mr . blair grants its gefolgsleuten , in order to express itself to this great project . heard i anyhow still nothing . you spoke mrs . praesidentin , the last mark of the half full or half empty glass . but the advice of cologne reached with support of the committee , which played its role as a founder of confusion marvelously , finally that all world forgot that it concerns here a competence of the national parliaments , which can be decreased this straight in the context of a policy of the small steps . excessive fundamental right protection is just as harmful as more insufficient ! if one hears the contributions of some delegates , one states that this information more necessarily ever is . the large question , at which the spirit separates now , concerns the purpose of the charter . we are thus again once disappointed and dissatisfied . of course we will be correct for the charter , however with the feeling that thereby the nevertheless so necessary enthusiasm and the commitment of the citizens cannot be caused for europe , for which like usually the governments - and some more than the others - which become historical responsibility to take over to have . to the correspondent , mr . duff , according to this represents an important step for the improvement of the quality of the european integration . who has the need in addition , i recommend a study of the explanations of the convention 49 as well as case law the two courts of justice connected with the charter . mr . praesident ! for the first time since establishment of the european union the foundation-stone for a condition is put here , a condition for the supranational thing , as it represents the union . they however understood nothing . we demonstrate for social and democratic europe , for europe of the citizens . up to then the charter available in the draft can serve the parties , trade unions , environmental protection organizations , churches and numerous further groupings in the member states and candidate countries of the union than interesting basis for the discussion over future co-operation between the peoples of europe . i would like to deal with three points , which runs in the in the morning by my colleagues was already addressed . the charter , which is to be decided today by us , does not only strengthen the common fundamental rights and values , the basis of our community to be is , it makes it also visible . therefore i follow naturally those , which aim at a reference to the charter in article 6 and their later admission into the contracts . we think only of the case berne pool of broadcasting corporations connolly , whose critical book concerning the commission could not be published after a decision of the court of first instance . this clarification is from special importance to one time , since the union is confronted with the task to commit itself the legal status regarding the rights and obligations legally of the members of third states , stopping in the european union . i am meinerseits exactly as he convinced of the fact that she will have some immediate effects and that it will receive in the near future an obligatory character . in run the discussion has i unite striking formulations heard , so the charter is a bone for the dog , whereby the dog should be the european parliament , or it is the fig sheet for all what gave a agonisierende french presidency up in particular with the guidance of the diplomatic conference . this our parliament arranged to suggest the mechanism of of a european-turkish forum in which qualified representatives of of the turkish community and european parliamentarians , who received in addition the mandate , employ together which are received considerations . unanimity does not mean however the fact that we would agree with the democracy development in turkey and the way , how with the human rights is gone around there . apart from it , i know naturally that the candidacy of turkey raises further questions . the presidency wishes that this draft is accepted immediately , as already as possible of the next advice "general affairs" on 20 november and , like i this already stated , considering the very precise decisions made in helsinki . it applies however , which very clearly said the commission in its progress report , turkey must , as all other candidate countries also , in the context of the advancing process the kopenhagener criteria to fulfill . president sezar said in his speech before the turkish parliament in the last month with all clarity , why there is no alternative to this reform course for turkey . i thank you for your attention ! there were some easily positive signals also here . we reject the partially unauthorized efforts , with which the equilibrium so successfully obtained in the report is to be disturbed . that applies particularly to those requests for modification , with which the european parliament is to be raised to the judge over the past of turkey . this is fact , just as it fact is that turkey , how each civilized society must resign itself , to the necessity to set itself with their past apart may have also been so terribly it . the membership of turkey on such a basis and not only from geostrategic considerations of the usa or nato would represent an enriching of the european union and an important step to united europe . did one forget that only a small part of the turkish territory belongs to the european continent? we will be correct therefore against this report , how we were correct against all reports , which pursued the goal of the inclusion of turkey into the european union . damage does not develop , if in turkey hopes for an entry were aroused , these in view of the political situation however to be above all then fulfilled can . report (a5-0310/2000) by mrs . langenhagen in the name of the committee for household control of the special report nr . 9/1999 of the audit office over research measures within the range of the agriculture and the fishery , program fair (research within the range of the fishery , the agriculture and the agro industry) , together with the answers of the commission (c5-0227/2000 - 2000/2133 (cos)) i welcome this report and for him will be correct . instead of lifting the human rights and the social rights to a higher level , it facilitates the efforts to press these on a smaller level . unquestionably it is to finally serve as foundation-stone for a future european condition , which should be the coronation/culmination of the development of the european union for its part to a federal thing , into the decisions , now with appropriate validity in law , of some few and strong to be met and of all converted . the principal purpose consists of generally serving interests the monopoly capital of the european union to loads of the interests of the persons employed and the peoples . a typical case for it is in article 2 abs . to find 2: "nobody may be condemned or executed to the death penalty . anywhere despite our demands it is not specified that a family exists out a man and a woman , whom children draw up , and that the basic cell of the society forms them . this represents a restriction of the democratic commonwealth considering the fact that these judges were not selected . surely i would have wanted that she would have been taken up immediately to our european contracts ! nevertheless i contained during the final vote , since i the opinion am that some social rights are formulated less clearly than the economic rights . originally the convention had assumed that to compile in the consent a text to which the member states would lend legal effect by admission into the contracts . to place in reality the fight of the social ausgrenzung on the level of the social welfare assistance limited instead of the demand after opposite the employers and the state of compelling fundamental rights . i for my part am convinced that the laizitaet is an emancipatory value up-to-date . likewise the social requiringness of the property is missing . this document is unsuitable as obligatory document , since it does not represent a right text . delegate of the irish parliament employs the question since short , in what respect brussels endangers the irish identity , and mr . ahern sees in the european union membership of ireland a basic condition for prosperity and economic success , at the same time leans he however all steps over-hurried in the direction of strengthens foederales - centralized - europe off , since this would encounter the desires of most europeans to contradict and refusal . guess/advise times , what interspersed itself . i would like to mark at the edge that in this parliamentary session altogether seven reports decrease/go back to national initiatives , which proves that this system proves , where it exists in the long run as very productive . these purposeful measures are completely indispensable for the fight of this feature , which constantly develops itself further and internationalizes . with this initiative the french advice presidency suggests a framework resolution for the adjustment of the criminal regulations and procedures on the area of the money laundering (determination , freezing and seizure of yields) . all member states should treat and with an imprisonment by at least four years occupy money laundering as a criminal offence . since the money laundering accepted world-wide enormous extents , we can work against only by an expansion of the powers of euro pole , whereby it concerns in the long run the development of a european strategy for police and justitielle co-operation to the fight of the money laundering . i welcome the report roure to a further initiative of the french advice presidency . in this case it goes around the improvement of justitiellen co-operation to the avoidance of obstacles , which prevent distribution of washing yields from criminal offences as well as the financial criminality suspicious offenders . mrs . praesidentin , this is the only report , to which i did not give my agreement . it would be the first member of the union , which the gap to asia geographically bridged and which has a predominantly moslemische tradition . that applies in particular to this stage , in which we use gradually ever more eib means , without covering however our financial risks fully . in this connection i underline the main conclusion in number 22 , turkey fulfill the kopenhagener criteria , and do not refer to the numerous condemnations of actions and omissions of turkey regarding the human rights , the democratic liberties and their international occurrence as well as to the appropriate recommendations of the european parliament to this country to adapt to the relevant european values . mr . praesident , the fact worries us , that from official representatives of turkey and of sides of the turkish press at present no encouraging raids are into this direction recognizable , but rather the attempt is undertaken to oppose this development . nikosia is today , 11 years after the case of the citizens of berlin wall , the only divided capital of europe . the necessary progress is not reached yet in sufficient measure , and turkey must give itself further trouble . mr . praesident , mr . ratspraesident , mr . kommissar , rates colleagues and colleagues ! i would like to take part in my characteristic as correspondents for the entry of cyprus in this discussion . mr . praesident , we morillon cannot be correct for the report , because we are safe that against the statements and hopes of many humans also in turkey the entry procedure will not improve the life of the peoples . but i am simultaneous the opinion that one should not sketch to black picture of the situation . there there is thus an internal relationship . conference of european mediterranean in marseille mr . brok , who is pushed to us now , addressed the straight delays determined in the negotiations . here we have european experiences , which we can pass on . in the reason it concerns no longer only like 1995 to manufacture a new balance opposite eastern europe but also , to prepare the future extension of the union . xenophobie , state terrorism or other kinds of terrorism belong into this range also inside , and i hope that there is the chance also here to bring the things in order . with this fact we must unfortunately live . in addition , here we should be open . all on it that one is aware of the inadequacy of the results reached so far , but do not become fair the proposals for solution of my judgement of the situation point yet , although admittedly five years for so complicated ranges are surely not much . therefore our current discussion can contribute to it , us the central meaning , which has this politics for the entire union to make conscious . there may not be competition between all these needs , but we must find new means . the spiral of the force in the near east , the consciously led cruel war against the palestinian population , to who israel still refuses its right to its own state , threatens the future of the whole region . mr . praesident , as the european union in nice their balance between recess and extension to find must create , should her in marseille a balanced relationship between their centraleuropean function and her mediterranen responsibility . however prevails in this days frequently pulled balances from five years barcelona process conception forwards that we us with bare continuity process , with which fact that consultation on minister level under participation of representatives of israel , which palestinian administrative authorities , syria , of lebanon took place the etc . contently to give to be able . that may be a poor comfort . the common problems existing today in the mediterranean region are numerous: illegal immigration , poverty , foreign debts , human rights , dryness and the terrorism , which destroy compassionless the life of innocent humans and families , as the tragic events show in spain , algeria or the near east . we want to believe that , but the countries of the south need more than speeches and promises . that we must give them . europe did not operate politics regarding wuestenbildung or the industrial water of the mediterranean countries , and one must consider an environmental policy for the mediterranean area , which of the coordinates , which ways of thinking and also the climatic variety of this area goes out . i find the current suggestions far more balanced . now to the agency in the kosovo . we may not disappoint their expectations ; all these countries need our assistance today more than ever . in the end i would like to say - and i repeat thereby the words of the commission - the fact that these two suggestions represent the trick and pivot of a process , which for the complete inclusion of these countries , which had so many problems and to have , into which leads european structures . we must fasten in the future the responsibility at few , also at a director , if you want so , so that really the responsibility carries opposite the committee , which selects these individual programs . i thank thus all colleagues and colleagues , who judged this goal as important , and am thus pleased that we can bring in in the future in this range more also at contents into these countries . in some reports on the elections in bosnia i , the ultranationalisten read the parliamentary elections in bosnia-herzegovina would have won . as you know , the european union engaged itself with reproduction , in order to contribute to these historical changes . the consultation over the reports westendorp and lagendijk to a regulation to the master program and/or to the european agency for the reconstruction is us cause to refer again to the range of the support which wants to grant the union to the western balkans countries for the company of the stabilization and association process . the long expected victory of the democracy in croatia and then in the federal republic of yugoslavia requires from the union , how we know to go still further . question time (advice) since they concern the same topic , the inquiries become nr . 2 and nr . recently with the resolution 1324 a further period was granted to the parties from four months , in order to try be attained at both fronts of progress . i would like to ask you for the conditions of the association agreement with morocco . the stability and the development of the caucasus represent one of the strategic priorities for the european union . which concerns the discussions with turkey , then we had a straight extensive discussion to this topic , and the point of view of the union to this point is well-known you in detail . i would like to ask the mr . minister to stress again that these suggested legislation aims at all those , which strike profit from humans , who are in an emergency situation , to kriminalisieren and that it does not concern , immigrants or potential immigrants further . both requires appropriate legislation and measures for a more comprehensive discussion and a stronger public consciousness . according to my opinion one must fight to all means with all means , really against these crimes , and i state that both the advice of the union and the general assembly of the united nations and , as i believe also the turkish government are ready to do this . and evenly because the 14 disapproved other countries it , they seized measures . as example: if tomorrow in my country , france - and i speak here as a minister - came a right-wing extremist a party to power , then i would wish that one seizes measures against my country , as they were met against austria . i wanted to speak of values: i mentioned the values , like her am embodied in our treaty system , i spoke of values , as they were again affirmed in the fundamental right charter , and i spoke in particular - is correct - of the fight of any discrimination , which is placed in front all european texts . by it we must be guided . i would like to remind of the fact that this political dialogue apart from the future entry partnership forms one of the elements of the vorbeitrittsstrategie for turkey , specified at that time . nr inquires . 12 of (h-0850/00): but we exert ourselves , and excluding this line we will pursue . in addition it must be marked that the moroccan side did not answer to the community offer . these citizens originate from scotland , where prisoners on remand must after 110 days remand either a passing be accused or released , without one may again accuse her of the same passing . were specific measures seized (as for instance the safety device of the supplies and energy efficiency) , in order to ensure that the national economies of the member states are less susceptible to external crises , and which is the measures and short and medium-term priorities of the advice for energy efficiency and energy conservation? the position of the union to the specially-territorial measures ordered from the usa is unchanged . finally i reminded of the fact that the european union with concern took from the un agencies and ­ locally the statements met to programs to the knowledge , and regrets the negative and often dramatic effects of the american restaurant embargo for the cuban population . doesn't the advice see that it concerns expressed a political problem here and that the keeping of the same distance is opposite victim and author inakzeptabel? on the one hand this agency of the decision of the commission follows for decentralization , on the other hand one it has to show exzellente results during the execution it transferred task . those do not recognize borders on . transnational illegal activities whether within the range of the drug trade , transnational co-operation or the slave trade , must against us are fought . and it would be reasonable , if mr . kommissar cuffs , who possesses very much experience - around not to say wisdom - in handling international crises and in addition visited different regions of the balkans , once to the seat of the agency for the reconstruction , after thessaloniki , would go and would regard , how this agency works . but this wrong-examined region of europe of as full hope never before was as now . first i would like to thank the house for the fact that it examined the two regulation drafts so thoroughly and so briskly . also in serbia , where the commission arranged euro within only plentifully four weeks a soforthilfsprogramm in the value of 200 millions , rapidly results could be obtained . naturally we also the suggestion can agree that the guidelines which can be specified by the commission should reflect that our reforms at the basis lying props after more efficiency . i hope , which understands parliament the sense of the suggestions submitted by me in may and in this difficult question further constructionally with all involved ones will co-operate . i cannot support however the request of the parliament for cancellation of the unanimity regulation , since this contradicts the opinion of the kollegiums . the challenge for the third summit in seoul consisted of deepening the asem process both for government-lateral participants and for the broad public . which concerns the concrete inclusion of the citizens , then one held to the principle of the opening of the asem process for a broader segment of the civil company , although the initiative of the nro failed for the creation of a social forum because of the resistance some asiatic partners . to that extent we are very lucky that the summit conference in seoul took place and apart from in or two heads of the government were all heads of the government there . even two concrete suggestions assumed , in particular the round table for globalization and the duo fellowship program , 4 ,300 fellowships at a value of 25 million us dollar . the report of the commission is limited to the treatment of the aspects of the competencies of the community and the member states with the tasks due to the co-operation the organizations . if we assume from all sea neighboring states in the world only very few have the economical , legal , legislative and political potential , which possesses the european union , becomes understandable , as much we must ask ourselves , wherein our responsibility lies . is of special importance the reformation of the gfp , but it is still more important to decide for the correct reforms . hardly a fish has a firm domicile . we all are probably conscious to us its both in the european union and far beyond them . mr . praesident , my very much honoured ladies and mr . abgeordnete ! first of all i would like to thank you for the support with our efforts to promote and also strengthen the activity of the community in the regional fishery organizations . so far some progress could be obtained of course , but here one must strive particularly for a better temporal planning . the constant improvement of the productivity of the attitude enterprises entails already a rising of the offer , and if still another unrestricted expansion of the produktionsapparates is then added , this would lead inevitably again to a strong market imbalance . instead it is more meaningful that each pig meat producer forms its own reserve . thus each pig meat producer its own piggy bank . one refers also to the necessary promotion of the producer organizations , whose introduction is very different depending upon member state . the market regulations , how they worked so far , served the concentration process rather , than that they would have prevented it . the globalization of the economics proves in this case as case , and nothing at all has to do with cyclic crises . each pig owner everywhere in the union can join this instrument . mr . fischler ! the correspondent , mr . garot , treated the available suggestion of the commission on the mechanism of a fund for the pig meat sector very essentially and precisely . that is a question of reconciliation . in this sense i must confess nevertheless that i come to another conclusion than colleague garot and also with the commission suggestion , how he is present now i would like nearly to say , agree on the whole . if we are however honest , is actually irrelevant in the reason for the problem . then the inclusion of the specialized piglet producers into the suggested system , as in the requests for modification 7 and 13 to the expression comes . what , please-beautifully , submitted the commission to us? first the household execution and housekeeping practice in the individual columns are examined . therefore the audit office repeats its criticism and references of the past years over the negative effects of this practice , which founded for example through not sufficiently , over-hurried decisions , due to errors due to work overloading and so on develops . the dramatic developments of the recent past showed that management and control on european level become more important ever . thus the conscientious member states are financially punished , recompenced those less conscientious member states financially . i would like to mention in the connection also briefly that the improvement of the assistance with regard to foreign policy is altogether a range , which represents an emphasis of the commission work both regarding the institutional restructuring of this whole range and in the view on the fact that the high refuse dumps must be strengthened within this range and be processed faster as in the past . now the european parliament is in an extremely difficult situation , because it explained still in this year - in january - that it will not any longer accept that also the statement of account remains afflicted with serious errors for 1999 . i would like to point some problems out and i hope that mr . karlsson can answer my questions today . mr . karlsson said yesterday , the indication of numbers was not simple . i want to examine whether this is possible not already in this year . then we can begin to judge the central management . of course we know around the present efforts of reform of the commission . they will contribute to a decrease of the error rate . therefore the commission is judged now and in the future by to what extent the regulations are kept . first i would like to thank mr . karlsson for the fact that co-operation with the committee for household control worked in this year substantially better , than in the preceding years the case was . i request you in addition to publish a list of the countries which particularly out-do by bad office guidance to call and the ranges in which this the case am . mrs . praesidentin , also i would like to thank you the audit office for the report completely cordially yesterday and also for the political valuation of the yard in the committee for household control . there also still once the efforts of reform and their necessity were stressed . there that belongs inside , which a while ago by mrs . van the laan - and there are we us perfectly united - was said . in addition it could be necessary to extend the powers of the president of the audit office so that these decisions over the work methods of the audit office and its way of communication can meet . the control items and their composition are different from state to state . in his most important work to the common agricultural policy , the special report over the effects of the reform of the gap on the grain sector , one of the conclusions of the audit office read the fact that the community center stop from 1993 to 1997 more than 13 billion euro more paid than would have been meaningful . "it is senseless to place to me questions which one cannot answer . also the european audit office must change its function . it is a luck not to be involved into this procedure . this report was accepted in the environmental committee of the parliament with large majority , and therefore i will defend the result of the tuning in this committee . the second point concerns the a while ago so praised export prohibition . therefore i have to announce here very large reservations and this regulation gladly would reject . in a second or third reading we need the famous 314 voices , and we - is present now as this report - will not get those surely . the commission undertook a zaghaften , but very welcome step in this direction , and perhaps the commissioner can deal in his answer more in greater detail with it . larger reproduction is to be put to the statement of the berichterstatterin , on the information of the consumers about the risks and on transparency particularly within the range of the health and security , agrees we . rather we should consider more to the subsidiaritaetsprinzip . i remember however a hot discussion , which i led with my daughter at that time of nine years elisabetta , when she asked me to go however on the road . it had to be guaranteed that we ensure complete consumer protection , without regulating however things several times or possibly still contradictory . i would like to then emphasize the meaning of the requests for modification accepted in the environmental committee , by which transparency for the final consumer is increased and the responsibilities not only the manufacturer , but also the dealer with possible recall actions for as dangerously regarded products is more clearly intended . this means also that the appropriate regulations of this guideline are set out of strength , if new , sector-referred legislation will issue . many of the requests for modification suggested in the report represent an improvement of the text and can therefore by the commission be approved of . thirdly will in request for modification 4 the admission of a condition demanded , which is to be integrated into a preamble , after which the member states in co-operation with the responsible authorities and public or private independent mechanisms to the production by justified reports are obligated . although the commission supports co-operation and the development of common principles , the formulation of this request contradicts the subsidiaritaetsprinzip . the commission are present no referring to problems with the existing formulations , and which would lead suggested changes to an attenuation of the regulations . in the requests for modification 39 and 44 is suggested informing the public only about dangerous products if a prohibition of the inverkehrbringens or a recall were arranged , and between the authorities , which accomplish the market monitoring , the exchange of information protected by the professional secrecy not to permit . mr . martelli , normally you can express yourselves only at the end of the tuning hour , but i give you the word exeptionally briefly . report (a5-0294/2000) by mrs . eriksson in the name of the committee for the rights of the woman and equal chances over the suggestion for a decision of the advice (kom (2000) 335 - c5-0386/2000 - 2000/0143 (cns)) over the program for the support of the framework strategy of the community for the equalization of women and men (2001-2005) mr . praesident , my question refers to the order with the tuning over the requests for modification to the paragraph 10 , which is concerned with the armenian genocide . (the parliament accepts the resolution request . ) both the governments of the union states and the governments of the partner countries in the mediterranean area carry the responsibility for it . the assistance is more than justified in view of this tragedy . the night work prohibition for women was one of the few ranges , within which the social legislation of some countries was somewhat more progressive due to the preventive measures to favour of the women for the employees than for the employees . i hope much that the commission in the future makes by punctual and annual balancing it for the european parliament possible to analyze and debate more thoroughly . i regret for this reason against it to have been correct . it is important that our products are safe , however should we to extreme measures to be hinreissen not be able . at present the agency for the kosovo is led by a board of directors , in which the representatives of the member states and the commission are seized a voice in each case to have and in that the resolutions with zweidrittelmehrheit . i believe , the algeria problem for serbia am kosovo . the danish social democrats were correct against a report , in which the introduction is endorsed by aids for the pig producers in the european union . it is even with a certain opening of the french presidency well-known only that the commission rejects these suggestions , and in the advice does not seem it majority for their acceptance to give . already a slight change of the offer can cause a crisis situation . mr . praesident , the genocide at the armenians was first in a set of genocides in 20 . century , which one can designate as one century of the genozide . since sweden is ready to participate in civilian crisis management not however at a common military defense , we can not endorse point 15 , in that the "will of turkey , to the improvement of the european abilities in the context of the common european safety and defense policy to contribute" are welcomed . but apart from the obligation of the erinnerns , which one must to call in and from that the europeans know from each democracy , as difficult and painful it is - so with difficulty that some european countries did not fulfill her yet fully - , may such document of cruelty , with those out ethnical , religious or cultural reasons of human lives destroy themselves and those the universal conscience be loaded , never again occurred . it concerns naturally another question than to the debate standing , but due to the meaning , the today , which i attach to turkey , i wanted to remind already today again of this point . is today in these countries possible for peace , because the population no more is not prevented from the practice of her right to self-determination . i was correct for the requests for modification , which demand this acknowledgment at the current time , so that this sympathy continues and is recognized the pain of a people . that happened at present the ottomanischen realm . the report jové peres would not only like to systematize this situation for the existing regional organizations and the organizations at present in the structure , but it would like to still strengthen it , by abolishing the usual proceeding of the commission , with the specialists from different member states for the support to be consulted . my remarks refer naturally to the topic , with which we are concerned today , i .e . the agency of the european community in the regional fishery organizations , but they refer for example likewise to the negotiations in the context of the world trade organization . joining suggested by me became from the advice president at that time , mr . trittin , and of the european commission supports , so that the decision of the parliament encountered to link three guidelines with one another no large resistance . in order to call an example: pvc constitutes 0 .7 % of the entire burned quantity of waste . finally i would like to stress that the ppe/de parliamentary group with the work carried out in the course of the third reading is content . mr . praesident ! also i would like to thank mr . blokland for the production of this important report . burn is not recycling . the report of mr . blokland , available in third reading , was for many in the parliament selected members of the environmental committee the first feuerprobe for the first time , with which they could learn the practices of the parliament . and mrs . evans pointed out that stricter emission limit values were specified for new zementoefen , which along-burn wastes . independently of the situation in the individual countries thus an almost general decrease of the mandatory insurance protection as well as the increasing meaning of auxiliary health insurances so mentioned are to be determined and the reinforcement of discriminating factors in all states of the european union . on the other hand a guideline suggestion for the following points should be compiled: primarily prohibition of the use of personal information from the gene research ; no obligation for a health investigation before signing of the agreement ; introduction of an obligation to the lifelong insurance protection by the insurer ; finally improves coordination rules for rueckerstattungen in favor of of persons , who move within the union or take up in another country a gainful employment , and the introduction of a switching mechanism . since we ever more positively stand for transnational supply , finds the free market principle in intensified measure application to the health welfare service . b . very often serve us as "example" for the free free-market economy . in the public health policy it would be a fatal error to take it to us to the model . b . or demands an insurance for all citizens issues health data . thus those is endangered variety of the auxiliary health insurances , which there are today in many countries and which are based on statistical principles . finally that there was a possibility nevertheless , fast a treatment showed up to receive . here it concerns the health of all citizens of our member states and the co-operation of our territories . not coincidentally i am confronted with such problems straight because i come from the netherlands . mr . praesident , admired delegates ! mr . rocard requests the commission to define in a green book of characteristics of a basis safety device for the legal health insurances . that is a completely large problem . mr . praesident ! who concerned itself like we a life long with the investigation of the social questions , it remembers that the old text books tended to give a definition of the social protection as whole of national preventive measures for the cover of economically assessable risks , which aimed at the individual or the family and at such risks , which could not carry an individual - or a family - even . that is , that we must think seriously about it , why the public medical supply suffered a fiasko . the auxiliary health insurance presupposes a legal system of requirements and achievements . in the attempt to abolish discrimination for reasons of the state of health mr . rocard would have slaughtered the goose , which puts golden eggs . the commission will rapidly act in the context of its competencies , and i want to try to give to the conclusions of your report an answer . i hope in addition that the suggestions are accepted , in which the special meaning of the qualification and the integration into the working life am recognized . therefore it must be considered that regardless of the practice of a paid occupation the phenomenon of the poverty and the social ausgrenzung gains ever more significance . mr . praesident , my very much admired ladies and gentlemen ! we want to congratulate also from view of the committee for economics and currency the berichterstatterin to their collecting main . after the agenda the recommendations of the commission for a statement of the advice regarding the actualization of the stability programs of germany , finland and the netherlands follow . this leads us to another consideration , and we ask ourselves whether this stability and growth pact with the reaching of the quantitative goal of a certain final number exhausted or whether further aspects should be taken up regarding the quality of public finances to the next programs . our main message therefore reads that the margin for the delivery shortening must be accompanied by strict control of the public expenditures . i believe , altogether seen can draw one a positive result . they mentioned that for one of the largest and for the european economy most important countries , i .e . germany exists , the danger of the overheating . mr . praesident ! thank you , mr . della vedova . i assume that you would like to hear today our statement to these two aspects , to the present measures in the fight against bse in europe and for development in france . we suggest to the european commission and our partners in the union accomplishing in this way the expansion of the tests on european level in accordance with the scientific recommendations . efficiency , independence and transparency will be thus the basic principles , which apply to the evaluation of the nourishing risks in europe . i will return to this point later . however such tests are necessary to far larger extent . active monitoring measures , including sample tests , are developed , in order to prevent that bse arrives in the fodder and food chains . in a situation , as we experience her now , one is always tried to hold according to a magic formula look out after a solution , which re-establishes at one blow both the risk eliminated and the confidence . on monday i will ask the member states whether they fear that weaknesses in the conversion of controls in the past years , which an offence against the community legislation would be , with which increased bse inzidenz a role at present play . both must be nevertheless possible , act fast and remain at the same time respectable . it is because of you to supply it fast . that is a particularly urgent demand , straight regarding bse . our parliamentary group demands the immediate prohibition of meat and bone flour for all battle animals , as long as the member states cannot guarantee the introduction from laws to the bse bse-vorbeugung and the strict conversion of the european guidelines . mr . kommissar , i does not know whether this is a universal remedy , but in the name of the precaution principle it is required my judgement to express immediately a prohibition of the use of animal flour in the nutrition of all breed animals also for pigs , poultry and fish . in our house the debate begun , in order to look for scapegoats in the advice , in the commission or in the parliament , is rather redundant my judgement . first of all we , as some my previous speakers already said , must accomplish systematic bse tests with all slaughtered cattle , which are intended for the nutrition of the europeans . if we act with courage and ambition , we can bring the interests of health of the europeans and the economic interests of our producers with one another in agreement , and in this way we can re-establish the confidence . i stress again that these occupational groups are responsible for the crisis in no way . for this reason the european union them must show in relation to solidarity . also i cannot approve the arrogance of some member states , which accomplish no tests and demand also no legislation . the european solidarity must be used also , because our politics proved as incoherent: fallow lands , animal flour for wiederkaeuer , nitrate , pestizide . then i must sound myself , which mr . gollnisch says here in the house that its parliamentary group was the tip of the spear in the argument around bse . furthermore we consider measures for the containment of all herd of epidemic and the imposition of an export prohibition valid up to the contribution of the safety proof for meat appropriate . it cannot concern that we also politically accordingly do not support this priority . i am glad over the fact that we speak still of the expansion of the tests on experimental basis . if we introduce however general bse tests , if we destroy animal flour , if we arrange the emergency slaughtering of a whole herd due to a only one animal gotten sick , then we must from third states , with which we want to operate trade and to export the living animals , battle bodies and meat products into the community , equally strict health regulations demand . the causes lie completely elsewhere . i welcome it much that the commission expressed itself finally vehement for surface covering tests . because france showed straight: who searches , which finds ! what prevents us thus to undertake something? each time only does a crisis have to break out , before we come and insure here that we grant the absolute priority as parliament of the public health? the connection between the feed of animal flour - a by the way very unnatural kind of feeding of animals - and bse is now everyone clear . also in this connection i ask the european commission for a certain harmonization . i request the european commission to make a total examination of the systems practiced in france to handling bse . as consequence the poison arrives into the system and destroys as it were this system . because it is surely difficult to bring in this range legislation of the individual nations and european with one another in agreement . in addition there is legislation going by to protect like the animal flour , how this fodder must be processed a further safety device , which into the system was built , in order the public health and ensure food security . it already said that that will be very expensive , a large number of battle bodies to cover might and so on . as examples are aforementioned: the "cushion technology" , which caused the death of a immigrantin in belgium , which use of strong tranquilizers in spain , which transport of immigrants zusammengepferchten in holds in italy and spain , who tragedy of the 58 chinese , who were dead found in the united kingdom , in the port of dover , after they had been arrested several times on european soil , and the general use of coercive measures and intimidation methods of different kind opposite proven immigrants . i deliver this obligation , and for me i stand for it in . the force against women knows many forms: the force in the family , a crime in the hiding , the different forms of the sexual exploitation , the woman trade or also the slave trade . mr . praesident ! i would like to say mr . nogueira that it is incumbent on the central bank in the model the monetary policy defined by us naturally , and it is the european central bank , which acts according to the criteria specified in the contract . mr . praesident ! i believe , in the public am it very important to differentiate between the interior and the external effect and me would interest: will the commission now still briefly start an action before the physical introduction of the euro , in order to explain to the population the difference between interior and external effect of the currency stability? as long as the greek side does not become active here , we will continue to pursue the procedure already introduced . we guarantee on our part that there is a measuring and a monitor . in the same decision the commission had committed itself to examine the aid systems in all member states on the basis of specific criteria which apply to 2004 , since at this time permission for the french aid regulation runs out . the goal the integration of promoting europe makes common efforts and actions necessary after the words of the european advice of lisbon . secondly , by the experience of the involved ones locally , the nro , the regional administrative bodies , which social mechanisms and personally by ausgrenzung the concerning is more comprehensively considered . that became safe many older humans obligations , in addition , those , which worked for hours for small wages , them decent life does not permit as for example agricultural worker . it concerns also humans with psychological disturbances , just like large groups , whose sprachkenntnisse are not sufficient , in order to find a place . in the usa by more flexibility within the occupation range it is ensured that the poverty only very short time and also unemployment is experienced from very short duration is . in my country about 75 % those , which work and live nevertheless below the poverty border , are women . we must try to at least partly fulfill this important task . this central equipment must be strengthened , places one the procedures and realism in calculation , which are it shown on this area . . (en) mr . praesident ! i would like to thank mrs . figueiredo and congratulate to her and to address also mine thanks to the other members of the parliament , that are not present now and that spoke statements of the other committees . i am like you to put the meaning of nichtregierungsorganisationen out as well as of regional and local participants and to consider their experiences locally better . we already agreed that the committee for social protection is to meet regularly with the group of contacts of the parliament . after the agenda the report (a5 ­ 0320/2000) of follows mrs . rothe in the name of the committee for industry , foreign trade , research and energy over the suggestion for a guideline of of the european parliament and the advice on the promotion the generation of current from renewable energy sources in the electricity domestic market (kom (2000) 279 - c5 ­ 0281/2000 - 2000/0116 (cod)) . we need now obligatory goals . a further substantial point , which the committee agreed , is the problem of the mains connection and the net entrance for renewable energies . in my country , in spain , these guidelines would be concretely responsible for the fact that from today until 2010 additionally 225 billion tons of co2 into the atmosphere it was delivered and we could not fulfill the goals of kyoto . mr . praesident , mrs . kommissarin , rates colleagues and colleagues ! the suggestion of the commission on the creation of a framework , by which it is to be made possible to increase medium-term the portion of electricity from renewable sources of energy in the european union substantially can be only welcomed . but of the compatibility with the domestic market still a danger can go out . garbage is not a renewable natural resource , although of it daily more and more is produced . thus this guideline attains at present an involuntary topicality . i nevertheless support this suggestion of hearts . mr . praesident ! i would like mrs . rothe for excellent report to thank , which comes in this week , in which we struggle with the crisis of the climatic change , exactly to the right time . the promotion of the generation of current from renewable energy sources is to be endorsed much . necessary are fundamental technological adjustments . instead in each case single suggestions in the area of the energy without large connection are submitted . finally i would like to address only three problems , which resulted in the process of this discussion . on the other hand the goals translated for reasons of the coherency into national parameters must be obligatory , because it would lack otherwise the guideline contents and substance . for the same reason we endorse request for modification 3 , not partly however request for modification 7 , which is too technical for the text of the suggestion . but we cannot accept those parts , which praejudizieren the application of the standards to subventions . after the agenda the report (a5-0308/2000) of follows mrs . theorin in the name of the committee for the rights of the woman and equal chances over the participation of women in the peaceful settlement of conflicts (2000/2025 (ini)) . while the official peace processes are dominated almost exclusively by men , international experiences and declarations show , how important the participation of women is in the conflict settlement and with the peace efforts . decisions over execution and conversion of relief work lie in the responsibility of the crisis staffs , and here the special and specialized authority of the women receives little attention and acknowledgment . obviously they want to retain and know their position of power within the range of the outside and defense policy for itself the interests of the women in their opinion by men to be quite represented . mr . praesident , i would like to express first my large interest in this report , which is even distinguished my judgement protruding . in addition financial means must be present , which make it possible to help the women the victims of this situation became . mr . praesident ! i will not repeat what was stated already in detail . first i would like to congratulate mrs . theorin to it that she seized the initiative to this outstanding report , itself with an important , at the same time in addition , current topic concerned . it concerns , how an effective participation of the women in the negotiations can change the world for the settlement of konfliken and replace the dominating culture of the gegeneinanders and the force by a culture of the peace , the dialogue and the democratic regulation of disputes . therefore i support the demands of the report , according to which women should receive a right to diplomatic influencing control . a very well documented , detailed , inexorable report , which states fundamental principles with a clarity , like this in the article 17 takes place , boldly , but at the same time with a large practical understanding and very necessary suggestions . i personally condemn jedwede rape and slavery ! fifth point: the role of echo , the office of the european community for humanitarian assistance , in addition requests - and the parliament followed this request - , to likewise appreciate the sex specific dimension . the problem is that millions humans , above all mrs . , exercise this activity that also a very large demand for it exists , in this connection however no legislation exist . my judgement should in the context of the occupation-political guidelines in accordance with the demand already in the statement of the european parliament to these guidelines posed the member states to a regulation of the sector be arranged . the immigrants usually place a large group within this range , which makes special measures necessary , how specialized photograph centers , which render the necessary help . it concerns a task of the member countries here . the need rose in the last years around a multiple , which became fact however hardly generally working life and the associated rights and obligations considered . (the meeting is closed at 24 .00 o'clock . ) (very lively applause) we must create not only the internal system of the liberty and the peace , but bring it also with the rules and customs in agreement , which apply in the european community and in the european union for decades . our first step in the attempt , which foederalen state constitutionally umzugestalten , is the definition of a framework for the spread-possible democratic dialogue over the character of the relations between both republics . they , the representatives of the european parliament , those directly the citizens of their member states , which represent citizens of europe , can understand best , why the direct possibility of an entry to europe for us , which appears extremely uncertain citizen of the today's federal republic of yugoslavia . we resume the meeting . finally it concerns a question informative extraordinarily important for the citizens and citizens and here , and it would be appropriate , if we it in run the today's daily to the conclusion bring could . thereupon the commission communicated then , it within a half yearly a concrete suggestion will submit , and it held word . in the european union documents are already today practically generally accessible , and one should call oneself in memory that courageous citizens and citizen as well as many progressive member states already for many years for more transparency fought . in this report a further treatment is demanded also in the parliament , and in this sense i believe that it must come thereby also here and today to rework . we are pleased that we regain the crucial principle , which also we represent as a committee for household control with vehemenz in the report . now the possibility is given to it to take also view of procedures in which the mass media and groups of interests are not interested particularly , and it can participate in the open and democratic debate , which is so important for the confidence into the european union . the committee on petitions would have seen gladly shorter waiting periods up to the publication of a document . as soon as it is no longer necessary , naturally also these documents are to be made accessible . in addition i would like to underline that entrance to documents in as many forms must be guaranteed to all citizens and citizens as possible . the dogma of the political responsibility may not be confounded with the rights of the citizen to openness . i would like to call therefore the correspondents , each reference to rights of the delegates from the regulation , whose article is the entrance of the public to documents , to remove and i would like to request all colleagues and colleagues to make certain completely exactly that its interests are not out-played against the interests of the public . in these ranges the entrance to documents is not ensured and does not only become the citizens and citizens , but also the european parliament refuses , which is consulted on the other hand neither formally informed nor to fundamental documents . a large who courage drop remains existing however . mr . praesident , first i would like to thank mr . cashman for a very good report . it concerns here an extraordinarily important report , an important part of its that one could call the new public principle of the european union . (technical disturbance) it concerns not only the principle of the unrestricted entrance to all documents , but naturally also around the fact that we succeed in finally opening the doors with council meetings so that the advice cannot fall in the future no more in the style of metternich in the secret one lonely decisions and operate afterwards then cheap brussels bashing . secondly i would like to deal with the question of the exceptions . the population regards europe as undemocratic , as a place , at which behind closed doors decisions are made . according to the article 255 of the contract the suggested regulation must be accepted before 1 may 2001 , i .e . , two years after the entry into force of the contract of amsterdam . they will permit me that i deal now with some problems , which stand for the moment an endorsement of certain requests for modification by the commission against . as said , we can agree in some cases the requests for modification in principle , but we must work in technical and administrative regard together on them , for example on the requests for modification for the classification of documents and for registration . we do not have anything written in the hand , and i would suggest gladly also for the future that the commission conveys the delegate their recommendations in writing . greetings we welcome the improved status of the reduction of the credit risk , in particular the collateral , which can be placed by smaller enterprises . report (a5-0321/2000) of mr . blokland over approved of common the draft of a guideline of of the european parliament and the advice over the burn of wastes (c5-0371/2000 , of the mediation committee - 1998/0289 (cod)) mr . praesident ! i would like the parliamentary group of the liberals , also as ko-berichterstatterin , request , to concern the whole a little more practically . it is thus the common desire both from the parliamentary group of of the european one people's party and the european democrats (ppe de) and from the parliamentary group of of the social-democratic one party of europe (pse) , to postpone the tuning up to the second november meeting . i suggest therefore postponing the tuning over the report villiers on the second november parliamentary session . i adhered to the order , which i got from the court-room services , and which has plenum nothing different one decided . that is everything that i can say you today as a regular meeting president to it ; as your colleague i agree however with you . apart from their rejecting attitude in the first phase , when the european parliament made seriously to the dangers in great britain attentive , the measures were essentially limited the second phase , when the scandal raged in great britain , to this country , without an emergency program would have been started for the execution of strict controls and for the restructuring of animal husbandry on totaleuropean level . therefore we want to draw four substantial teachings , which should be considered in the future . we were correct for this common resolution . the increase of cases of the new variant of the creutzfeldt jakob illness in england and the situation in france moved , this time the topic "mad cow disease" (bse) again on the agenda with still larger vehemenz . from fear of panikmacherei under the population or in the effort around preventing a commercial disaster some governments conveyed the necessary information not in time to the commission and/or with the first occurrence of the dangerous features not immediately the consumption of the products concerned stopped and their export did not prevent . the farmers alone cannot align anything in view of this crisis: a plan is necessary for flanking the cattle breeding as well as measures for the recovery of the confidence of the consumers . the inability of the european institutions in its whole (advice , commission , parliament) , to specify an adequate community policy which comes to meet security needs of the member states most directly concerned , will raise problems of the order of rank between the obligations of the domestic market and the health and safety requirements of our population . after numerous discussions with the advice we could succeed in several points . the placing on dumps will belong soon to the past and must be replaced by more pollution free procedures . the social carriers and in particular the representatives of the disadvantaged groups , to which the program turns off , to which procedures are taken part , so much we over renewed growth and the decrease of unemployment are pleased , may not lock we nevertheless not the eyes before the fact that the inequalities remain existing or to worsen ! i believe , the correspondent demand rightfully a stronger participation of the public places , management and industry and the citizen company in current measures for the fight against poverty and social ausgrenzung . the "poor employees" , mostly women , who are employed as partial time forces , to dumpingloehnen and on most uncertain jobs , line up into the course of the misery , which is so masterfully ignored in official speeches . before three years the prime minister furnished the social ausgrenzung , whose task is the coordination from government measures to the dismantling of social ausgrenzung by development of comprehensive solutions for comprehensive problems to paper . those are in the meantime plants also over 60 rotors , which take thousand football fields up . without the development of the renewable energy sources the energy-dependentness of the european union from at present about 50 % would increase to the year 2020 to 70 % . it is natural that it applies to keep the most progressive and most effective safety regulations with the use of the nuclear energy and the storage of radioactive wastes . we must therefore for an energy look for , which is from present already from nature , but so for a long time remained unused , as nobody the technology developed , them usable to make . on the occasion of the preparation of asem 4 it applies to renew the democratic demand as on the one hand the information and the inclusion of the selected representatives of the people and the civil company - particularly in form of a social forum - are ensured and on the other hand the social rights as well as the environmental and human rights consideration to find . lately this parliament several times had to resist ambiguous statements and even criticism . we saw that the parlacen with the same cases of change had to do as also this parliament in its beginnings . therefore one had to fight , and the parlacen fights also further for more competencies , more means , a stronger operational readiness level and the asserting of its repraesentativitaet . the centralamerican parliament must win exactly the same as the european parliament at prestige , reliability and legitimacy , by relying on the activity of its parliamentary groups , because the party life is the getreuliche reflection of the societies represented by them , or at least it should be like that . concerning the human rights we support the co-operation programmes since 1990 for the attention of the human rights , by informing about this topic and sensitizing humans for it . ­ b5-0855/2000 of the delegate van the bos in the name of the eldr parliamentary group ; the extreme confusion , which prevailed to the last in the surrounding field of the elections in weeks in côte d ' ivoire , which was considered so far as economical sample country , is symptomatic for a country , in which an economic crisis , social despair and as consequence political chaos prevail . the political , military and religious leaders must set everything to make a national reconciliation possible . in particular it applies to set over the ivoritaet an end for this blurred debate and to remove each reference to the ivoritaet from the ivorischen condition , those nothing different one meant than the creation of a national preference , which we fight in our own countries and whose logical consequence would be in the long run the ethnical cleaning . also it has the change of basic law supported with the intention of switching its largest adversary off ouattara due to the fact that its two parents are not ivorer . mr . praesident , loves colleagues and colleagues ! even if the ivory coast were compared with other states in west and central africa in the past a stronghold of stability and democracy , there are nevertheless for a long time ethnical and religious tensions , there were in the long run also misuse of power by the former government under president bedié , and this finally led to the seizure of power by force by the military . we condemn the ethnical acts of violence and above all the political responsible persons , whose demagogie of the trips was . after the agenda the common discussion follows over the following resolution requests: the forthcoming european union asean meeting in december in laos offers a crucial opportunity to us to condemn this regime on the sharpest . i have by the way also no confidence into our own ministers that they bring these topics there to the language . the asean proved in each regard as paper tiger , because she did not succeed to react to the terrible events in burma . the junta announced that it intends , the party altogether to smash . there is a historical hereditary load , and naturally the situation is difficult . these slight improvements in the last years , - which are to be owed surely not to the author of the requests for modification of the socialist parliamentary group , mr . sakellariou , - led to a situation , which is not surely any longer tragically , however still devastatingly and under no circumstances on the height of the today's tasks of viet nam . mr . swoboda , the european parliament is flexibly , efficient . it would be appropriate nevertheless , if the american president in hanoi on the reinforcement of co-operation do not only concentrate , but this straight of concrete promises of viet nam would make dependent to noticeably improve the miserable human right situation in the country in each regard . i request the advice and the commission to protest energetically against these rough injuries of the freedom of religion by the vietnamesischen authorities . in addition the process led to the signing of the co-operation agreement between the commission and viet nam in the year 1995 . those are naturally parts , which were contained in that resolution request , which we brought in . also i am the opinion that we must do all standing in our forces , in order to help them . at most would be however helped them , if we would change something in the situation , which brought them and countless other humans in the world into this state of distress . at present central and long-term solutions are discussed . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , which place inundations , by which in the last weeks beside other european countries such as great britain , spain , ireland and france also different areas of north italy were afflicted , this parliament again before the problem both municipalities and enterprises to an unusual immediate measure , in order the state of distress concerned of humans , too lindern , and a more long-term policy , in order to prevent a repetition of natural catastrophes of such extents . the straight traffic sector will make measures of larger consequence necessary in view of its foreseeable constant growth - over 38 % in the next decade - . the discussion is closed . perhaps it belongs to the customs of this parliament but it seems to be nevertheless very delicate me to arouse the impression that the parliament of the europeans with a so small participation obligations is received to a such topic and the european commission such a task transfers . (the parliament rejects the request for adjournment of the tuning . ) the economic and social politics of the european union , those limited the purchasing power and the ability of the employees to pay contributions , as well as the occurrence of new diseases and the zuegellosigkeit of the medicament companies noticeably drove the costs in the health service up . in this way a far field is opened for the private insurers under the condition that it selects the patients and the insurance premiums (at first) not after diseases . who receives and spends not much money , does not take in account . mr . praesident , my very much admired ladies and gentlemen ! i am completely particularly pleased that i can speak today in presence of a group of visitors from my beautiful constituency , which i welcome very cordially . that presupposes however that sufficient time is given to the institutes to prepare for the new regulations . in the report of the fact the speech is that increasing agreement exists over it that the present regulations are not able , to carry for the developments of the financial sector in the last ten years calculation . we say to the stronger consideration of risk-reducing techniques , and we say also to the extension of the basic idea of the basler of committee . with same satisfaction we take the important contribution of this report to the total process to the knowledge . finally , and that is the crucial point , is completely conscious we us that we must respect the institutional equilibrium specified in the contract . the tuning takes place tomorrow at 9 o'clock . permit me , mr . praesident that i notice finally the opportunity , in order the citizen-assigned , mr . jacob soederman , to its work in the fight against bad states in the administration and thus in the tendency for a larger public-friendliness of the work of the institutions for community at the same time to congratulate . mr . praesident ! the european parliament used fortunately completely in conformity with the scandinavian official tradition always to strengthen and strengthen the position of the citizen-assigned . the tuning takes place tomorrow at 9 o'clock . finally the entrance to documents is a fundamental citizen right , and for an applicant no document is more important than the test documents . we hold it for legitimate that an applicant receives entrance to his own corrected test work , because the entrance to documents is a fundamental right , which is recognized in the rest of also in the charter of the fundamental rights , over which we in this week co-ordinated . so it is to also be . all other organs and mechanisms should follow this example , how it recommended the committee on petitions . the citizens of the european union must win a positive impression in the contact with mechanisms of the community . and the new means in this case to follow the best practices and all avoid , what can bring after the reliability to our experience the union in the member states themselves in discredit . which concerns other institutions , then application hangs in this report and in the demands of the citizen-assigned addressed procedure of them off . minutes of the meeting of yesterday were distributed . if they are prevented due to an unavoidable disaster , then the democracy is disturbed , but if they do not have desire to come , then they do not earn the voice . the at the basis put criteria of a stricter state supervision of the banks are correct , but must also different aspects , in particular the solvabilitaetskoeffizient , be considered , that a weighting parameter for the respective contracting parties are approximated and the credit risk connected with the active of a bank . provisional establishment of the european police academy (epa) this police co-operation plays a relevant role , in order to achieve the large goal of ensuring for the citizens of europe a higher safety level within europe of the liberty , security and the right . the extension of the european union , which brings an expansion of the area for the free traffic of persons with itself , must be accompanied by additional measures for security and peaceful living together of the member states . as i see , the conditions are in french and portuguese institutes for detention completely different . that is , if you want common standards , you must define these only once , because otherwise you have training , which can be arranged perfectly different . owing to the work of mr . posselt now it is finally planned that the training of the police personnel must take place also in the ranges of human rights and defense ; just as importantly and appropriately nowadays the recommendation is to create the possibilities of the internet using virtual police academy . but we are here in strasbourg in a plenary assembly hall almost become extinct and must the almost unbelievable also listen to . it is a good idea , and in the european one union , where humans enjoy liberality , where there is free trade and the right to address , where one can travel from scotland to sicilies or greece , is it logically only if one expects the development of a common system of the maintenance of the public order . in the netherlands the police is trained on the deeskalation of conflicts and on repressive tolerance , whereby existing subcultures , ethnical minorities , which are considered to use of churches as places of refuge to humans without legal residence status and political protest meetings as normal social features . who in the good solutions believes , for which it occurs , may no fear have to measure it at the solutions of the others . i hope that the academy will supply a starting point for the future here . this is a good example of what we call meanwhile interlaced europe , europe , which brings the nations to each other in direct contact , without creating unnecessary blown up bureaucracies . most cases of child kindesentfuehrung are clarified at present very efficiently and in appropriate way by the central authorities in all member states . therefore this gap must be absolutely concluded from reasons of the equalization and realism in view of a social development as well as the same rights and obligations for all citizens of the european union . meanwhile we welcome this measure and her from whole heart our voice will give . we feel sympathy for the set goal and agree the suggested measures . with this one day concerns it clearly persons , who often travel around the whole world , in order to see a child . this view of the commission is confirmed also by the statements of the european parliament in this affair as well as by the iurisdiction of the court of justice of the european communities . i white , the fifa already on time played and to for a long time waited , until she already reacted to 1998 of the commission published formal explanation to those at all . a matter of course is that the union will be represented in the future in the wada by the committee member responsible for questions of the sport . resolution of the united kingdom for the collection of a delivery of not-british transport enterprises ireland is certainly very smaller , but open market , but most that we buy , comes from great britain . finally i would like to say that it is still too early for this debate in the european parliament , but i welcome the fact as well as the explanation of commissioner vitorino , from which clearly the right of the government of the united kingdom follows to introduce a system of the euro euro-vignette if this stands in conformity with the already valid regulations and regulations . mr . praesident ! deliveries and duty tariffs are naturally sensitive , and which i can confirm straight for austria , where we have this discussion constantly , and where for solutions for a good traffic solution is naturally constantly looked for . here no other driver or forwarding agent in europe is discriminated against to favour of british drivers . that pays some more for its vignette , it is , it a certain deduction on a by diem basis is granted . on 22 november , i .e . exactly to 25 . anniversary of the coronation/culmination of king juan carlo , who opened spain the way of the democracy , had to pay its faith in liberty , tolerance and attention of the other one to one of the most outstanding representatives of this democracy for his part with the life . i please it to keep all your relevant word messages carefully in the memory . the negotiating position of the european union concentrated on the safety device of the environmentalpolitical objectives of kyoto minutes within the ranges change of land use and forestry , on the problem "lowering" , the relationship between the mechanism and national measures , also "auxiliary principle" planned in kyoto minutes mentioned , and the system of fulfilment control . during the preparation of the next conference the european union should not all topics again discuss , but on the emphasis concentrate , thus particularly on "lowering" , the mechanisms , the "auxiliary principle" and fulfilment controls . mr . prescott disappeared now under the water surface , and we do not know , how long he will still float there . last remark: i find it correctly that you remained hard with the question that lowering , above all because it is extraordinarily difficult to measure a lowering exactly . for the nuclear energy no prospect insists on a comeback . it requires however still further steps . with the next meeting in bonn in may 2001 the equality principle must be fixed . to the next conference in bonn in may 2001 still another relevant compromise would have to be found . the task , before which we stand in view of the climatic change , is surely one of the most fastidious 21 . century , if we want to have all in the future a planet , on which we can live . the same applies to the partial charge of the co2-senken as well as from additional afforestation projects . hague the conference will have announced , like you , mrs . kommissarin , us this , in the coming spring in bonn continued . mrs . praesidentin ! thanks , mrs . kommissarin barrier-flow , for its remarks . if there is an affair , with diversities of opinion existed , then this did not apply for the relationship between the delegation of the european parliament and the commission . it is out of question to obtain with the next cop6 no agreement . we were expressed constructional and up to the last minute of these hague conference negotiated . they have the word , mr . acting advice president . with the coordination of the social security systems , the tax policy , the asylum , visa and immigration questions , the commercial policy within the range of the services , a very important topic , certain countries have still serious problems . to add i would like that for allocation of seats in the european parliament still no agreement was obtained . to arrive at an agreement , which secures its capacity to act for the union after the new beitritten , which are prepared actively at present , is an important challenge for the future of the union and the extended union . their president is naturally invited . it is submitted in nice and - as we naturally hope - are accepted . how you see , there is very much to advise in nice . in union with 27 or more member states will unanimity requirement completely simply to it to lead that jedweder progress within the ranges , in which one holds to this principle is prevented . they spoke of the joint decision of the european parliament . (applause) this task is the reunification of our old continent . the task insists in an extension , as it did not give it so far , and on it must nice us prepare . mrs . praesidentin , the most important goal of the summit of nice is the extension of the european union and the preparation on this extension . mrs . praesidentin , mr . ratspraesident , mr . kommissionspraesident ! i find , so far the governments of the 15 with fame did not bekleckert myself . this is not the correct method . now one suggested co-ordinating within 49 ranges with qualified majority . majority decisions extract the right of veto from the parliamentary democracies in the member states , but the european union does not become a parliamentary democracy . europe needs leadership , needs clarity , needs decisions , needs energy . the attempt of the extortion with proclaiming does not appear to us in view of the conclusions of the european advice of biarritz acceptable , even if it were informal . we are indeed the opinion that the conclusions of nice must exhibit a passage , in which the commission are requested to compile a framework guideline for this range . i will take position to the contract of nice , if i know the result , but i feel the debate as something schizophren here . in amsterdam the state and head of the government were already once not shifted , and this class must after-sit now again in nice . if the difference between large and small in the advice becomes too large , we must fear a large authentication crisis in some years within the european union , because the small ones do not feel then any longer at home , because they have fear not to be able to defend their identity any longer . it concerns to the president and the prime minister frankreichs obviously with priority its own political future and less around the future of europe . if the text is not taken up to the contracts and only if a political signature receives , then substantial legal interpretation problems can result . on the other hand i would like to emphasize , as extraordinarily important it is to equip our union with strong institutions in order the institutional vacuum , which with acceleration on the economical level , caused by the euro , occurred , to adjust . avowed goals of this reform are simultaneous the education of more effective , institutions prepared better for extended europe and the dismantling of the incontestablly existing democracy deficit . but it concerns also the restructuring of the committee 133 , which must be subjected to much stronger democratic control , whose agenda and conclusions must be accessible and which itself by a broad and comprehensive composition must distinguish . mr . praesident , i contacts not only the acting advice president , but also to all governments of the member states , if i point out that these difficult topics will further pursue us also if in nice in this connection no agreement is obtained . the smooth application of the joint decision procedure in the past years showed that it functions . therefore the first step should consist of it to make commercialpolitical decisions already now with qualified majority . as a seven-year girl it was forced to flee before the invasion of the red army from its country and hide themselves as a refugee before the bombardment by soviet combat aircraft in ditches . the colleague méndez de vigo referred a while ago rightfully on the charter of the fundamental rights . we cannot expect more from him . the agreement , which becomes from day to day more probable , is not the smallest common denominator , but unfortunately nevertheless rather only smaller , a very small common denominator . mr . praesident , i would like to thank first the parliamentarians , because i considered this debate extremely levelful . "it did not concern thus not to announce the charter this is no problem of transparency . because the principle of the equal rotation concerns also the large countries , which would have like all different at a certain time no more commissioner . according to my opinion the parliament will be able to state that the union found improved institutional mechanisms , which might make it for her possible , the further development of the european union , which us all eint , to master . the tuning takes place tomorrow . mr . praesident , i would like to follow the explanation of the colleague van orden . i am clear against the fact that an invited minister is threatened - and applies also to the turkish minister of foreign affairs . it stands except question that we here , in this house of of the european democracy , which to security of all of our guests and everyone , who have to ensure stay with us . under the slogan "pills do not harm anything" and with the expression "couriers we the tumore with marijuana" have the italian minister of health those humans would undermine , by demanding the liberalisation of the drug . this is at least a bad coordination to say in order not to say an affront for our parliament - it is not , one is the opinion , the european delegate would have anything to the human rights although they adopted recently the fundamental right charter with very large majority - that it in this forum the european union not participate cannot , on which it in the last year were numerously represented , in order to debate with the nro and the institutions . we now discussed enough . now it was already before amsterdam the view of the european parliament like also the commission that we would have dearest a vice-president of the commission responsible for the foreign policy , which the role of the high assigned one a special obligation and connection to the advice should take over at the same time . as the european parliament before the summit of feira on 15 june a resolution accepted , might it also tomorrow a text discharge , which summarizes its position before the advice of nice . the development of the esvp is a new important project of the european agreement work , therefore the existing institutional framework must be revised . in nice the european advice might confirm several decisions , which i want to call here . for the first discussion at the beginning of the yearly the commission will provide a status balance arranged to countries for the past financial year , from that the conditions of the commitments of funds , which come out disbursements and the amounts for the most important , still which can be used , of the community center stop and from the eef of financed programs . we were likewise concerned with the question of regional co-operation , a concept , which encountered up sides of the countries of this region a certain resistance , since they did not want to be included by new into one past , which they had overcome . but i believe , say to be able the fact that they understood on this summit that a contradiction between a regional co-operation and its advancement , over at this opportunity did not confirm to its approximation to the european union in particular and specified stabilization and association process exists . it had before given a summit with india under the portuguese presidency , and a minister meeting with the asean will still take place . this does not mean naturally that we can be discouraged . i would like to remind of the range of these tasks: humanitarian assistance , evacuation of citizens , conflict prevention , in addition , the military separation from war leading parties . it proceeds naturally from the decision autonomy of the european union and the acknowledgment of the freiwilligen of a political character of the received obligations . it has more than other in a part the world as personalisierung of conflict resolution carried out , which i know very well , and world-wide acknowledgment for its efforts acquired itself . i find the medium reports in my homeland very strange for the mechanism of this troop . i would like to thank mrs . lalumière for its reference to the report to conflict avoidance , which the commission prepares together with the high representative for the european advice in nice . thank you , mr . kommissar christopher cuffs . after my view the european union thereby is actually set to the test stand . impatient citizens deplore themselves over the fact that the mills of the european bureaucracy grind infinitely slowly . in addition , the citizens must receive as far as possible entrance to information and documents . from the available suggestions it does not become clear at all wherein this task should lie . with a european flag on the car one comes everywhere , even into the entlegendste refugee camp . for these reasons europe must decide according to my opinion to act now . if we do not create it as europeans to take over with the solution of this conflict a responsible role independently from the united states to we must count on the fact that one does not give us also with other centers of conflict than mediator confidence . only , your personal commitment does not replace the democratic authentication of the european safety and defense policy . i cannot accept some details in the report of mrs . lalumière . during the final tuning i become for the refusal of the report votieren . the neglect of this broad equipment of civilian conflict prevention will prove in the long term as error , and there me the explanations of the advice are not sufficient to have , the reference , we already resolutions calm , but it becomes long-goes somewhere there ! how you will understand , we tune , everything that stands in our power , against both reports and commit ourselves against the policy . . . thirdly: a nuclear weapon-free passage , as once olaf palm energized it , is to be established from the baltic sea to the black sea . i would like to congratulate to mrs . lalumière to its report . in mr . broks report also the office of the high representative for the common outside and security politics is addressed . unfortunate drum , calls i mean colleague van orden and the other one too , because my colleagues behind the "small pond" , the irish sea , have within this range so much to offer: the tradition , the experience and practice . after our understanding the european parliament is in co-operation with the national parliaments the instance best suitable for it . i think that us the experiences from these recent developments of the future zustatten very well will come , if we are concerned with the necessity to develop a european defense policy and ­ capacity which is in my opinion just as important component of the european integration as the uniform currency . i am also the view that the combination of these different means is a specific condition , a specific possibility of the european union and that our task , if this politics unfold and strengthen must of it consist to develop a real european culture of conflict prevention and ­ accomplishment . i believe rather that a positive dialogue will develop . mr . praesident , ladies and gentlemen , rates colleagues and colleagues ! the resignation of the commission in march 1999 showed , how necessary a reform of their structures and work methods is . the reform can be however understandable from above be compiled , must and describe the trade unions as well as all officials , and these must be drawn into the entire process . this definition will require , is however indispensable and substantial time for the reform . the reform of the commission is a substantial condition for the future of our institutions . during the drawing up of my report i could study not only the white paper , but also the second report of the committee of independent experts and the resolution suggested by michiel van hulten over the work of this committee of experts , which was accepted on 19 january in this parliament . the audit office points out in its report that it does not oppose the abolishment of the ex-ante-visa , if this abolishment is replaced by other procedures , which can offer at least equivalent collateral and include the so different participants than the financial examiner . everywhere an increasing opening of the large enterprises is to be observed , it becomes more transparent , it uses the information technology innovatively ; they depart from traditional vertical organization forms , by exchanging information about enterprises away and among themselves . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , rates colleagues and colleagues ! despite its consequence does not raise the white paper actual institutional questions submitted by commissioner kinnock . we debated in all other respects this afternoon in the context of the discussion the common foreign policy . finally the delicate question of the suggestion for an anticipated retirement schedule must be tackled . the transfer of the financial control to the central management represents an important step , and it will function only if the coworkers are trained appropriately , sufficient means to be available and the competence of the line managers is accordingly strengthened . the institutions and their ladder must have clear possibilities for the optimum realization of the administration . disziplinarverfahren - there are promises also here , but is not so far still no clear rules , no clear statements , how these rules are to be implemented , and also the question of the external ones yet finally clarified . such a change is necessary , in order to serve god trueful , and can not by regulations be forced . and as , if it concerns the change of strengthened conditions , also here obviously eight-samness and care are always required . 6 withdraws and a separate tuning over the last part of request for modification nr . 15 request , since we are not convinced of the fact that the present system will lead in the ezb automatically to this situation . when i belonged to the parliament in former times already once , the president of the commission was called jacques delors , and this worked side on side with mr . brittan and before with mr . cockfield . mr . praesident , mrs . kommissarin , mr . kommissar , loves colleagues ! we pursue this reform with probably justified expectations . such problems such as bse crisis , oil prices and greenhouse effect expressed one european dimension . humans must have also the feeling that the commission is really accessible and transparency . the reform is for the european parliament an important thing , on which it exerts a crucial influence as budgetary authority and a legislator . regarding announcing deliberate failure within and outside of the institution , with which the official is employed , besides a number of clear procedures is specified , for which several channels can be used . therefore i am sure that we will have the pleasure to listen to you also in the future . let me briefly say , mr . garriga polledo , those categories of the financial forecast remain . the reform must be also carried by the personnel of the commission , and it needs therefore acceptance . according to our opinion a cosmetic reform is not meaningful in this time of profound change . mr . praesident , very honoured colleagues and colleagues ! i would like to emphasize first the quality of the initiativberichts of mrs . sauquillo for the reform of the commission and their effects on the relations of the european union with the developing countries . we aim at more accountability . before we talk about project assistance , must be tried to eliminate all existing causes of the profitmacherei and those , which drew advantages from the exploitation and utilization of the emergency suffering subpopulations to determine and pull for responsibility . but because mr . nielson that is so course-bent collegial responsibility , it will defend the suggestion completely surely heue evening . according to our opinion the territorial separation maintained in the suggestion of the commission is still more serious . for the year 2001 are for example the transmission of the financial responsibility at 22 delegations , the modernization of the edp systems intended at 15 delegations as well as the creation of 40 additional places with the field service . ship security but the erika like also the ievoli sun was not french ships . it stands since the fatal fall of the erika eleven months ago on the agenda of the commission completely obenan . we hope and expect that the transport minister advice contributes its part on 21 december to the common determination of the european institutions , in order to cause by the acceptance of common points of view to all three legal texts a genuine improvement of security on lake . i think , the chances for it stand well , but we need the certainty that this agreement is then also carried out . i understand and welcome the effort of the minister to come also with these two reports as rapidly as possible to the conclusion . therefore hold i its suggestion , the question , if possible , to treat in december for in principle welcome . when have we a parliamentary report for the change of the guideline prepared result all its , in which improvements in different regard are suggested , which come down to a stabilization of the classification system as important instrument for the guarantee of the security of the maritime traffic . however the inheritances remain from the years , in which materials were sunk simply in the sea . they emerged occasionally again and looked for each other home , often with very bad consequences . in this connection the publication of information is a crucial factor for the possible entrance of the public to information , emergency call numbers etc . . i set large hopes into the second series of suggestions and the creation of a european agency for the security of the maritime traffic . i consider your consideration honourable , but we can negotiate only about results , which were examined in the advice . we know that port state control was not in the past a sharp sword for ship security , we know that not all klassifikationsgesellschaften settled their control as ship doing v correctly and respectablly , but rather schlampig , and we to know that tankers without double covering represent swimming time bombs . we develop side on the new reliability , and we should not play these by wrong acting of the commission on the other page . who this responsibility does not become fair , simply nothing has to search in our waters and in our ports . the report of watt plans harder measures against ships , which represent or under complaisance flag drive a serious risk , without abolishing however these flags . nevertheless i am pleased that the suggestions of the commission took up the most important demands of the delegates of the french coastal region , so the prohibition of einwandigen oiling anchors , the reinforcement of controls in the ports and the evaluation of the classification companies . equally i agree its suggestion for mandatory travel writers . as was already said , the guarantee of ship security required important measures regarding the responsible persons societies and the inspection . in short , measures , with which security is to be brought on the level desired , are noncommittal . everyone speaks of it , as i finds completely rightfully that the present 25 necessary for this port state control % target is not reached yet . the time of putrid compromises , which be converted besides with difficulty can , is past . to the classification company i would like to stress on this occasion - and that is also my order - again: the special attention of the current discussion seems to lie on the adhesion . regarding port state control the regulations must be further intensified and controls be increased . the lax in relation to the large-scale enterprises is an indication for the fact that this are more powerful than the selected institutions . mr . praesident , admired colleagues and colleagues ! with a discussion , which has the security of the ships and thus the security of humans as well as the protection of the environment to the article , it concerns without a doubt an extraordinarily important question . the submitted reports go into this direction . we are us united regarding the appointment of a minimum height for personal injuries or deaths and damages to property , whereby it is left to the member states , to raise these amounts . the introduction of new technologies and constructional improvements on the ships are part of this important work . we must arrive at a consent at the highest possible regulation and safety level . i am pleased , say to be able that the commission will support many changes suggested in these three reports . the commission can the changes 6 , 7 and 8 approve of , can meanwhile only partly in agreement with request for modification 1 explain itself . it is to be expected that the imo accepts the superseding plan on its conference in april next yearly formally . the task of the commission consists of making sure that the klassifikationsgesellschaft keeps further the quality criteria set up in the guideline supervising and the efficiency of the klassifikationsgesellschaften . the commission notes the support with gratitude in relation to its originally suggested restriction . that points once more , the verabschiedung of better , preventing and strengthening measures to community level to the protection of our seas is as urgent . mr . turco , i heard your message and will consider this . with the two other reports , i .e . inspection organizations and the report on port state controls , the opinions go to the report over the ship examination and ­ apart . in most questions the parliament for the strictest procedure occurs . mrs . praesidentin ! i would like to submit the suggestion to change the request for modification going by that it begins with the words: "urges , in this respect , the council and the commission . report (a5-0329/2000) by mr . pomés ruiz in the name of the committee for household control of the white paper of the commission for the reform of the commission - competencies of the committee for household control (kom (2000) 0200 - c5-0445/2000 - 2000/2215 (cos)) report mckenna (a5-0336/2000) the privatisation of the klassifikationsgesellschaften , which changed over into the hands of the shipowners , as well as the absence of effective control of the ship inspection by the national authorities and the tacit agreement between these authorities let the capital act still more excessively . therefore i welcome it that the correspondents of watt , vachetta and piétrasanta tried to close the gaps still existing in the commission suggestion . for the conversion of these measures thus the member states are responsible . cladding tankers should not be allowed to operate no more here , if they disappeared elsewhere after the years 2005 , 2010 or 2015 . with of mr . hatzidakis submitted suggestions however those are limited the commission . the promotion of a stricter regulation on international level must remain a fundamental goal of our politics for security on lake . it is particularly important to make clear that the causer pays principle must apply in its entirety . this community measure must be strengthened by the reactivation of the imo , those , with real police powers for the penetration of the ism code , an effective instrument after the model of euro pole would be equipped . as long as the costs of offences against legislation are under those for their observance , enterprises , which aim at maximum gains , will make the wrong choice again and again . preparation of the advice by nice instead of getting the human rights and the social rights going , facilitates the charter measures , which are directed toward the sinking of their level . i however unfortunately miss this thoughts in the resolution requests . i have it , how , sometimes it regrets many that the prime minister , lionel jospin , while this half yearly expressed so rarely because of the "cohabitation" but i knows itself that he gave constantly strong impulses to his ministers , and whereupon would like i to refer . in the social range the suggestions are very reserved and do not even lend to the obligations substance accepted on the lissaboner summit . this particularly concerns the necessary reinforcement of the economic and social coherence . in this sense one should not make a decision , which saves the danger of the alienation of the citizens of europe for the development of the european union . the british population wants that the european union with the reform is taken more strongly into the obligation that it becomes more efficient . this text takes the future (into ever further distance moving) extension to the pretext , in order to demand the stabilization of a system , which already lies in the last courses . now controversy prevails no longer only between "large ones" and "small ones" , but the "large ones" argue also among themselves . we welcome and support the report , which affects many important tendencies in the development of the common outside and security politics . how each year seizes this ritual report of the european parliament , which is dedicated in principle to the annual balance of the gasp , in fact the well-known method up to gain gradually ground as a foederalistische breach , which was struck within a certain range , is extended incessant , regardless of the contracts and the resolutions seized on the conferences of the european advice . during our discussion it that a fast strike force of the states of the european union is developed , heard the peace receive in order into and around europe . it is not also task of the european parliament to specify or find over it the capacity of a european fast strike force whether one is to have intervention capacities within the range of the sea and air forces in this connection e .g . . the conflicts of the future can be solved not by military interventions , but only by a policy with the goal of social , economic and ecological justice . we are whole and against this european army , just like against nato and our own national army . for example the report contains formulations going too far over the gasp and the nato , over which "threat with use of armed forces" as arguments with conflict prevention , which offends directly against the un charter . ten years after paging in the east are we the opinion that "the european peace project" conveys an unpleasant signal to the countries willing to join with these reports . straight six of these numbers contain statements , which belong to the topic . unfortunately the clear intention exists of setting national abortion laws out of strength and faith traditions , which turn against the abortion , for suppressing abzustrafen or . . surely many ten thousands of women concerned in the european union would be pleased about the fact that we are concerned here with the legal regulation of the housework in the shadow economy , if they knew it . mrs . smet suggests among other things the introduction of a european definition for household services . during the elaboration of the labour legislation the needs from domestic helps are to be considered to . they exhausted their pension contributions to the different national governments , that let these to be disappeared as turned bag players fast . finally the parliamentary group union for europe of the nations with reproduction reminds of the fact that the citizens of the european union expect more than ever that in the course of the measures to the reform as well as with the attitudes the variety of the opinions and convictions consideration existing in our countries finds . regarding personnel resources the new administrative reform must be generally aligned particularly to the abilities of the officials and a larger transparency with the personnel policy . i would like to use this explanation for tuning , in order to refer and emphasize seriously to the fact that our parliament does not have unfortunately all powers , which it should have . with a request for agenda i come in the end . the information is indeed contradictory , mr . barón crespo . it is not like that that the socialist parliamentary group does not want . but makes for us problems exact: it is an important summit and everything that we say , binds us . i must point out you that the committee will meet tomorrow afternoon , in order to evaluate primarily the conclusions of the diplomatic conference . (the parliament agrees the suggestion . ) i would be very connected for you , if you corresponded to this request . i condemn also that in rotterdam few days ago to one hunger strike-end sympathizers by a command of the grey wolves one murdered . that would have been naturally not at all necessary , if the advice had at all considered our first reading and the changed suggestion of the european commission , to which a whole piece went into our direction , in june somewhat more or . then it must be examined thirdly whether the regulations , which we agree contribute to it that the domestic market works better , and whether they stand in relation to the objective . our second concern is particularly legal nature and us caused to manufacture a still closer interrelation between the harmonization of the market and the health protection whereby we adhered strict to the recommendations , which result from the reason to the judgement issued recently by the court of justice for the abolition of the "tobacco advertising guideline" ; only during an arbitrary interpretation of this reason one arrives to the conclusion , these two aspects is compatible not with one another . mr . praesident , loves colleagues and colleagues ! in europe there were so far 80 deaths in connection with the new variant of the creutzfeldt jakob illness , and europe , its council of ministers , the commission , the parliament decides an animal flour prohibition and mandatory tests for cattle , which are older than 30 months , before its release to the consumption . according to our opinion it is completely natural that the article 95 forms the legal basis for this guideline together with article 133 , as by the committee now in the request for modification 1 suggested . in the opinion of the court a complete tobacco advertising prohibition in the name of a smoothly functioning domestic market is not to be justified . there references like "low tar content" , "mildly" and "easily" my judgement misleading are , are i strictly speaking against the requests for modification 10 and 30 . i would like to speak also about the obligation containing in the contracts . the correspondent , mr . leading seamen , suggested this legal basis with plausible reason , by reference to another article , article 133 over the commercial policy strengthening and he suggested beyond that making in some articles a set of changes in order to avoid that this guideline on the basis of the valid iurisdiction is contested by the judgement of the court of justice . i regret that also in the committee for right and domestic market points of view were represented , according to which the prohibition for tobacco advertisement , imposed by the court of justice , scoops out this guideline in certain way . as a member of the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics i was referred very clearly of different groups to the necessity to adjust the sales and opening of tobacco products in europe more strictly . paradoxically in this guideline the cultivation of tobacco in the community is not forbidden - even if in countries such as greece the produced tobacco is so strong that it would be according to this guideline a criminal offence , to use it for the subsequent treatment . thank you also at mr . byrne for the clear statement of the legal basis . in the european union annually humans an unnecessary death die over one half million , and this number will increase , if we do not act now . also this legal basis is suited to nothing at all after my conviction , and therefore it is correct that the trade unions that the enterprises that the colleagues refer here to the loss of jobs . i am for warnings in picture form , a reasonable list of the contents contents of , european-wide efforts of research , to remain exempted from smoke , tar , nicotine and craze health promotion measures , with which one helps to children . this compromise readiness existed also in the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics . as i understood the request for modification , the exception to article 3 would apply , i .e . the tar , nicotine and carbon monoxide content . due to the general character of the guideline we cannot solve one from the other one , why we must tilt everything . the production of a greatest possible warning reference with some large packings would be an appropriate solution . finally it communicates the remark that i am pleased , to be able that the commission of the 54 requests for modification of the report 33 can accept partly completely , partly ansatzweise . the main argument , which for these requests for modification and a report speaks after in each case five years , is in the reason the extension of the european union , and straight after the summit of nice is particularly attached and applicable it . the summer time seems equivalently to one more at quality of life , and the positive effects of the summer time counterbalance those temporarily arising difficulties due to the time conversion more than . the summer time is not the problem for our common house europe . a unique examination on the part of the commission in five years is sufficient . besides the needs of the manufacturers of computers and electronic travel writers as well as from calendars and appointment calendars are to be considered to . mrs . praesidentin , mr . kommissar , loves colleagues and colleagues ! for the patients necessary medical research must be approved fast and unbureaucratically , but ethicalally motivated borders must be strictly respected , and the test subjects must be maximally protected from abuse . that is an important distinction , which we make here in our report . even if in relation to the advice still certain contentious points remain , i would like to remind of the fact that the verabschiedung desired of this guideline is the result of a long and fruitful search for compromises . we have this our correspondent mr . liese , who i thank for its partizipative and constructional function , and who advice , that showed up the requests for modification of the environmental committee approved in second reading opposite cooperatively and openly to owe . i particularly think of research in connection with the krebsbekaempfung , but there are still many other ranges . unfortunately new threats and diseases seize around itself despite appropriate measures , and often the existing medicines are not sufficient to their fight . it is the obligation of the medical profession to demand means up-to-date and/or more effective against these challenges . the tuning takes place tomorrow at 12 .30 o'clock . in order to avoid and the schemes without interruption thus to update be able a second reading that no vacuum develops , with the advice , with which commission agrees and naturally also with the environmental committee of the parliament to extend these four programs around two years as it specified the commission to make the means available however annually . if in the meantime the new health program is accepted and put into effect , understandably no more extension need exists and can the means for the second year be used . it is at all highest time that itself the member states unite to grant the european union with an absolutely legitimate supranational affair more scope of action and according to more budgetary appropriations: because diseases do not know borders . the import of drugs even increases estimations of international organizations such as according to euro pole into the union . public health politics are national policy , and so it must remain . after the agenda the discussion follows over the report (a5-0355/2000) of mrs . cerdeira morterero in the name of the committee for the liberties and rights of the citizens , law and internal affairs over the initiative of of the portuguese one republic regarding the acceptance of a framework resolution over the position of the victim in criminal procedures (9650/2000 - c5-0392/00 - 2000/0813 (cns)) . a further initiative on international level is the explanation of the united nations over basic principles of the legal treatment of crime victims and victims of abuse , which was accepted by the resolution 40/34 of the plenary assembly of the united nations on 29 november 1985 . perhaps they remember the debate over so-called di pietro pietro-bericht , which ran some time ago here in the house . with this initiative three fundamental requests are pursued: the right of the victim to information , the entrance to the law and the right to payment of damages . the most important aspect exists however my judgement in the fact that one becomes conscious finally also on union level of the necessity to find a new beginning for the procedure of the member states during the crime prevention . the member states should be engaged to furnish special police units for crime victims . italy placed demands of extradition for this repeated murderer repeated at france , where lojacono on free foot is , so that it can serve finally its punishment . the victim must always be located in the center - not the author ! as you will have noticed , three different kinds are intended by measures in the framework resolution draft: first of all minimum rules are issued regarding the rights of the victims ; secondly concrete regulations are introduced , with which the individual situation of those humans to be considered is , thirdly who in a member state of a criminal offence to the victim are fallen , which is not their mother country , and the states are continued to compile measures for the support from victims to . it already is about to support the cross-linking of the services of the individual nations for the support of victims on european level in order to ensure an appropriate assistance for victims , in particular if they live in another country than that the criminal offence . permission of minutes of the preceding meeting the word has again mr . varela , chairman of the committee for fishery , responsible for this thing . well bravo thus ! we gave the final touch to the common explanation of advice and parliament still on last tuesday in a tri log . we created it thus to receive a solution for the household 2001 . we must consider ourselves internally , how we develop the existing necessities within the field of the transport politics all to transparent procedures . we asked for their name , and one said us: "that is the country without names . the advice accomplished its second reading to the budget with consideration with the delegation of the parliament made of the agreements and in the constant tendency to discharge a household which makes the financing of all priorities for the european union possible and to which for the execution of the means corresponds to actual need as well as the actual capacity . the third important element of this second reading of the advice exists in the agreement over the central equipment of the multi-yearly program for enterprise and business initiative , which continue and supplement the occupation initiative , for the period 2001 to 2005 . generally i would like to emphasize that in some days the budgetary procedure going to end showed , how useful the inter+institutional agreement from 6 may 1999 was . the discussions were occasionally quite hard , but always pertinent and always served the exchange of ideas , which to a better mutual understanding and thus for faster causing of one - how i hope contributed - for all agreement contently placing . it is substantial that no country of the balkans region will have now less assistance available due to the democratization of serbia , than this was planned before the development in serbia . indeed the repeated demand can within two sequential years - according to my opinion however to injustice - when a kind revision of the financial forecast are regarded . today now we heard of the advice of its readiness , in order to up-improve 3 ,5 % . but i speak in particular the commission and the advice mean sincere thanks out . mr . praesident ! also i would like to thank mrs . haug for its excellent work . i assume , in order to simplify it once highly , the flexibility apply to small amounts and the revision to large . we will see in the next years , how functions . we stand now before the situation that we must decide , whether we can agree this household on next thursday or not . there one must look at oneself that naturally exactly . but the inter+institutional agreements between the three institutions are also an important property . they should lead to the fact that we have common planning security . the increasing problem pressure refers particularly to unemployment , the bse crisis and the balkans stability pact . mrs . praesidentin , ladies and gentlemen europaabgeordnete ! i estimate myself lucky , today before you the balance of the french union presidency state and in these last months the reached progress to estimate to be able . as we had promised , in nice no unsettled questions remained remaining . it concerns the procedure of intensified co-operation , which was simplified to a large extent in the context of the first and third column . it represents both a tremendous challenge and a historical stage of the reunification of our continent . with this charter our union strengthened , values that , which affirms liberty and the solidarity , on which it is based . some weeks ago the chemistry tanker ievoli sun in the proximity of the channel islands came into distress . we had set ourselves goals , are fulfilled them . from this half-year - i believe to be able to say today - our union followed strengthened , by it itself prepared to accept new members the family to unite - now , since we are safe , to remain also together authorized to act . at the same time it has itself also strengthened in the heart of our fellow citizens , within the range of the basic values , within the range of growth and the occupation , the solidarity , security , retaining the european society model , and it won also at strength and influence on international level . (applause) in view of the pursued concept this seemed inevitable , but is the result for two reasons the more disappointing: first of all , because it still more with difficulty will to achieve a qualified majority and therefore a check minority is facilitated , although in an extended union the opposite would be necessary ; (applause) (applause) the requirement , with which nice was tackled , was the probably most ambitious european requirement for a summit for many years . mrs . praesidentin , mr . staatspraesident , mr . kommissionspraesident , rates colleagues and colleagues ! the judgement of my parliamentary group over the fifteen after that little taking play , which they ordered to the surely speechless europeans , who could experience live at this opportunity , like it really around the common vision , the solidarity consciousness , which mutual confidence the european leading politician stands , precipitate very hard . for each clearly thinking humans they refer to the extremely serious consequences , which will result from the project of foederalen europe with 27 or 28 members . mr . praesident , you let me also underline that in particular france stands there after nice again once as a loser . mrs . praesidentin , mr . praesident ! the parliamentary group europe of the democracies and the differences regrets that the presidency did not take up the message , which to it already in july convey became . many do not see yet the port , into which the european union is to run that once . there is thus also a border , which is to be considered . i believe , it am not only the opinion of three parliamentary groups , but also of other parliamentary groups , which could not sign however for technical reasons . it is desirable to promote the development of medicaments in the community since thereby the patients increased chances of an effective treatment can be ordered . i congratulate my colleague mary honeyball to its first report for the european parliament . surprisingly the colleague fatuzzo has the word , and i am strained , which pensioner said which to him now ! the victim must as a person is regarded , who is in a special situation , which is coined/shaped by uncertainty and distress . the situation is probably the worse , if the criminal offence does not occur in the homeland of the victim . after the agenda the continuation of the common discussion follows over: it was for despairing to have to also regard that the debate concentrated only on who was more or less to get a voice whether germany or france , which the netherlands or belgium , portugal or spain somewhat to it-win . we are pleased about it that a new method was created , and hope that in view of the hope , which results from intensified co-operation europe will continue to progress that it will be able , to compile a future condition those our fellow citizens hope into this marvelous project , which represents the european adventure , show . the entry candidates will take themselves the egoism of our own member states to the model . the joy over it is unequally distributed , but the main message is clear: europe can be summarized now in an extended democratic european union , which by the contract of nice is besides citizen near . the particularist interest prevailed forwards . an open crisis , which would have questioned the extension , was avoided by one into extremis obtained agreement over the contract , but can speak we of a latent crisis , with which we will have to argue us now . i do not believe that it is more realistic , to occur for the penetration of the own national prestige instead of for efficient functioning of the union and i do not believe also that the union citizens rose in masses , in order to pursue the sea-battle of their governing in nice . what marvelous project nevertheless eleven years after the case of the citizens of berlin wall ! at that time applied to half europe , and now we must develop it for the whole . after nice one will not be able itself to appoint no more to the institutional obstacles . first of all: an institutional imbalance , if as the advice got much and the commission as well as the parliament little . this model has retired . the consequences for europe would have been absolutely incalculable . for example , like you knows , at the beginning of the european union for the check minority two of the "large" countries in such a way specified is necessary , today there three . the way is marked out , the extension is possible , the european parliament becomes its place in the debate , during which have further development of the conceptions and starting points . the european public interest , when its exclusive true one - and in this point mr . moscovici is right - can probably raise itself nobody , cannot rely on the sum of the national interests , which overlap and waive mutually , and which were message of prime minister yard city in this connection very attached . we recommended their ratification . i am personal the view that a new weighting of the voices is to be made on the basis the population size . at the european parliament one proceeded in such a way , and at the advice one would have had to proceed likewise . but nice , mr . praesident , is not the end of the way , but the starting point of a new stage with many challenges . therefore i would like to return to what was today already reminiscent a few marks . it is apparent really successful , the total paralysis of the future to prevent extended european union but could the ambitious goals of the french presidency not in the new draft agreement be converted . from me nice gets directly a insufficient . i do not know whether the commission at the end of the discussion will express itself in addition , but in view of the absence of the advice i ask myself whether the commission is convinced likewise of the fact that to 2004 czech , hungarian and polish delegates as well as delegates from the baltic states in this european parliament will sit . we do not have verhehlt that on the way to the extension with the same dynamics and determination as before nice it must be progressed , in order to achieve our goals , and that this is the largest historical task , which the european parliament and the commission must master in the next years . above all however the problem of the financing of the balkans remains existing in the next years in its entirety unresolved . i would like meinerseits the correspondents , which chairmen of the budget committee , which commission , which advice and the presidency express my congratulations for the performed work , for the conclusion of this agreement , which makes us possible the verabschiedung of the budget for the year 2001 . is to be thanked to the correspondents for it . good it is also that as chief work givers additional means were put to the small and central enterprises at the disposal . transferred to the football , one became from a 1: 1 undecided speak . the fact that we could a budget have and us in the mediation procedure unite , does not mean however that all are clarified our problems . this meaning was not given to us simply , but it results from the contracts , although sometimes it falls the advice heavily to recognize . in addition also an obligation of the kollegiums of the commissioners belongs to a fair and effective distribution human and to material resources for the execution of the different politiken , i .e . , which must political priority of the parliament and the management priority of the commission are harmonized . therefore it is the straight task of the common european level to advance the safety device and regeneration of the environment . it is much of post office nice the speech . they are naturally right to refer again and again to this question . neither military force still another possible further advance of the dictatorship are to be still feared today . regarded russia is placed exactly household-moderately with morocco nearly on the same stage or somewhat more highly , and that cannot be correct probably . it would be very dangerous , if the europeans would go into a logistic dependence on russia . and there also a tacis program can intervene only very limited , in order not to say that it can be only one drop on the hot stone . the birth rate sinks , and the mortality rate increases ; the net loss of the total population of russia amounts to annually one million . the solution can be only political nature . mr . putin explained , for hauptproblem is not appropriate in the status of chechnya . which with russia , with which population happens , with the society , that is the west indifferently . mr . praesident ! the european union discharged different russia-referred documents , which form a good basis for close relations with the russian republic in the past years . and which means liberty for the chechnian people? it is the first step , later we toward it will work that laws can be respected , what the second step would be . in addition the economic development stabilizes , and fourth in the result its courses of a civil company will mint themselves . but that is an excellent report , which underlines just like the common strategy , what great importance we the relationship - which strategic partnership - attach between the european union and russia . that means it that we must concentrate on key ranges like the environment addressed by a set of delegates as well as nuclear security , on kaliningrad themselves and a better coordination of the different finanzierungsquellen . we must avoid the error addressed by one of my previous speakers , the at the beginning of the last century were made , when russia was excluded after the leninistic revolution from 1917 practically from the political life of europe , which had devastating consequences . as you know , the advice adopted a common point of view for the change of the guideline 90/220/eec . my judgement can you thus the answer to your still unsettled questions here find . i am quite ready to place me to this debate but best the framework suitable for it must be found . i do not have sufficiently exact information for the answer of your auxiliary question . there he cannot say nevertheless , he has no precise information about it ! the advice reminds the delegate of the conclusions , which it adopted on the occasion of its conference from 19 may 1998 over betrugsdelikte in the alcohol and tobacco sector . all member states affirmed their will to the strengthened fraud fight , both on more internal and on intergovernmental level . the european union affirmed its strict adherence to the right of asylum several times . in june 2000 in cotonou signed akp eec partnerschaftsabkommen plans in this connection that the community makes at the latest to 2005 the duty-free entrance possible for essentially all goods from the ldc . i remind you of the fact that the presidency is not there to express the opinion of individual persons that it does not concern any government , but therefore , which point of view the advice represents x "or" t "at the time" . a system is to be created , in order to buy up and to the producers a remuneration at height of the market price pay these not tested cattle for removal . it was from the outset the request of the french presidency to make a european answer possible to this crisis is affected by the nutrition , society and health . in the context of the process of barcelona algeria signed a set of principles , under it that the right nationalness . i had already some weeks ago the opportunity to submit to you considerations for the preparation of the special meeting of the general assembly of the united nations for the subsequent measures of the world summit conference for the topic of children , which will take place in september 2001 . concerns: obligations of turkey in the context of the partnership european union - turkey in the suggestion of the commission on the partnership european union - turkey it , the advice is called the situation regarding pending law cases will examine , again in particular regarding the effects on the entry process and with the goal of promoting the settlement of these conflicts over the international court of justice to at the latest at the end of of 2004 . does the advice intend to bring this affair in the context of the mentioned partnership in relation to the turkish government to the language? can the rights to defense are granted in appropriate way , and cause the mutual acknowledgment somewhat? beyond that it is thing of the individual member states to meet on national level sovereigns decision over the employment of national troops in the context of such an operation . concerns: meaning of the taxes for functioning the domestic market the president of the european commission novel prodi explained in november in an article of the financial times , it does not wish tax harmonization and common tax levels in the european union , since the control items would have to lie in the hands of the national parliaments and remain also there . 23 to nr . 32 is answered in writing . the stabilization and association agreement between the european union and the republic of croatia come to the correct time . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , loves colleagues and colleagues ! i would like to congratulate first to the colleague baltas very cordially to its report , above all also to its rapid report , because it was important and correct to react rapidly to the changes in croatia - mrs . kollegin stenzel mentioned it - . that is really positive , which is reached at progress there . 1991/92 were driven out over 250 ,000 croats from the kraina , from west and ostslawonien . this was naturally for south-east europe a historical year . i mean , such an annual balance can to be seen be able . that is for us an important point , and i hope that we can count again on the support by the parliament , if we will officially consult you after conclusion of the negotiations to the stabilization and association agreement . the government wahid encounters substantial resistance , and that reform process is obviously in coming to a hold guessed/advised . also papua leaders are still in detention . also in our resolution request we request the european commission to steer this course . thus the explanations in the report of the commission of the beginning of the yearly have fully and completely their authorization , even if them are characterized by certain euphoria , reliably from the changes at that time resulted . the not taking place sentences and as the refugee camps furnished for the eternity are areas of the confrontation between the old and new indonesian powers and certification of the weakness of the democratization process . the situation on the molukken is most concern-exciting , where plenty of rope is given to the dschihad fighters excessively . also irian jaya is a victim of the resettlement politics . we must be capable of setting priorities . we may do ecological , social or politico-economic questions into a pot do not throw with the key problem of the attention of the democracy and the human rights , which represents a political priority in our relationship with indonesia clearly . this resolution states clearly that irian jaya belongs to indonesia . the situation improved , and president wahid earns our support , but there are still enormous problems . it cannot concern naturally that ten thousands are delivered of bandits armed by refugees from osttimor of the grace , who use the patriotismus as pretext , in order to escape a punishment for their criminal past . that is connected with the size of the country , because indonesia stands regarding the total population in fourth place in the world . that is connected with its economic meaning , its regional meaning and its meaning for the environment . therefore we must interconnect the police , administrative and criminal means and instruments both between the member states and with the european union . (the president rules out of order to the speaker . ) before this house repeated it stressed mrs . schreyer , sie here that you see your task as the clerk sarin responsible for the fraud fight in particular in securing the independence from olaf to . the problems result from the introduction of a restaurant administration on european union level , because the models created by the "community in such a way specified" are badly durchdacht and often also completely unwanted for the rearrangement of the tax fundses of the european union citizens . i would congratulate the berichterstatterin , which i admire as a politician and as humans much , gladly to its report , but i cannot do that unfortunately . in the report it concerns around the protection of the financial interests of the community and , how we deal with this topic . those are the most important questions . i will seize myself briefly due to the temporal restriction with the conception of the individual points . the discussion is closed . there is european union width of laws , which are to protect enterprises from such omissions , and which commission has meanwhile promised to introduce own regulations for the guarantee of the immediate vornahme of the payments . we have other mechanisms , in order to make attentive in cases of fraud , not uncovered yet . they , mrs . schreyer , mentioned and said the straight advice that there was a member state , which had opposed the establishment of a european public prosecutor . therefore the parliament behaved very intelligently , if it let the audit office know , what exactly we by these reports to expect . neither the commission nor the member states are to be able themselves to extract from its responsibility , above all not by mutual referring to the responsibility in each case of the different one . he said that completely seriously and regretted this circumstance . it was very more pertinent , and i believed also a very self-confident step of you to include the commission and also the audit office before the elaboration of this report into its consultation . they see mine seeing on remarks that i consider it meaningful to discuss these suggestions further in order , in which way more strongly responsibilities to be designated to be able . the first crucial lack is the missing harmonization . therefore , i believe , must improve we also the article 4 . within this domestic market investors should be in the situation , their vested titles in favor of the enterprises , into which they invest , and in favor of the appropriate enterprises to exercise , whereby it unimportant whether it concerns thereby private people , enterprises or pension funds . we may not lock the eyes before the reality: with an assumption there are restructuring of the staff appointments plan , dismissals . . . , thus measures , which affect her on the jobs . but for what we let us possibly tempt as parliament from the suggested requests for modification? that is the principle , over which the opinions will possibly go apart tomorrow: what does it depend on with a law for the regulation of assumptions in the main? more easily to solve would however be the question of the competence of the supervisory authority . the requests for modification of the correspondent donate confusion regarding potential law cases , and it would be wrong , if we would give our agreement to such an unjustified demand . on which i would like to refer regarding this assumption guideline , that is the close relationship , which between it and millions of voters in my country and millions of citizens exists bound pension and austerity plans also to the stock market . such a procedure already existing in some member states concerns however not only the range of public assumption offers , but has a substantially larger range , and in the context of the general revision of the corporate law intended by the commission possibly further investigations could be accomplished to this question . the moreover one i would like to remind you of the fact that it concerns in accordance with a desire of the european parliament expressed already in former times a framework guideline . follower-genuinly the indispensable and inalienable rights of the educating artists to a portion of proceeds from the far sale of their works represent . on the one hand british lobbyists fears the loss of jobs . the compromise accepted by the advice is thus only a weak poor copy of the original suggestion of the commission , to which in the first reading broad support in the european parliament found . i hope also for the support of the commission , at least in one of the three large contentious points . here it concerns also the vitalitaet and the competitive ability of the european art market . in another case would certainly elsewhere be the work of art , i .e . sold in america . this request for modification is however only partly acceptable . liberalisation of the market for postal services this corresponds to my suggestion , mr . savary . first of all: we must make certain that we obtain favourable prices with the postal services . secondly we must make certain that we a high quality to have and thirdly that we can guarantee a high availability of postal service achievements within all ranges of the european union . the legal committee made higher demands with the price borders of the services reserved for the universal service tenderer , suggests however at the same time also the 150-gramm-gewichtsgrenze and rejects unanimously the 50 gram specified in the guideline suggestion . and finally we cannot accept a new liberalisation date , as long as no previous evaluation was accomplished . they know , how difficult the dossier is , it are ideologically loaded , sometimes from both sides . this step , which is quite welcomed by some members of this house , would have however for the postal services in the european union devastating consequences . in addition this will in the country lead to the locking of post offices , because these cannot survive without the postal services . if we continue in the past speed , we will need 100 years , in order to establish an open market for postal services in europe . mrs . praesidentin , i would like to make three notes . with the discussion over this new guideline we should completely particularly consider one point . that is not like that and may also be . with a fair competition monopolists can prove that they understand their handicraft . but if granny is pleased that a friendly postman comes , which belongs also to a high quality of postal services , then must for us that happy not sad make , but also make . who goes so badly prepared into a negotiation , who the demanded report over the effects since 1997 does not submit , who ideologically argued - exactly we will achieve the goals specified by you only if we liberalisieren , to liberalisieren , liberalisieren - , needs nevertheless not to be surprised , if he falls on the nose ! mr . bolkestein , the commission is the hueterin of the contracts . that is , as if we would determine the average value from the income of a loaded one and begging arms , which is surely satisfying then as number , due to the fact however that there is beg-poor humans at all , in social regard not as acceptable to be regarded can . recent times are started , mr . simpson . the governments , that had caused , were not socialist , but conservative or liberally . me it was from the outset clear that the suggestion of the commission in its original form would be never accepted . because over this opening and this liberalisation we are united , important to us all are meanwhile the speed . the effects of the first guideline were not published , because the consequences were obvious: losses of one's job and degradation of the conditions of work , no even and surface covering supply of postal achievements , in particular on the country and in the worker quarters . so slowly we advance with one of the political topics most important for the completion of the domestic market , the liberalisation of the postal services . this is of crucial importance for the development of the direktmarketingsektors . i appeal directly to the british conservative ones . and turned at post office on , i would like to determine: if this comes through , a valuable breathing space is to you at the disposal . we can only hope that we succeed in a daily to overcome the traditional and defeating the egoistic corps spirit , so that europe really advances . only 3 % of the letter market was already liberalisiert . it will be overhauled by the technical development and ignored by the consumers , if this receive no appropriate achievement for its money . we can support it with this adjustment only if the opening of the market controlled and gradually after a fixed schedule takes place . which concerns the requests for modification 60 and 61 , i support the demand after a completion of the domestic market at a later time , which is to be determined within an appropriate time framework . the commission will take the same point of view , and therefore the advice on the basis of the commission suggestion will make the decision , which meaningful it considers . the parliament must deliver however now a statement . my second report resembles thus in many points first and takes over the requests for modification adopted in the plenum . it is correct , mr . kommissar that we have further some reservations and some differences to continue . mr . praesident , mr . kommissar , ladies and gentlemen ! i would like first the correspondent , so clearly mr . dary , congratulate , us the reform , its history and its connection - which i do not want to repeat - represented . it exists in different special regions of the community , in the regions in extreme peripheral location , which have a set of difficulties , in order to compete on the markets , and one of the few products , which they have , bananas are even . chaotic conditions are avoided by the world trade organization , because in the world trade organization rules are created , to which all involved ones have to adhere . one can say without exaggeration that this question belongs to those , which released largest attention in all institutions . we must contribute unreservedly to living costs of these producers , by buying their products with priority . mr . praesident , the correspondent earns our thanks and our acknowledgment for his report to this difficult topic . likewise i thank the chairmen of the parliamentary groups of this parliament that they accepted the obstinacy and halsstarrigkeit of the delegates from the areas in extreme peripheral location , so that this reform suggestion of the banana sector can be delivered today in this parliament be discussed and the prescribed statement and we become thereby in time in the next days the taking place consultation of the advice of the secretaries of agriculture finished and the year 2001 with a new reform of the gmo for bananas to begin to be able . in this discussion it was stressed several times that the report was unanimously supported by mr . dary by the committee for agriculture and rural development . loves colleagues and colleague ! i have the honour to communicate to you that a delegation of the parliament of korea on the honour grandstand took place . succeeded achieving in the advice a positive decision for media . report (a5-0377/2000) of mr . trakatellis in the name of the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics over the suggestion for a resolution of the european parliament and the advice on the extension of certain schemes of the community within the range of the public health , those with the resolutions nr . 645/96/eec , nr . mr . praesident , i would like to use only the opportunity to point out with reference to the remarks of the commissioner tonight at 00 .15 o'clock that the request for modification nr . 1 the commission into the obligation takes . (the parliament accepts the verbal request for modification . ) request for modification 2: the parliament would have the requests for modification , those in its point of view to persist and the majority of it again to submit be supposed , above all the size of the warning references , the indication of the contents materials as well as the protection of the consumer and in particular the young person concern . there are about two categories of citizens in the eyes of some delegates: those , which one protects , and those , which one exposes for economic reasons to the danger? i would like to describe in particular , why i had rejected the export prohibition for tabakerzeugnisse , whose tar/nicotine content exceeds the maximum value valid in the european union , and had supported the requests for modification for the abolition of this regulation . mrs . praesidentin , i welcomes the radical suggestion to be used as in canada pictures in order to demonstrate the health damage caused by smoking . all consider that i welcome , although i would wish myself - and i would like to affirm that on this occasion - that substantially more is spent on the disease preventing . i would have preferred it , if this regulation were made by a regulation , because this became activities , which concern the citizens of the entire european union , better fairly . the requests for modification of mr . zimmerling the european art market the mortal blow shift and the loss of jobs mean . in addition i fear that only few living artists will profit from this right to a portion of proceeds from the far sale . - (nl) i would like to thank mr . zimmerling for the trouble , which he used on this complicated topic . therefore i see myself forced to be correct against the guideline . and the stabilization and association agreements , the cards program and the european investitionsbank cannot represent the substantial instruments of the contribution of the european union for the economic and social development of croatia . the indonesian government and the army have the obligation to guarantee the security of their citizens and protect their life , independently of to which faith they profess themselves . therefore we must create as fast as possible the necessary instruments for a more effective fight of the fraud with european union means . thus in the european union a uniform right area would be created , determined in that with offences of this kind , which prosecution be introduced , legal proceedings can be carried out be accomplished and the enforcement of the judgements . sometimes this seems to be the case . the requests 11 and 13 aim off to only evaluate the system of the contingents again in 10 years and the commission now not would obligate to suggest a tariff regulation and some our trade partners to demand a tariff regulation . which concerns the consideration reason , which refers to the akp preference , then we agree also here with 300 euro per ton , consider however the word "at the most" unnecessary . such an extension might have also with our trade partners hardly a chance to be accepted . after the agenda the explanation of the commission follows to the summits european union/the usa . that is naturally more easily said than done , but we should resist the temptation to employ us too intensively with these summits with the problems of our daily political and economic relations . i know that larva line albright , which is an american foreign minister , likewise this view . one of the most important theories from it was that the europeans must make a larger contribution for the preservation of security in europe . i would be grateful , if you would take up to for the spring the anvisierte report this point in detail and apart from the analysis , which was demanded by the other side of the house , likewise suggestions would make to all points , as we in the future new goals to be reached can in the range of the dialogues , in the range of co-operation with regard to foreign policy , the security politics , in addition , with these pragmatic topics , like for example mutual recognition agreements . i know and welcome the liberalisation initiative for all goods except weapons , ask however the commission to use with the lining up summit the opportunity and request the usa , this initiative to follow . we must act thus , in order to prevent the irrevocable fate , which waits for those , which must partly endure like mumia abu jamal or leonard pelletier for years in the death cells . that is a meaningful suggestion , which we will gladly take up . thank you , mr . kommissar . i am afraid that i am momentarily in the cross fire of my own parliamentary group . thirdly , simple formulas for the taxation must be used , concretely the reversal the person liable to pay the tax shank . the first conclusion consists of the fact that one can do few , as long as this international framework is not changed . mr . praesident ! the committee would like to state first of all that the valid agreements for the european union offerers of the following services are from disadvantage: software , data processing and computer services , supply of web hosting , web design and news services . one always said to me , one of the first rules and/or principles of the legislator must read as follows: issue no laws , which are not interspersable . fortunately a number of important elements in the report of the responsible committee , among other things owing to the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics , which were supported by meeting several circumstances in the transport committee clearly too little , is . at the same time we must occur however also for a revision of the agreement of chicago of 1944 , in order to reach a re-organization in international area . short term location advantages of the country go debited to another or other european union states . mr . praesident ! europe is to take a prominent position in the world in the area of the internet use in the coming decade . many people ask themselves , mr . kommissar , why the europeans are always so fast with taxes and new regulations with the hand . the agreement of chicago is completely outdated in this point . i regard the introduction of a common value added tax system not as a priority and am also not the opinion that the introduction of a common system is already for a long time overdue . with a delivery ratio of under 30 % obtains the usa budget surpluses of several 100 billion dollar . the option by far which can be preferred is the tax exemption of the european e-enterprises , in order to provide for them the same competitive conditions , as they prevail for the american and other enterprises acting world-wide . the tax competition lies in the interest of the citizens and the economy . so itself the enterprises of outside of the union must , in order to fulfill , for the purpose of the value added tax in a member state of their choice register let the same fiscal obligations as the native enterprises with the contribution of services for the consumers , whereby the vat rate of the selected state is applied to their business . now , completely so the state of affairs is evenly not simple . concerns prepares question source , i .e . place , at which the tax is to apply , and which discussion over the number of the countries , which would come for it into question that the enterprises can be registered there , to my understanding will become quite loading and the usa a complaint with the world trade organization will naturally provoke . it is nevertheless little meaningful that a flight from london to brussels and back z . b . with virgin airways whole 89 £ costs , while i for the euro star , that is many more pleasant far fewer greenhouse gases emitted and with that the journey , for which same distance approximately 250 £ pay must . mr . praesident , in this debate the old fright ghosts show up again . the moreover one the suggestions of the french presidency on the taxation at the place of consumption became , with which obligation of the dienstleister discusses for registration in all member states . the european airlines will would be distorted compared with airlines from third countries disadvantaged and by it the price structure for flights within the european union contrary to the prices for intercontinental flights . however to me a solution , which does not lead to an outflow of capital from europe seems , to be only in the range of the oecd and not punctually with single negotiations possible . i am conscious to me that the members of this house represent every now and then controversy opinions . thus the complexity in the case of the use of macro-economic or comparable criteria is avoided . i come now to the suggestion concerning the minimum standard rate . consequently in the icao working groups still no substantial preparatory work is accomplished , and that on the next meeting a renegotiation of the agreement is already decided of chicago , it is improbable . this feeling unfortunately also today still exists in the european public . and the last goal of this guideline exists in the stabilization of the distress drop management by the obligation for the definition of ports of refuge , by the discharge prohibition during a strong storm and by larger competencies when intervening by the coastal state on lake in the case of a heavy danger of pollution . the oil companies say us , it have a freiwilligen fund . i hope that the doubts became smaller and resistances after the impulse of nice and our project succeeds . of course we trust in it , if it concerns the guarantee of the security on lake , because it certainly white that no week passes , in which us the same question is not placed: "and which undertake their european delegates for the guarantee of security and for the change of the regulations? " mr . praesident , the commission knows on 8 november 2000 of the british government announced plans , which contain the introduction of a special road use fee among other things , for example of a vignette , which is to be paid from british as also by not-british transportation of goods by road enterprises equally , if they drive on the roads in the united kingdom . secondly: if the minister , which he originally intended , suggests , taxing foreign trucks in order kraftverkehrsunternehmen of the own country to subsidize , contradicts this then the european right? this imbalance of economic kind between the deliveries and taxes , which have to pay the kraftverkehrsunternehmen in the individual member states , distorts the conditions , under which kraftverkehrsunternehmen of different nationality stand in the united kingdom in competition . to the question of the use of meat and bone flour: to its export applies exactly the same legislation , which applies also to the production of meat and bone flour in the european union , whereby the demand that z . b . specified risk material from the meat and the bone flour to remove is , is likewise contained in the legislation and starting from 1 march 2001 will enter into force . the jews are traitors and liars . i hope very strongly that we state in each country in this region that the training system carries the tolerance and not the intolerance . the answer of mr . monti i had imagined . nr inquires . 37 of (h-0900/00): besides the commission will suggest a temporary support mechanism , which is meant particularly for meeting the unfair korean practices in the time for protection purposes which is needed up to the conclusion of the world trade organization procedure . this is a topic of full dramatik . the user industry for coke has altogether 70 ,000 persons employed , but this product constitutes into this sector only a very small share of the cost of approximately 2 % . nr inquires . 40 of (h-0889/00): we submitted our suggestion to the akp states practically at the same time as our member states . i can by the way insure you that this initiative does not aim at to regulate this problem since the additional quantities , which could be introduced to the community market , are very small . these countries have due to their situation unfortunately no independent negotiation power , and therefore must we my judgement in this case on one side and without return act . the grant procedure of the commission for the requested financial subsidies shortly locked and also the means needed by ecpat 2001 to cover . we have to do it here with three kinds from activities to . to the location of the future court in the commission suggestion nothing is said . i am not safe me , which the worth mr . abgeordnete means with the word "proliferation" . the inquiry of mr . berenguer fuster concerns trade marks . i regard it as stimulus , in order to undertake new steps and ensure that spain converts also the necessities as immediately as possible . on last request you answered , spain is debt and you that would do , what is incumbent on to do you . this was a good explanation to the answer on my earlier request . the guideline 89/48/eec concerns diplomas for the conclusion of an at least three-year professional training following the secondary school . concerns: traffic facilities in the nordkvark (vaasa , finland - umeå , sweden) the navigation into the strait of the bottni sea bosom (nordkvark) one will adjust as unprofitable , after the shipping companies do not have possibilities for the tax free sales more . for example in the city specified by me vaasa were diminished in the last two years of 550 jobs in particular in the tourism , perhaps straight because of the attitude of the tax free sales . the suggestion reflects the request of the summit of lisbon , because it pursues the goal of supporting the development and use of digital contents . besides i request the commission to develop more efficient and faster execution modalities in the area of the obtainment from suggestions to . if we understand by it only contents useful for enterprises , in particular we may not ignore meteorological and geographical data , which it is naturally extremely desirable that the things become more difficult with contents intended for the citizens , since this beyond the information only useful for enterprises go . digital contents , which are characterised more by quantity than by quality , standardize and limit the cultural and social variety . the second point , which appears just as substantial to me , is that we to the small and middle enterprises that we think of start ups . if we make a virtue , which signs turn simply however from the emergency , our languages not as barriers , but when bridges , when advantages recognize and use , then is that the basis for the european market and a certain independence . i will not deal again with all objectives of the program: creation of favorable conditions for the marketing , spreading and use of european digital contents to improve in order to energize the economic activity , the occupation prospects and to use the potenzial of european digital contents in the comparison to the usa better . thus it becomes ever more importantly to create that for the multilingual production of contents in europe the correct conditions . some these requests are actually very valuable , but in other legal instruments better waived . the different points of view can be now stated to place the tuning do not line up this evening not , and if in opinion of the strongest parliamentary group in the parliament on it were not to be co-ordinated tomorrow , then i held it for by far more correct , with the tomorrow's tuning round , if the members of this house am fully present , such a request instead of doing this this evening . mr . praesident , admired colleagues and colleagues , ladies and gentlemen ! ever more citizen in the european union by noise are troubled . on it , when the evening and when the night begins , the member states can decide freely . therefore i welcome the commission suggestion , see therein however first and my judgement to zoegerlichen step . by therefore it the reduction and preventing environment noise will have to be in the future a substantial part of the european environmental policy . the parliamentary group united european linking supports readily its suggestions , although we would have still somewhat continued to go gladly , in order to find conclusive solutions and proceed against those , which strike money from noise disturbance still . let me however still somewhat to the gezaenk and to lately in the committee behind , apart from , under and over the window blinds and now also controversy led still here say . therefore i would not like to verhehlen that my country will have enormous difficulties to agree the suggestion of the commission it am , he contain a sufficient flexibility mechanism , in order to know the life habits taken over by our ancestors , which by the spaniards themselves as also by our foreign guests to become so estimated , maintained . i recommend the report and naturally also the suggestion of the commission to the house nevertheless . to second we have daughter guidelines regarding the quality standards . my full support applies for the necessity for the harmonization of the noise indices and the evaluation methods , the entire range of the noise maps , the production of plans of action to the appropriate decrease of the noise and the protection of calm areas as well as the extension of the clearance to the information of the public . secondly this suggestion uses a new beginning for the evaluation of the total noise situation in europe , which concerns the number of persons disturbed by the noise . 1 to 3 , 14 , 18 , 27 , 30 , 34 , 35 and 43 accept . the following requests for modification are in principle and/or partly acceptably: nr . besides additives generally may not be used for unmachined food - concerns it in this case - , which did not go through any treatment , which leads to a substanziellen change of its original state . mr . praesident ! in the committee for environmental questions , public health and consumer politics we were correct with the evp parliamentary group for the report lannoye , which corresponds in all other respects fully and completely to our conceptions . nobody says that . after the agenda the discussion follows over the report (a5-372/2000) of mr . staes in the name of the delegation of the european parliament in the mediation committee over the common draft of a guideline of the european parliament and the advice approved of by the mediation committee for the change of the guideline 95/53/eec of the advice with basic rules for the execution of official feed controls . from the french presidency i got therefore an unmistakable sign , a very clear message , which continued to mean "to here and not" . in long negotiations now in the mediation committee a compromise was found , which is acceptable: the warranty that preventive measures , which were met by the commission remain so for a long time in strength , until they are replaced by another resolution , and that the member states obligate itself to grant the experts of the commission an unrestricted support during the investigations and controls locally . i welcome this legislation . the means from the structure funds of the european union , above all the esf , and the means , which make the treasuries available , must be always concentrated on the development of disadvantaged and poorer ranges in our society . the european cities are important economical , political and socio-economic centers . a clear legislation and careful control of their observance are further instruments . the commission is grateful to the european parliament also for the considerable support , which brought it to this suggestion , and for the many requests for modification . considering the character of the measure the commission knows the requests for modification nr . i legend this , because it concerns expressed a topic up-to-date , and it surely agree me that no day passes , at which this topic not for all possible reasons , rightfully or injustice , unkorrekt in the press is however usually discussed . the maximumists wants to block innovation and progress , while the minimalists guesses/advises to fall back only with a substantial danger for health and environment to the precaution principle i .e . above a threshold still which can be specified , how however none knows , how this definition is to take place ! clarifying the respective tasks and competencies is a fundamental condition for the re-establishment of the necessary confidence of the public in the science and also the decision makers - in us , the politicians . in these cases caution for the sake of a safety clearance is left . we required also measures in the world trade organization , perhaps a regulation , which would secure that it is possible in the context for the world trade organization , to other obligations to appoint itself - z . b . the obligations transferred in the context of multilateral environmental protection agreements - , in order to extend the range of application of the precaution principle . important is naturally also to lend to the precaution principle more right stability to embody with the goal , it than international-law standard . the art of the life consists of dealing with these risks and uncertainties considered . sometimes it uses it too much and banalisiert it thereby , then again too few that causes our indignation . that applies approximately to phtalate in kinderspielzeug . we have the remarkable intention , toy in sweets of forbidding ice and other esswaren . the same applies to the demand of the commission after a preceding thorough risk analysis . in the resolution the commission is requested to use their guidelines and to consider the precaution principle during the elaboration of their legislation suggestions and with all their measures whenever this is necessary . a general de-minimis-threshold cannot be determined . by the first assignment of the sakharov price to a human right organization , which leads its fight within the union , the european parliament affirms officially that any injury of these rights must be unconditionally fought . mrs . praesidentin , ladies and gentlemen abgeordneten ! above all the citizens' initiative "basta would like to express ya" this parliament their thanks for the honorable acknowledgment , which us today assign becomes . and murders are not only committed . i ask thus to follow me here and trust . (the parliament accepts the legislation resolution . ) mrs . praesidentin , if the high house permits it me , i would like to deliver a verbal clarifying to my amendment 51 . report (a5-0334/2000) of mr . garcía garcía-margallo y marfil in the name of the committee for economics and currency over the report of the commission: taxation of aviation fuel (kom (2000) 110 - c5-0207/2000 - 2000/2114 (cos)) the present agreement is attractive for certain enterprises , the environment and the democracy is however detrimental it . the most outstanding event since our last budgetary debates is naturally the bse crisis . that would offend clearly against the letter and the spirit of the above-mentioned resolutions of the state and heads of the government in the seat question . the parliament could successfully specify a number of important priorities - among other things an intensified employment for the fight against unemployment and poverty , a number of important environmental and equalization questions etc . . we were correct against the attacks of the civil side on the life program and on the european women ' s lobby . the range of the means planned for the kosovo raises however the legitimate question , to what extent this region of yugoslavia can actually take up for originally 2001 the planned 350 million euro . there is no cause to grant a certain distribution form of tax benefits . a final date gives clear signals to the participants on the post office market and the national monopolies the possibility of preparing better for a deregulierung . can a whole philosophy of the postal service , which can be explained from the characteristics of each state and there their roots has , with a simple , possibly only resolution seized with a very small majority be rubbed out? the borders of 50 gram with a price border at height of the two-and-one-half times one of the public tariff , suggested by the commission , are really too drastic and devastating effects on the offerers of universal postal services would have had . therefore we point the whole of the requests , which it aims at , clearly and decided back . . (sports association) we are not the view that the european union should concern itself with the problem of the post office sector , even if the suggestion is importantly better after the treatment in the committee than the original commission suggestion . report dary (a5-0374/2000) however after our view the small producers , which work on their planting must , without exploiting someone , before which consequences of the economic war are protected and their income independently of the market fluctuations are ensured . since the practice of the right brings according to the article 10 obligations and responsibility to the free expression of opinion with itself , it can be subjected conditions , restrictions or punishing threats . considering the fact that numeric contents constitute related to value 5 % european gros domestic product and 4 million jobs , one can only welcome such an initiative . under these conditions the usa have to owe their supremacy on this future market straight of their coherency and their unit . i hope also that this authority distribution goes with application of the subsidiaritaetskriteriums so far that the regions and the autonomous communities know their status within the union maintained . about it we are pleased . thus for example with the commercial negotiations specified above the national parliaments of their last rights to ratification are robbed , and a country , which is in the advice in the minority , cannot say no more no , if it sees interests hurt in the negotiations its . before it we repeated warned , and the expiration in nice shows in all clarity that perhaps a substantially more extensive would have led agenda to it that in this year at all no results would have been reached , with catastrophic consequences for the extension . . (en) considering the fundamental meaning of the resolutions , which it applied to meet on the summit in nice , acknowledgment must be gezollt also , where acknowledgment is to be zollen . differently said , the intention of the parliament consists of attaining control of the questions of the taxation and social security . these resolutions of the advice knitted in long night hours do not offer a solid stop ; they have thick holes , by which terms fall through such as transparency , identity donation , more democracy , participation of the citizens or reform consciousness smoothly . therefore we must regard its conclusions as result of a compromise , with which there is neither clear winners nor clearly being subject . in the opposite , the influence of the national democracies decreases , because the right of veto is continued to limit and the european parliament receives more power . therefore you must for this report , in accordance with whose condition the taxation will be further only possible limited by aviation fuel , are correct , because thereby the flugtickets for us become ever cheaper and we thus more with this means of transport to travel to be able . "" run not under the houses along , you could fall a flower pot on the head . the complexity and the versatility of the technological change and the structural change processes require compellingly the inclusion of all partners of the local and regional level into the development partnerships , embedded into the development of strategic concepts of the regional policy for each region . therefore we must be endeavored to avoid everything what could suffocate and/or impair these three important conditions . one could say that the innovation for all participants of the production process lies in the range of the possibilities . the gap between wealthy and backward areas in the technological development is substantially larger than with the gross domestic product . as main argument the buerokraten makes , it as well known valid exists the danger of errors . i do not know whether it was a direct consequence of this risi initiative that today three ladies signed the european budget , but i would be pleased , if this weihnachtspraesent , which we decide , would benefit also in the future the women . it is also an error , the household in a chapter as to be reduced this , which for pilot projects , for new ideas in the local and urban development - with more than acceptable results - on the basis of on local level as popular community programs as urban and inter+move was intended . as mr . rack expressed very well , i had this regional policy and this coherence politics never as a kind alms in relation to the poorest regions understood and will never understand it as such . for this reason respected i in the present negotiations over the eppd , apart from the innovative actions - i speak thereby of the mainstream - for it that each program planning document contains a regional plan for the entrance to the information society , and examines the quality , apart from the range of this regional program , above all which directly the kmu , which concerns educational facilities and even the agrarian enterprises . mrs . schroedter , mr . izquierdo collado and mr . ortuondo larrea addressed this question of the central equipment rightfully . the prices for ship new buildings sank in the last years drastically and 1999 due to this politics of south korea their tiefpunkt reached . the committee had to co-ordinate specially , in order to secure that this point stands on the agenda for the today's discussion . this concept in all other respects stands in conformity with the contract . my time is not sufficient , in order to deal in the detail with it . nevertheless we hold the suggestion of the commission , which an aid for research and development , the complaint before the world trade organization over practice in korea - one works there there with prices , still under the costs are - , and the possibility of transition aids , as long as on the complaint is not decided , nevertheless contains , for a perhaps more or less weak way out , but for a way out . at the same time korea , if possible in the context of the oecd , must be pressurized by antidumping measures strengthened . that is , we suffer the other rule from unemployment and make the real business with the shipyards . in my opinion it gives a outstanding analysis of the shipbuilding sector in europe , which corresponds to the reality . this process will produce and should no fast results , all stages be gone through , then this lasts up to two years . the mechanisms would be brought in application , until in this world trade organization procedure a decision falls . i am sure that we feel united now all , in order to defend the liberty in europe with strength and reproduction , but i would like to say that we need their commitment in spain over the solidarity of the colleagues in the european parliament outside . it swam in may in waters the siziliens , when its nuclear heart delivered disturbing signs of a damage . it would be alarming , if we would not act in view of this situation as fast as possible . in both wise we on the necessity that the two member states concerned , great britain and spain , in close co-operation look for the most reliable solution for the repair of the submarine and hold - naturally - the public up to date . we have statements of responsible persons of the british war fleet belong , after whom the average is not serious , and other one , which is substantial exactly the opposite mentioned and after those the damage and make lengthy , complicated repairs necessary . the house it is well-known that she would be here , if this had been possible , so that the task is given to me now to answer in its place . the commission is about to analyze this plan . it happens already , talks we thus with consideration of the true state of affairs about it , which possibilities have the authorities of the united kingdom and gibraltar , in order with the problem to become finished . calm co-operation is the method used by our union . the british government acts just as as recently the russian government , when it came on one of its submarines to an average . mr . praesident ! also i would like to state our spanish colleagues in view of the recent attempted assassination of terror of the eta my deep condolence . the commission was so responsible in its clear answer of two months ago ago and in their current reaction to grant this although the draft resolution of the parliamentary group of the people's party did not recognize this , what us beside further minimizing of the affair prevented to give our agreement . chief minister peter caruana did the correct , when he instructed the group of experts to refund to him directly report . this is and remains in for our opinion the most coherent point of view , which protects the interests and the security of all sides concerned best . b5-0908/2000 of the delegates maij weggen and pos elt in the name of the ppe de parliamentary group ; 1980 by the unhcr 5 million refugees were cared for . today we appreciate the unhcr and all humanitarian coworkers . mr . praesident ! the commission would like itself the support , those the unhcr on the occasion of 50 . anniversary his establishment of the parliament assign , naturally will attach . i would like to speak on a general problem come and refer thereby to the remarks of a delegate . b5-0909/2000 of mrs . pack and other delegate in the name of the ppe de parliamentary group ; and the last problem , which i would like to address , are the terrible events at the border between serbia and kosovo . there milosevic belongs and not on party congresses in belgrade . our judgement is necessary also in the kosovo a going by reorientation that the groups of peoples respect each other , instead of fighting each other further mutually . without wanting to sing to us a praise song , we can also say that the european union reacted very fast to the new situation . b5-0915/2000 of mr . medina ortega and other delegate in the name of the pse parliamentary group ; b5-0918/2000 of mrs . napoletano and other delegate in the name of the pse parliamentary group ; the chilean government assured that general pinochet in chile would receive a fair procedure , and actually general pinochet its immunity lost now , and the judicial authorities to have a procedure against it introduced . and you permit me to remind of it that it is important , this common resolution now , since pinochet in chile is , to assume , what did not succeed to us , when he was in great britain . i legend this in the knowledge around the fact that these are the fundamental convictions of the parties of the free european alliance and the greens in this house . mr . praesident ! before i begin with my speech contribution , also i want to follow the condemnation of the assassination attempt , a selected representative of the people , member and a local council of the people's party in katalonien , in spain , which cost lives . from this reason are pleased i me that my parliamentary group and - as i believe - which does not let itself be tempted majority of our parliament to agitate the drums in order the present crisis to use . their life is in highest danger . the league for human rights closed , their premises sealed and its president , moktar trifi , is , like it just have heard , for 25 december before court loaded . human right activists , union members , university graduates , journalists and students report on constant chicaneries on the part of the authorities . its condition is very , very serious . daily chicaneries and the zusammenschlagen of democrats are really the rule . i hope that the chilean law system in this thing will prove further its independence and effectiveness . as we know , the mission bosses of the european union pursue the political situation in the country very exactly . to the conclusion i would like to mention the important role of the european parliament , which contributes by attendance of parliamentarians and public discussions like the today's to the sensitization of the public and to the reinforcement of the dialogue to these questions . laurent gbagbo must operate a genuine policy of the national reconciliation , by the term of the ivoritaet banished , which racistic condition changes and accomplishes democratic elections , with which a candidate not being excluded , since otherwise the danger of the secession and the civil war still increases . mr . praesident ! for months the messages of the ivory coast caused a justified unrest in the european public and appropriate concern in our parliament . conditions for the fact are that nobody feels impossible that of military the used highest court is abolished , the head of state clearly into the process of the re-establishment of the democracy brings in itself and the statements of the committee for the national reconciliation is belonged . me the concept of the ivoritaet seems to be perfectly justified . now about a half dozen of copies of it is available with the president . mr . praesident , in the name of the greens we withdraw our resolution request likewise . mr . praesident , i follows the words of mr . posselt . (minutes are approved . ) the member states do not have to carry out for older humans new political concepts and both the problem of the necessary support and the question of the kostendeckung anpacken , which applies in particular to the handicapped ones , their families really in the situation are to carry the associated loads fully and completely alone . mr . praesident ! it is to be congratulated to me a special joy , the berichterstatterin in the name of the parliamentary group of the greens/free one european alliance to the excellent report . owing to better medical supply , information , care , better housing conditions and pension regulations live nowadays ever more humans longer . there is above all the governments of member states , the administrations of partial states , provinces and municipalities , which can begin something with many recommendations . the foundation-stone for this living standard is put in the family , in which each humans grow up as a child . very frequently it happens that one in the last years of its life very seriously ill and completely helplessly and the assistance of all needs . finally i would like to say still something to the medical supply . there one also said , women must away from the working life , so that the men have work . at first sight many could understand this as disadvantage . we will for this already have to find means and ways . the countless active old persons should motivate us all to argue for a society in which the solidarity between the generations is not a cliche ! these measures must be adapted then to the respective special situations and characteristics regarding the quality of life and financial independence . only common constant efforts can help us . there must be a scope for discretion for individual preferences and decisions . if someone regains the articles , which were misplaced our colleague , then it is to return them please , above all the eyeglasses , because mrs . flemming was behind you , mr . fatuzzo . finally the possibilities must be taken up by measures for areas in extreme peripheral location and their logo again expressly to the text . to refer in addition is on the kind-fair and pollution free production method in europe . therefore it makes happy me also that we furnished this week in the european parliament a working group for biotechnology . naturally these institutional information campaigns should only supplement the co-ordinated advertising measures particularly on the part of the large supermarket chains . if the suggestions of the parliament were converted , those three times with majority went through here - again the powerlessness of the parliament shows up however there - that the deactivation surfaces with leguminosen , with clover be cultivated could and the feed would be permitted , then we more basic fodder , more protein fodder would have had . this is incumbent on nevertheless probably manufacturers , salesmen and occupation organizations and not the european union . we must place ourselves the question , to use why we it in the past to have missed to arrange the industry in the european union the disposable money . naturally , if we can produce and promote food , which for the environment is better , which and which consider the animal health on the world market also still well sell themselves , then really fulfills we the requirement , with which the common agricultural policy had begun . to the requests for modification 9 and 22 , in which the mechanism of a special administrative committee is demanded , as well as to the requests for modification 7 , 19 , 23 and 27 , where further changes of process are demanded , it is to be said that the commission must adhere to coherent rules of procedure . everything those , which point out that one can to be able to be still tasted it in europe , are right . mr . praesident , it is scientifically proven that a moderate wine consumption is the best vorbeugung against cancer , cardiac infarcts or alzheimer , and i could enumerate still many further diseases . i would like to express the correspondent for its work my praise .